HIGH-PERFORMANCE SOUND & VISION
B&W 700 Series
Hitachi 75in TV
NADT777V3
Atmos receiver
LG UP970 4K
Blu-ray player
Denon X8500H
AV amplifier
EXTREME EXCELLENCE
Sony’s XF9005 TV promises premium
4K HDR pictures - and delivers!
Bigscreen
bargain
Vivitek aims
high with
HK2288 PJ
Form a Q
Is Samsung’s
65in Q9F an
OLED killer?
°483S?
vivitek 4c
m SURROUND
RECEIVER
BIG IN 2018!
FILM & TV M
STAR WARS: THE LAST JEDI
JUSTICE LEAGUE ■ FAR CRY 5
OUTLANDER BRITANNIA
1JHE SHAPE OF WATER W
The best of this
^year’s Summer
^Ibckbusters, p21
Inside buyer’s guide -» reader’s system -> kef reference in-wall
COLLECTING... BEST PICTURE WINNERS -» PRO CINEMA INSTALL ♦ B&O OLED
www.homecinemachoice.com
M 1 ISSUE 285 MAY 2018 £4.99
AUS- $13.50 NZ- $14.99 CAN- $17.00
05
9 "771359 6271
OLED
The best OLED TV
you can buy
Philips OLED TV.
Looks better.
EISA
★
★
AWARD*'
* *
* *
★ 1 . ★
Best
Product
2017-2018
® ovforums
RECOMMENDED
HOMEi
CINEMA
Choice
HIGHLY
RECOMMENDED
AWARD 2017
Philips 55POS9002 1
BESTBUY
P cketlint
RECOMMENDED 2017
E
BEST BUY OLED TV
Philips 55POS9002
www.philips.com/oled
PHILIPS
OPINION
HOME
CINEMA
Choice
www.homecinemachoice.com
EDITORIAL TEAM
Editor Mark Craven
mark.craven@homecinemachoice.com
Deputy Editor Anton van Beek
anton.vanbeek@homecinemachoice.com
Art Editor John Rook
CONTRIBUTORS
Steve May, John Archer, Tekura Maeva, Jon Thompson,
Ed Selley, Rik Henderson, Richard Stevenson, Vincent Teoh,
David Vivian
Photography Mike Prior
ADVERTISING
Advertising Sales Executives
Sonia Smart
E-mail: sonia.smart@hifinews.com
Mob: 07972117331
Richard Morris
Mob: 07834 346461
E-mail: richard.morris@homecinemachoice.com
MARKETING AND SUBSCRIPTIONS
UK: New, Renewals and Enquiries
Tel: 0344 243 9023
E-mail: help@hcc.secureorder.co.uk
USA & CANADA:
Toll Free: 001 866 647 9191
REST OF WORLD: New, Renewals and Enquiries
Tel: +44(0)1604 828 748
BACK ISSUES
www.mags-uk.com
MANAGEMENTTEAM
Group Editor Paul Miller, paul.miller@avtechmedia.co.uk
Group Sales Manager Sonia Smart
Subscriptions Manager Kate Hall
Chief Executive Owen Davies
Published by AVTech Media Ltd
Suite 25, Eden House, Enterprise Way
Edenbridge, Kent, TN8 6HF
Tel: 0844 412 2262
From outside the UK: +44 (0) 1689 869 840
Distributed in the UK by Marketforce UK Ltd
BACKGROUND WALL IMAGES:
©SHUTTERSTOCK.COM
©iSTOCKPHOTO.COM
Home Cinema Choice, ISSN 1359-6276, is published monthly with an additional
issue in May by AVTech Media Ltd, a division of MYTIMEMEDIA Ltd, Suite 25,
1 Eden House, Enterprise Way, Edenbridge, Kent, TN8 6HF, UK. The US annual
subscription price is 68GBP (equivalent to approximately 98USD). Airfreight
and mailing in the USA by agent named Air Business Ltd, c/o Worldnet Shipping
I Inc., 156-15,146th Avenue, 2nd Floor, Jamaica, NY 11434, USA Periodicals post-
I age paid at Jamaica NY 11431. US Postmaster: Send address changes to Home
Cinema Choice, Worldnet Shipping Inc., 156-15,146th Avenue, 2nd Floor, Jamaica,
NY 11434, USA. Subscription records are maintained at CDS GLOBAL Ltd, Tower House, Sovereign
Park, Market Harborough, Leicester, LE16 9EF. Air Business Ltd is acting as our mailing agent.
recycle
When you have finished with
this magazine please recycle it.
If you can’t always find a copy of
this magazine, help is at hand!
Complete this form and hand in at
your local store, they’ll arrange for
a copy of each issue to be reserved
for you. Some stores may even
be able to arrange for it to be
delivered to your home.
Just ask!
NEXT ISSUE ON SALE: May 17,2018
Welcome
How many speakers does your home cinema setup
have? I'm sure if I'd asked that question a decade ago
the answer would have most likely been 'five', or
maybe 'seven'. Fast-forward to 2018 and we're
auditioning a Denon AV amplifier (see page 52) that suggests
you might want to pepper your listening room with 13 speakers.
I can see the attraction. The Dolby Atmos and DTS:X
formats have opened a new world of immersive
surround sound, where additional speakers can be put to
good use to cocoon you in a thrilling aural bubble.
But I also love 'vanilla' 5.1 audio, and this issue's 700 Series
system from Bowers & Wilkins (see page 48) is a fine example
of such a soundscape writ large. And deep. And detailed. And
rich. It's not a budget package by any stretch, nor designed for a
'regular' living space, but is proof that you don't always need
more of everything...
Editor
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
ISSUE 285 MAY 2018
MENU
CONTRIBUTORS
a John Archer:
The experienced
TV tester cut his
teeth as an early
HCC staffer
Jon Thompson:
Film producer and
post-production
expert delves into
Hollywood and AV
Steve May:
HCC’s former Ed.
is one of the UK’s
most respected
AV journos
Martin Pipe:
Technical expert
Martin is renown
throughout the
industry
Richard
Stevenson:
Former Editor of
the UK CE trade
journal ERT
Ed Selley:
Audiophile Ed
mixes his home
cinema passion
with a love of vinyl
Vincent Teoh:
Professional video
calibrator writes
about technology
and tweaking
FEATURES
In-depth interviews and special reports.
Starts... p21
COVER STORY
21 Summer lovin'
From superheroes to giant sharks, meet this
year's must-see blockbuster movies
28 Poetry in motion
Everything you need to know about your
TV's frame interpolation tech
34 Room reborn
Careful planning ensures this movie room
gets the best out of its state-of-the-art kit
86 Certified: AV-Holic
Another HCC reader shows off their system
SEIECT
The place to look if you’re planning to buy
some new AV gear. Starts... pill
in Gear guide
HCC's comprehensive Top 10s list
only the very best kit money can buy
BUllETIH
The place for hot products, trends
and technology. Starts... p7
07 For your Reference
KEF's high-end in-wall speaker breaks free
08 B&O goes back to nature
OLED flatscreen gets a style revamp
09 Sky relaunches VR app
David Attenborough fronts ambitious project
io Samsung targets cinema
World's first Cinema LED screen debuts
12 A super day out for fans
Exhibition explores DC's iconic superheroes
14 The show must go on...
The Greatest Showman sings on 4K Blu-ray
16 Back of the'net
Trailers and tech to check out on the web
18 Sony tunes 4K HDR in 2018
Japanese giant reveals the calibration secrets
behind its latest flatscreen lineup
RE6UIARS
Whether you want our opinions or your
own, here’s where to look. Starts... p75
75 Digital Copy
Mark Craven would still rather shop with his
eyes and ears than a mouse and keyboard
76 Film Fanatic
When did it all go wrong for the Oscars?
78 In the Mix
Jon Thompson wonders if HDR is already
bringing about the end of OLED
82Feedback
Share your thoughts with other AV addicts
122 AV Avenger
Steve May celebrates an initiative to stop
mobile phone use in cinemas
COHPETITIORS
85 Great Blu-rays to be won!
Buck Rogers, Nightmares, Amazon Women on
the Moon, Rawhead Rex and Molly's Game!
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
SUBSCR Sign up to the world’s best
to save money and never miss
KWfK
40
'Sony's panel
exhibits ful
detail in all
lg mod
With a focus on performance, these are in-depth tests you can trust... p39
The latest Blu-rays, DVDs and videogames
reviewed and rated. Starts... p91
COVERSTORY
40 Sony KD-55XF9005
Direct-lit 4K HDR LED flatscreen delivers on its
promise of premium picture quality
44 NAD T 777 V3
Seven-channel Dirac EQ AV receiver with
a lean, mean sound
48 Bowers & Wilkins 700 Series 5.1
Heavy-hitting speaker array doesn't hold back
when it comes to delivering the goods
52 Denon AVC-X8500H
Feature-packed AV amp cranks immersive
audio up to 11 (well, 13 actually...)
COVER STORY
56VivitekHK2288
Projector brand shakes up the 4K HDR market
with this mid-priced marvel
COVERSTORY
60 Samsung QE65Q9FN
Range-topping 4K flatscreen reminds us just
how good LED TVs can be
64 LGUP970
Bargain-priced Ultra HD Blu-ray player gets
a long overdue Dolby Vision upgrade
65 Hitachi 75HL16T64U
This 4K HDR TV offers a monster 75in image
for not a lot of money
66 Cello C32277T2
Is this battery-powered 32in 720p set the
ideal camping accessory for AV-hedz?
66 Airpulse Audio A200
Tired of the familiar wireless suspects? Try
these studio-style active speakers instead
72 Long-term test:
Focal Sib Evo Dolby Atmos 5.1.2
Compact speaker system still offers an ideal
Atmos upgrade route for sub/sat owners
The Shape of Water [4K]
Three Billboards... [4K]; The Snowman,
Ferdinand; Pitch Perfect 3
Star Wars: The Last Jedi [4K]
Far Cry 5; Britannia: Season 1; Outlander:
Season 3; Amazon Women on the Moon
Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle
Earth: One Amazing Day [4K]; Heimat;
The Awful Truth; Otley; Breathless
^ Justice League [4K]
Buck Rogers in the 25th Century: The
Complete Series; The Beast from 20,000
Fathoms; Damnation Alley; The Valley of
Gwangi; Murder on the Orient Express [4K]
W Lara Croft: Tomb Raider - 2-Movie
Collection [4K]
H Jarman: Volume One 1972-1986; The
Avengers: Tunnel of Fear; JoJo's Bizarre
Adventure: Season 1; Blood Harvest;
[ Slaughterhouse Rock
0 Blade of the Immortal; Legend of the
Mountain; One-Armed Swordsman;
The Final Master
106^ Best Picture winners
We round up 20 of the best films to win
the top prize at the Academy Awards
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
EISA \
EUROPEAN IMAGING AND *
SOUND ASSOCIATION
The
* *
* *
** **
* * * * *
GLOBAL
HOME THEATRE AUDIO
The European Imaging and Sound Association is the unique collaboration of 55 member
magazines and websites from 25 countries, specialising in all aspects of consumer electronics
from mobile devices, home theatre display and audio products, photography, hi-fi and in-car
entertainment. Now truly international with members in Australia and the USA, and still growing,
the EISA Awards and official logo are your guide to the best in global tech!
TECHNOLOGY
mvvmRDS
Celebrating the best life-enhancing,
— I
:= i _
TESTED BY THE EXPERTS ■ WWW.EISA.EU
WWW.HOMECINEMACHOICE.COM
BULLETIH
-►News HIGHLIGHTS OPTOMA Budget beamer targets 1080p cinephiies
B&O OLED TV gets a retro revamp DC HEROES Comic book king takes up London residence
SKY Sir David Attenborough boosts VR plans WEBWATCH Trailers and tech NEWS X10 AV stories
in bite-sized chunks THE GREATEST SHOWMAN Plan your Blu-ray singalong & MORE!
For your Reference
KEF Ci5160REF-THX«» www.kef.com
The G5160REF-THX mounts
to a depth of 99mm
KEF has added an in-wall speaker to its Reference
range, featuring drivers especially designed for its
flush-fit form factor. Dubbed the Q5160REF-THX
(and THX Ultra certified), the metre-long speaker
uses a quartet of 6.25in woofers and a single Uni-Q
unit, fed by 'high-grade' crossover networks claiming
a smooth response with minimal distortion. Priced at
£7,500, each model comes with a certificate signed
by the audio craftsman who built it - order one now
and it'll be ready in a couple of weeks...
The grille is a style match for the rest
of KEF's Ci speaker lineup
HCC ONLINE...
For breaking AV news, blogs, features and
reviews visit
Follow us on Twitter
Like us on Facebook
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
9 B&O BEOVISION ECLIPSE/SKY VR
Bang & Olufsen claims its latest
designer OLED 'brings a totally unique
dimension to the television landscape 1 by matching
its slim bezel aesthetic with a handmade oak
speaker panel - retro-fashionistas will need to
find £8,200 for the 55in set, £11,500 for the 65in
version, or £900 to add the wood trim to an existing
BeoVision Eclipse TV. As with earlier models, the
4K screen (plus WebOS smarts and Dolby Vision-
capable image processing) come via LG.
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
Elipson plays the music
I Elipson is shipping
the latest edition
of its Music Centre
- dubbed the Black
Edition - with
a Chromecast
Audio dongle to complement its aptX
Bluetooth streaming feature and physical
analogue and digital inputs. This black
satin-finished cylindrical system hub also
integrates a 2 x 120W ICE power amplifier
stage to drive partnering speakers (plus a
subwoofer output with adjustable low-pass
filter), and a CD player and DAB/FM tuner.
Pricing is around £900.
www.elipson.com/en
Put a projector in your pocket
Weighing just 750g
and measuring 18cm
wide, Vivitek's Qumi
038 claims to offer
'the largest projection
display size yet in
1080p resolution 1 for a projector of its size
- namely an image that can hit 130in from
a 3.5m throw - plus an LED lamp-life
rating of 30,000 hours. Available for around
£600, this pocket PJ features a single HDMI
input, dual USB ports, and wireless hookup
to mirror smart devices and PCs/Macs.
On-the-go use is aided by an onboard
two-hour-rated battery.
www.vivitek.eu
ourm
Sky relaunches VR app
Sir David Attenborough enlisted for a virtual night at the museum
Sky is rebooting its VR app this Spring and has
enlisted Sir David Attenborough for its most
ambitious project yet. Hold The World, produced
in partnership with the Natural History Museum,
invites VR viewers to take a closer look at some of
the museum's most popular exhibits, including a
blue whale, stegosaurus, trilobite and pterosaur,
with Sir David as their personal guide.
Sky CEO Stephen van Rooyen says the project
puts his company at the 'leading edge' of VR
technologies. 'This is a brand-new experience.'
Once users enter the VR museum, they can
choose a route to the Conservation Centre, the Earth
Sciences Library or the Cryptogamic Herbarium.
In each Sir David is on hand to relate in-depth info.
Once a full examination has taken place, the object
'comes to life.' The average VR experience typically
lasts between 20 minutes and an hour.
HCC tried the
VR experience on
Oculus Rift, and
enjoyed both the
resolution of the
image, and the
level of interaction offered. You can expand or
contract objects virtually in size, spinning them
around for a detailed look in ways that are simply
not possible in the real world.
For the experience, developers Factory 42 created
a photorealistic 'behind-the-scenes' in which VR
users can venture deep into the museum to discover
exhibits. The museum's CT scanning department
was responsible for creating the scientifically
accurate models and animation.
The virtual Attenborough, meanwhile, was
created at Microsoft HQ and required more than
100 cameras to photograph him from every angle.
Hair is a problem for volumetric capture, he reveals.
'I had to spray down every wisp, else there would
have been a hole in my head.'
Attenborough has long pioneered new broadcast
technologies, from introducing colour TV as controller
of BBC2 and pioneering programme content in HD,
3D and 4K.
VR for VIPs
Hold the World is Sky VR Studio's first fully-
interactive production and will be available to Sky
customers when the Sky VR app is relaunched as
part of the broadcaster's new Sky VIP customer
loyalty programme. The experience will be available
on Oculus Rift, Samsung Gear VR and Google
Daydream, but not PlayStation VR.
Sky says it will follow with new VR content on
a monthly basis across different genres. Upcoming
experiences will focus heavily on sport, including
football action and a ringside encounter featuring
Anthony Joshua. There will also be a VR behind-the-
scenes special for Britannia (see p96), and a fully
narrative VR episode of Italian drama Gomorrah,
written especially for the technology.
Attenborough has pioneered HD, 3D, 4K and now VR
BULLETIN 9
Playful biopic dealing with the
unconventional love life of the
man who created Wonder Woman.
Goodbye Christopher
Robin (All-region BD)
(R2DVD)
Dogs
(Region BBD)
The UK Blu-ray debut of this
enjoyably silly 1976 revenge-of-
nature flick is thankfully no dog...
Matt Schrader's documentary
charts the development of the
modern movie score over the
decades. Fascinating stuff.
Professor Marston and
the Wonder Women
(R2DVD)
A tough watch made all the more
bearable by the superb 1080p
encode it receives on Blu-ray.
Team HCC spins up its disc
picks of the month
Thor: Ragnarok
(Ultra HD Blu-ray)
While we may have some
concerns regarding the
Atmos mix, there's still
plenty to savour about
this visually spectacular
and extremely funny
Marvel sequel in 4K.
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
10 SAMSUNG CINEMA LED/BENQ TK800
Heading out to see a flick?
Catch these this month
Avengers: Infinity War
April 26: A decade of Marvel
Studios movies has been leading
to this: the biggest and most
spectacular superhero film ever
made. Turn to p22 to find out why
we're so excited...
The Strangers:
Prey at Night
May 04: Mad Men's Christina
Hendricks stars in (and Johannes
Roberts directs) this belated
sequel to the 2008 home invasion
horror flick, which finds the
masked maniacs stalking a family
at a secluded trailer park.
How to Talk to Girls
at Parties
May 11: Elle Fanning, Alex Sharp
and Nicole Kidman appear in this
sci-fi comedy (based on a Neil
Gaiman short story) about an
alien visitor who learns about
teenage love during a visit to
London in the 1970s.
sihrcfly svl
l2 Difi2 Dia
Samsung targets cinema
Mega LED screen debuts in Switzerland, put!'projector out of a job
A cinema in Zurich has become the first in the
world to officially install a Samsung Cinema LED
screen, news that has the Korean corp boldly
claiming: 'The movie screen and traditional
projection technology are a thing of the past.'
Samsung's next-gen cinema display features
24million LEDs, using a modular construction to fill
an area measuring 10.2m wide and 5.4m high.
While in essence a giant TV, it's certified by the
DCI (Digital Cinema Initiative) and delivers a 4,096 x
2,160 4K resolution.
Exit light
The benefits of this projector-less approach are
numerous, believes Samsung. An absence of light
reflections enables 'pitch dark 1 theatres, in addition
to 'true' blacks on screen. Switching between aspect
ratios is achievable without masking technologies.
Cinema LED also delivers 'unprecedented
colour brilliance, luminosity and sharpness,' says
the company. The screen's extreme contrast
makes it a suitable partner for HDR, with its LED
illumination delivering a brightness of 146fL
(approximately 500 nits), around 10 times that
of a conventional projector-based theatre.
3D playback is also on tap.
The screen is also designed for 24/7 operation
and prepared for 'secondary uses', says
Samsung, allowing cinema owners to explore
new revenue models.
Another benefit of removing a projector from
a cinema is the scope to rethink interior design,
now that there's no pesky light beam to contend
with. 'We have removed the complete furnishings,
implemented an innovative seating concept and
consequently are providing the audience with the
ultimate cinematic experience,' says Edi Stockli,
owner of Zurich's Arena Cinemas Sihlcity where the
screen has been put into action. (If you find yourself
nearby and fancy checking it out, book a ticket for
Screen 5).
Partnering the Cinema LED screen is JBL's new
Sculpted Surround system, which aims to deliver
a greater sweetspot. JBL, a division of Harman,
is now owned by Samsung.
Says Daniel Perisset, Samsung Electronics
Switzerland: '[We] always try to go the hilt and
advance technological progress to make life easier
for people and enrich their lives. We have once again
succeeded in doing this with the new Cinema LED
Screen. We're already looking forward to the use
of the screens in other movie theatres.'
Cutting the cost of 4K projection
BenQ's TK800 beamer goes on sale at a wallet-friendly £1,200
The arrival of Texas Instruments' 4K DLP solution
was always tipped to dramatically lower the
entry price of UHD home cinema projection.
BenQ's TK800, available now for £1,200, is proof
that such claims weren't wide of the mark.
Compact at 35cm wide and given a funky blue
face plate, this affordable 4K DLP PJ is very much
designed for use in everyday living rooms. A 3,000
Lumens brightness rating, suggests BenQ, makes
it ideal for sports viewing in well-lit environments
- and there's even a Football Mode viewing preset.
The projector's 1.2x optical zoom leads to a
fairly short 1.47-1.76:1 throw ratio, with a lOOin
a 12V trigger, twin HDMIs
(one compatible with 4K
HDR sources) and audio
in/outs tied to the unit's
CinemaMaster Audio+ 2
in-built speaker system.
www.benq.co.uk
image possible from a distance of
3.25m. Automatic keystone correction
is supplied to align bigscreen
images, in place of vertical
lens-shift functionality.
Connections include
The TK800 is BenQ's most affordable
4K projector yet
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
TM
v_i_i r
A' MEMBER
NewWave
Home Cinema Rooms
Complete r
Home Cinema Solutions
DUAL PURPOSE LIVING SPACE DEDICATED HOME
CINEMA ROOMS CINEMA SYSTEMS CINEMA ROOMS
We have expertise in designing and delivering all
the elements required to create a great home cinema:
design, construction, sound, projection, seating, lighting & finishes.
01732 852 500
honnecinenna(a)new waveav.co.uk
www.newwavehomecinenna.co.uk
O Visit our Tonbridge
demo suite
By appointment only
DAWN OF SUPER HEROES EXHIBITION/NEWS XI0
Small items that could
make a big impression...
A super day out for fans
New 02 exhibition explores DC's iconic heroes on both page and screen
Alien Queen Wall
Sculpture
Give your
movie
den an
Aliens -style
makeover
with this
life-size
wall
sculpture of the Alien Queen from
Hollywood Collectibles Group.
Priced around $1,600(1), the
hand-painted 'museum quality'
sculpture is constructed from
fibreglass and mixed media.
An alternate version with an
interchangeable extended
inner jaw is also available.
Stormtrooper
Wireframe Light
Imperial
Storm-
troopers
maybe
associated
with the
Dark Side,
but that
doesn't stop them from lighting
up your cinema room. This USB-
powered, Trompe L'oeil effect 2D
etched acrylic light is based on the
original movie helmets created
in 1976 by prop master Andrew
Ainsworth (whose signature is
printed on the base). Grab one
from TheFowndry.com for £25.
Jurassic Park Gates
To mark
the 25th
anniversary
of Jurassic
Park, US
toy and
collectible
maker
Factory Entertainment will be
releasing a detailed polystone
reproduction of the film's iconic
gates and park vehicle. The limited
edition sculpture stands llin tall
and features battery-powered
illuminated flickering torches.
While it won't be available until
later this year, you can pre-order
one now for $250.
From the gleaming cityscapes of Metropolis to the
beaches of Themyscira, via an overnight stay in
crime-ridden Gotham, the new DC Exhibition: Dawn
of Super Heroes offers a whistle-stop tour of the
DC universe. Mingling film props and costumes
with comic art, the show has begun a six-month
residency at The 02, London. HCC donned a cape
and cowl and took a closer look...
A co-production between DC Entertainment and
Art Ludique-Le Musee, the exhibition is rich in heroic
detail. With 45 original costumes and props, 300
or so concept sketches and more than 200 pages
of original comic art, there's no shortage of spandex
to revel in.
After the gauntlet of merch, visitors are ushered
through a predictable chronological warren. Our
advice is walk slowly, else you might miss some
gems. A running loop of vintage Max Fleischer
Superman animation reveals influences on Hayao
Miyazaki, while superhero fashionistas will want to
savour Christopher Reeve's cape and Lynda Carter's
Wonder Woman bathers.
Bat's entertainment
The Batcave offers perhaps the widest variety
of exhibits. Fans can inspect costumes worn in the
Tim Burton Batman movies (for what it's worth,
Penguin's suit appears to have aged rather better
than Michelle Pfeiffer's Catwoman outfit) and
gawp at the artistry of Anton Furst's original concept
art for 1989's Batman.
And if you've ever wondered
just how awesome the full-size
Batpod from The Dark Knight Rises
is close up, then this is the place
to find out.
There's a lot of context on offer.
Video clips document the DCU
throughout, and there's specific
narration via little audio paddles.
There's so much to digest, in fact,
that HCC went through twice.
Reading and watching first time
around, and then listening to the
narration second time.
Much will be familiar to comic
die-hards, but there are also
items we've never seen before,
such as early concept sketches
for Tim Burton's aborted
Superman Lives, the movie
set to star Nicholas Cage as
a tousled-hair version of the
Last Son of Krypton.
The DC Exhibition also
acknowledges the impact the
publisher's iconic characters
had on Sixties pop culture, with
references to Andy Warhol,
Roy Lichtenstein and, of course, the classic 1960s
Batman TV series.
The real treasure
Curator Jean-Jacques Launier was given full access
to the Warner Bros archive for the exhibition. 'Many
of these props and artefacts are priceless. Some of
the sketches, like the first ever Joker sketch, would be
worth millions,' he says.
He's not wrong. The real treasure here is the art.
Around every corner is an iconic cover in its raw
pencil and ink form, sourced from private collections
and dealers, or a comic page depicting hand-drawn
visceral action.
The fine-art style of Neal Adams, be it in his
Superman vs. Muhammad Ali pencils or legendary
Green Lantern/Green Arrow covers, is a joy to behold.
The photorealistic painting style of Alex Ross is
similarly beautiful, and the opportunity to see the
clean, classic original lines of Curt Swan's Superman,
juxtaposed against the raw, scratchy style of a young
Frank Miller's Dark Knight, will be worth the price of
admission alone for many. Make the effort to seek
out Jack Kirby too. Comic art doesn't get much better
than his original cover for Forever People #1.
Inevitably, the exhibition is heavily skewed to the
trinity of Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman.
But there's a nod to members of the Justice League
and Suicide Squad, particularly Harley Quinn.
Whether your interest is in DC's movie franchises,
or comic book legends Jerry Siegel
and Joe Shuster, Bob Kane and Bill
Finger, this exhibition is a pilgrimage
worth taking. Catch it before it's
up, up and away.
DC Exhibition: Dawn of Super
Heroes runs at the 02 in London until
September 9. Visit www.dcexhibition.
co.uk for information and tickets.
The exhibition covers DC's heroic history
from the 1930s to the present day
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
BULLETIN 13
This month's top 70 news stories in handy, bite-sized chunks...
I Sony
slashes
VR
costs
Sony Interactive
Entertainment
is dropping the
price of entry
to the world
6 Netflix beats BBC
The BBC is losing out to Netflix when it
comes to appealing to younger viewers.
New research conducted by the broadcaster
reveals that people aged between 16 and 24 now
spend more time per week watching Netflix than
all BBC TV (including iPlayer). It also shows that
people aged between 16 and 35 spent more time
listening to streaming music services during the final
quarter of 2017 than all BBC radio.
of console-
powered Virtual
Reality. As part
of a global price
reduction, the
company has slashed the cost of its PlayStation VR
Starter Pack (consisting of a VR headset, the
PlayStation Camera and a download code for
PlayStation VR Worlds) from £350 to £260
in the UK.
7 Sing while you're streaming
ROXI is a new music streaming service that
promises to turn your TV into the 'ultimate
music entertainment hub 1 . The brainchild of
Electric Jukebox, ROXI differs from more traditional
streaming services by also providing a karaoke mode
(a Wii-style microphone controller is provided) and
an interactive music trivia quiz. Altogether now...
Making sweet
music together
Bowers & Wilkins
has been named
the 'official headphone and
speaker partner' of the iconic
Abbey Road Studios. As part
of this partnership, various
B&W loudspeakers (including
the flagship 800 D3
floorstander) will be installed
throughout the studios.
Lowering the 'bar
More slashed prices as Bluesound rewrites
the ticket on its Pulse Soundbar. Perhaps
with one eye on the Playbar from multiroom
rival Sonos, the Pulse Soundbar's price tag has
dropped from £1,000 to £800 in its standard black
finish - and lowered to £900 for the white iteration.
LG embraces DTS VirtuahX
LG will release the world's first TVs
with integrated DTS VirtuaLX technology
this year, beginning in its South Korea
homeland before rolling out to other territories.
As yet unspecified models from its 2018
Ultra HD TV lineup will pack the post-processing
talents to deliver - it's claimed - believable
height and surround effects from a conventional
speaker array.
X-Men movies delayed
Twentieth Century Fox appears to be having
difficulties with its X-Men movie franchise.
While Deadpool 2 is still on track to hit
cinemas as planned (see p23), the studio's other
X-Men films that were due for release this year
have both been delayed to accommodate reshoots.
Fellow spin-off New Mutants (originally due this
month) has been bumped back to August 2019,
while X-Men: Dark Phoenix has been shuffled back
from November to next February.
Playing the
game in 4K
It looks like Game
of Thrones will make
the jump to Ultra HD Blu-ray
this Summer. While there's
no official announcement
from HBO, Amazon France
is taking pre-orders for the
show's first season on UHD
Blu-ray, and lists a June 4
release date. Given that HBO
previously re-released the
early seasons of the show on Blu-ray with Dolby
Atmos audio, this seems like the next logical step.
Icon moves on
Troubled independent UK distributor Icon
Film Distribution has finally found a buyer in
the form of home entertainment specialist
Kaleidoscope. The purchase includes Icon's library
of more than 300 films including Apocalypto, Drive,
Paranormal Activity and The Babadook.
Stand Alone... together
Manga Entertainment is bringing the
acclaimed anime series Ghost in the
Shell: Stand Alone Complex to Blu-ray
in June. Priced around £100 and limited to just 1,000
copies, the Zavvi-exclusive 11-disc boxset collects
together all 52 episodes of the series, the Laughing
Man and Individual Eleven OVAs and the Solid State
Society film, plus an exclusive 140-page book.
Premiere...
What's happening in the
world of TV and films...
Thor: Ragnarok co-stars Chris
Hemsworth and Tessa Thompson
might be teaming up once again
for yet another comic book movie.
The duo are in talks to play two of
the leads in Sony's upcoming Men
in Black reboot, which will be set in
the same world as the previous
films, but involves an all-new bunch
of characters. Fast & Furious 8
helmer F. Gary Gray has been
tapped to direct.
Grudge re-match
Men in Black isn't the only film
series undergoing a reboot at Sony.
Horror franchise The Grudge is also
being 'reimagined 1 , with Andrea
Riseborough, John Cho, Demian
Bichir and genre stalwart Lin Shaye
attached to star in the new film.
Spielberg on Indy 5
Steven Spielberg has confirmed
that the fifth Indiana Jones film will
begin shooting in the UK next April.
There's no word on what Indy will
be up against this time - we just
hope it's not aliens again...
We asked...
What is the resolution
of your main home
cinema display/
screen?
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
14 DISC PREVIEW
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
ars of the Silver screen
EW Silver Series
Surround yourself in sound with the multi-speaker
Silver Series, perfect for enjoying movies to the full.
monitoraudio.com
(flj) MONITOR AUDIO)
16 WESTWORLD/OPTOMA
Face to Face
Topics of discussion on
theHCCFacebook page
Thor: Ragnarok's
Blu-ray soundmix...
The sound is so lacklustre!
Stewart Heed
I've a feeling it might be to do with
the film's original soundmix. I saw
it whilst on holiday in Florida,
at a Cinemark XD screen, by all
accounts a fantastic cinema.
I wasn't too impressed with the
Dolby Atmos sound - it basically
adhered to all the criticisms in your
review. Lack of power, lack of
actual surround sound... not what
I'd expect from a big Marvel movie
on a premium screen!
Mark Hornsby
What you're watching
on your home cinema...
Good Easter films
for me! Strangled
and Psycho III
Robert Corrigan
The Spider-Man Trilogy in 4K,
Justice league in 4K and GoldenEye
on DTS Laserdisc.
Mike Wadkins
The third and fourth Indiana Jones
films - impressive sound and
picture from normal BD - plus
The Mummy 3D, which was
entertaining action-adventure
with a monster or two.
Theo Coetzee
Nothing - I'm going to see the new
Tomb Raider in Dolby Atmos.
Lee Regan
Pitch Perfect 3 and Jumanji in 4K.
Steve Smith
The original Jumanji, on 4K disc f
or Atmos, and Muse: Live in Rome
are on my hit-list this weekend.
Ricky Wilson
Fast things going round in circles...
Yes, it's an FI weekend for me in 4K.
Stefano Pascuzzi
Join in the fun
Like our page
at facebook.com/
HomeCinemaChoice
Back of the 'net
Trailers, technology and more to check out on the web
The beasts are back
Warner is already hyping its Fantastic Beasts...
sequel (The Crimes ofGrindelwald) in advance of
its November cinema release, and judged from this
teaser trailer the studio has given director David
Yates a massive SFX warchest. Look out for Jude
Law taking on the role of a young Dumbledore.
youtu.be/_bUbEu3SlmE
Cambridge takes audio to the Edge
This short behind-the-scenes video gives you a
taste of the craft and time that Cambridge Audio
has put into its new Edge series, premium slabs
of hi-fi released to celebrate the company's
50th anniversary. But could we please have
a multichannel version?
youtu.be/3eHCh-05n6E
The end of the line
Margot Robbie (pictured) stars in Terminal, an
independent crime drama due for release in May,
also starring Dexter Fletcher, Simon Pegg and Mike
Myers. If that description doesn't float your boat,
check out this trailer, which suggests it may have
a unique, neon-infused, noirish vibe.
youtu.be/AW-NivlFgrQ
Sound advice
The first episode in a new series of podcasts from
Dolby, this runs for over an hour and features
Skywalker Sound stalwart Randy Thom going
into detail about movie audio design, the birth of
surround sound, his own career and plenty more.
Highly recommended.
youtu.be/lZn_lsyhxvk
Saddle up again
Westworld's first season was one of the best TV
dramas of recent years, so this follow-on (beginning
on Sky Atlantic right about now and hitting disc later
this year), has been hotly anticipated. This teaser is
exactly that - hinting at what's to come but keeping
its cards close to its chest. Consider us hooked...
youtu.be/sjVqDg32_8s
Puppet masters
The Critters franchise - a kind of sci-fi-tinged,
gore-laden version of Gremlins - was notable for
its brilliant practical effects, none more so than its
puppet cast of killer aliens. This (very fuzzy) behind-
the-scenes vid gives you a flavour of how the FX
team brought them all to life.
facebook.com/Fangoria/videos/1630317240348104
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
BULLETIN
Bargain hunt
Optoma HD27e^ www.optoma.co.uk
The 'e' suffix denotes this DLP
projector is an evolution of Optoma's
previous HD27, with the PJ specialist
claiming improvements to lamp-life,
running noise and image punch (through
a 3,400 Lumens rating). Native resolution
remains 1,920 x 1,080 rather than state-
of-the-art 4K, but factor in the dual
HDMI inputs, 12V trigger output, 3D
playback, powered USB for streaming
device hookup, neat design and £550
price tag and you may find you don't
crave any extra pixels.
BACKGROUND IMAGE: SHUTTERSTOCK.COM/KOKSHAROV DMITRY
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
18
The AF80LED (above) features the same THERE’S MORE TO Sony’s 4K TVs than meets
panel and processing as last year's A1 the eye The Japanese major says it’s exploiting
years of expertise in the broadcast field and
cinema production to ensure its 2018 TV range
is a class apart.
Certainly, looking at the brand’s incoming
flatscreen lineup, with its premium designs and
head-turning image quality, it’s difficult to believe
there was once speculation that Sony would shut
down its loss-making TV business. But that was
then, this is now. With a new high-end OLED hero,
plus a formidable fleet of LED 4K flatscreens, Sony
is (literally) a brand to watch. HCC was invited to
Sony Europe’s HQ to peer behind the new panels.
Sony's XF80 series: entry-level 4K sets
with an attractive design
Its. An(other). OLED
The company's 2018 headliner is the AF8. First
spotted at CES, this second-generation 4K OLED
offering takes a more conventional approach to
design than its A1 predecessor (it no longer leans
back, for a start), although the set also retains that
model’s Acoustic Surface audio technology, wherein
the panel itself produces forward-facing sound
using vibration rather than conventional stereo
drivers. However, out goes the powerful subwoofer
(mounted in the TV's stand) and in come new,
downsized bass drivers.
Also retained on the AF8, across both its 55in and
65in versions, is the Al's panel and XI Extreme image
processor. This is perhaps an unusual move in a
world of rapid change, but no bad thing. Fine detail,
colour depth and near-black performance still
appear exemplary.
And, says Gavin McCarron, technical marketing
manager at Sony Europe, it’s not through
happenstance. 'We carry out factory calibration
of luminance and colour to mimic the characteristics
of our Trimaster mastering monitor. This level
of calibration can’t be achieved once a panel has
left the factory. It needs to be done factory-side.'
Such fine-tuning is done to both OLED and LED
LCD screens, we're told.
McCarron concedes that the pre-calibration
of a studio-grade Trimaster is a little bit more
time-consuming than a consumer panel, but points
out that there’s direct correlation between Sony’s
flagship Ultra HD TVs and a reference Trimaster
EL monitor, as used in studio colour grading suites
around the world.
'We really try to mirror a director’s intent in our
picture processing,' he says. 'I know there are a lot
of calibration services, but some things can’t be
achieved on a finished set. We picked up a lot
of expertise in our CRT days.'
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
TECH FOCUS IS
While the AF8 is born of an 'ain't broke, don't fix it'
ethos, bigger changes can be found on Sony's LED
sets, including wider deployment of the high-end
XI Extreme processor. One beneficiary is the XF90
(reviewed this issue, p40), which replaces last year’s
XE90. This comes in the same screen size options
(49in, 55in, 65in and 75in), but benefits from an
improved full array LED backlight for greater contrast,
as well as better processing by moving away from
the (non-Extreme) XI chipset.
Sony's silicon doesn’t just analyse any incoming
signal. It also analyses the characteristics of the
panel it’s driving. When the processor understands
the capabilities of the TV’s colour, brightness
and detail, it can apply more precise and accurate
dynamic tone mapping, says the brand.
Living on the edge
Edge LED illumination is still employed on the XF85,
which will no doubt be Sony's mass-market hero.
Fashionistas should note that it’s available in both
black and silver finishes on its four smaller screen
sizes (43in, 49in, 55in and 65in), while two larger
models (75in and 85in) come in black only.
Mid-range it may be, but the specification is still
high. Like the XF90, this uses a 100Hz panel, with
image processing handled by the brand’s workhorse
XI processor. This means it’s not in line for a Dolby
Vision upgrade, but does support HDR10 and HLG.
The real win here, though, remains the brand’s
object-based HDR remastering. Used to give a faux
HDR look (exploiting the natural ability of the panel
and backlight) to all SDR content, the technique
works well. We’ll be waiting for a sample to see
just how effective its HDR handling is, but an early
hands-on has us salivating.
Another range likely to attract attention is the
edge-lit XF80 Series, which represents a new entry
level for Sony UHD. Available at sizes up to 55in,
this combines stylish looks (the narrow aluminium
frame and central pedestal stands are attractive)
with a better-than-budget spec. But there is a
Sony demo'd its new TV hardware
at its UK-based European HQ
Looking for a bigscreen experience?
Sony's mid-tier XF85 lineup goes all
the way to 85in
afld-roidtv.
sj
B RAVI A
caveat - the key difference between the XF80
and its XF85 stablemate is the use of a lower-cost
50Hz panel, which impacts motion handling, an
ongoing challenge for LCD screens. Meanwhile,
the XF90 range is endowed with Sony's new
X-Motion Clarity, which uses a proprietary algorithm
to boost LED brightness selectively within an image,
reducing flicker caused by black frame insertion.
The result is less motion blur without unwanted
side effects. (See p28 for more about motion
smoothing technology).
All Sony's X-branded TVs are based on the
Android platform. It’s fair to say that Android isn’t
the best loved of such systems, but it is getting
smarter. For a start, Chromecast is built-in, which
enables a growing number of apps to cast directly
to the TV. It also now offers hands-free control via
Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant (they were
demo’d at Sony's HQ with the company's LF-S50G
Google Assistant speaker for control and search).
And there’s even the promise of a more intuitive
and less cluttered user interface down the road
when Android Oreo is released.
Once again, Sony is stocking its TVs with YouView
functionality, enabling full catchup from the UK's big
four broadcasters, and backwards EPG interaction.
HDR all over
Of course, Sony isn’t just about 4K. It continues to
offer HDR support on some of its Full HD models
too, (whereas some brands still sell 4K screens
with no HDR compatibility). However, it says much
that the company isn’t launching any new 32in
screens this year, just continuing with existing sets.
Both the ongoing R series (non-smart) and the WE6
(smart) are HDR-capable and are seen by Sony
as screen partners for the HDR-capable base
PlayStation 4 model.
What is new for 2018 is the RF4, which is an
HDR compatible HD TV, albeit non-smart, and the
step-up WF6, a Freeview Play set in 43in and 50in
screen sizes. While it doesn’t use the Android OS,
it does offer a healthy selection of catch-up TV
services (BBC iPlayer, ITVHub, AU4 and Demand 5)
plus Netflix, Amazon Prime Video and YouTube.
It even has a basic web browser. As a secondary
screen, it has a lot going for it - as long as you won't
miss those extra pixels ■
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
WHAT HI-FI?
M2 SOUNDBASE
with Bluetooth™ and built-in subwoofer
AWARDS 2017
Soundbars and soundbases
Best soundbase
Q Acoustics M2
Hearing is Believing
Create the ultimate room filling, cinematic experience and bring life to your TV sound.
The M2 delivers stunning TV sound and audio performance using a powerful
amplifier, unique BMR™ 180 degree, wide dispersion sound technology and
built in subwoofer, all in a one box solution.
Discover more: www.qacoustics.co.uk/m2
ACOUSTICS
PLAYBACK EXTRA 21
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
2018's blockbuster season is about to get under way. Team HCC
settles into the front row to pick candidates for the year's biggest film
THE BIRTH OF the Summer blockbuster began in
June 1975, when shark thriller Jaws surfed a wave
of unprecedented pre-release promotion to swallow
remarkable box office takings of more than $100m.
Canny marketing by Universal studios, the success
of Peter Benchley's source material and a wide
release strategy made it the first true 'event picture'.
A template had been set.
In 2018, Hollywood still follows the Jaws rulebook.
Spend millions on promotion, open big and hope
the ticker tape comes rolling in. And it's gone global
too - while Jaws opened during the Christmas
of 1975 in the UK, modern movies are typically
released in the same week across domestic and
international markets.
What has changed, however, is the notion of the
'Summer blockbuster'. Summer is getting longer.
The so-called 'Oscar season' of November/
December still exists, and the start of the year
remains the time for less-fancied genre movies (such
as the Liam Neeson thriller The Commuter, released
this January) to have a box office crack. Yet with
studios focusing ever more on big-budget flicks with
the aim of billion-dollar turnovers, the traditional
June/July Summer has become crowded. All those
tentpoles need space to stand.
Over the page we reveal the 2018 blockbuster
slate that crams in aquatic monsters, dinosaur
wranglers, con artists and more superheroes than
you ever thought possible... >
1 \U
22 SUMMER BLOCKBUSTERS
Avengers: infinity War
In cinemas: April 26
Since the release of Iron Man in 2008 and the establishment of the Marvel Cinematic
Universe, all roads have been leading to this point. The third Avengers film sees the
beginning of the end for what the studio has referred to as 'Phases' 1,2 and 3, and it
will wrap up next Summer with another helping of Avengers action. Where does Marvel
go after that? Not much is known, but maybe don't expect to see Robert Downey Jr
donning the tin suit again.
Infinity War promises Marvel fans a conclusion of the long-running Thanos/lnfinity
Stones plot, a team up between the Avengers and the Guardians of the Galaxy, and the
studio's winning mix of humour, SFX and mindboggling set-pieces. One challenge is
whether it can find all of its 30-strong cast enough to do.
Another challenge concerns the film's eventual BD release, potentially around August.
Disney's Thor: Ragnarok caused some bafflement thanks to an at-times underpowered
soundmix - improvement here would be welcome. There's also the possibility the movie's
all-IMAX digital cinematography (a world's first) will land on 4K Blu-ray with a Dolby
Vision encode, unless the House of Mouse is reserving that tech for its Star Wars platters.
Solo: A Star Wars Story
In cinemas: May 25
Spin-off movies from the main Star Wars saga didn't
sound like the greatest idea ever (we all have
memories of The Scorpion King), but 2016's Rogue
One proved that the franchise is big enough to veer
away from its main arc and still deliver what its fans
want. Next on the spin-off agenda is this Han Solo
origin story, which casts Alden Ehrenreich as the
young Millennium Falcon flyer, abetted by his
Wookiee companion Chewbacca.
A decision by studio head Kathleen Kennedy to
replace directing duo Phil Lord and Chris Miller with
veteran Ron Howard midway through So/o...'s
production has set the Hollywood rumour machine
into overdrive. At the same time, the initial trailer
led to some (predictable) gnashing of teeth from
Star Wars stalwarts about Ehrenreich's suitability
to fill the boots of original Han Solo actor Harrison
Ford. None of this means the movie itself won't be
a hit, however.
When it comes to Solo's home media release,
the film's 3.4K and 6.5K digital photography (and
4K digital intermediate) will hopefully filter through
to a superior Ultra HD Blu-ray release (and separate
3D outing), and should follow the format set by
...The LastJedi (see p94) in featuring Dolby Atmos
audio and Dolby Vision HDR.
Just don't look out for a warts-and-all Making of...
documentary.
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
PLAYBACK EXTRA 23
Deadpool2
In cinemas: May 15
Marvel's mutant 'Merc with the Mouth' returns to
cinemas with another foul-mouthed, ultra-violent,
fourth-wall-breaking adventure in the latest addition
to Fox's X-Men franchise. This time around Deadpool
puts together his own team (which he dubs X-Force)
to save a young boy from a time-travelling soldier.
Released back in 2016, the original - and strictly
adults-only - Deadpool was an unexpected smash
hit for Fox. It's appeal didn't end on the bigscreen
either, with the film going on to become one of the
biggest sellers of the fledgling 4K disc format.
But for all of its success, there's no getting away
from the fact that the original film's action scenes
(whisper it) felt a little cheap by the standards of
most superhero flicks. Thankfully, it seems Deadpool
2 won't be content to coast by on its outrageous
humour, and will be marrying it to some spectacular
action. The film has a whole new team of
mutants on tap (who already have their
own spin-off outing in the works), and Fox
has drafted in David Leitch to direct, who
previously helmed Atomic Blonde
and is one half of the team
behind John Wick. The
promise is therefore
of a sequel that's a
little more polished -
and another best¬
selling 4K Blu-ray.
Jurassic World: Fallen
Kingdom
In cinemas: June 6
Jurassic World, the long-awaited fourth instalment
of the dinosaur franchise, was huge. Brachiosaurus
huge. The movie, which teamed up Chris Pratt and
Bryce Dallas Howard as park employees struggling
to contain a new hybrid dino, stomped its way to
a massive $1.6bn global box office taking. A sequel
was never in doubt.
The first Jurassic World worked so well because
it finally delivered on the wishes of park owner John
Hammond (Richard Attenborough), and allowed
audiences to tour around a full-size, fully operational
Jurassic Park. This follow-up film won't have that
same wow factor, so will have to explore other ideas
to keep us hooked. One of which appears to be
bringing Jeff Goldblum back for a cameo role.
Pratt and Howard are also returning.
Before trooping off to catch Fallen Kingdom at the
multiplex (in either 2D or 3D), Universal is whetting
our appetites by releasing the previous four films in
the franchise on UHD Blu-ray in May - as a 'Trilogy
Collection' plus Jurassic World as a standalone
release, or in separate steelbooks as a Zavvi-
exclusive. At the time of writing there was still no
official word on disc specifications, but it may be
that we see soundmixes upgraded to DTS:X.
Time to get your subwoofer primed...
Chris Pratt is back in Fallen Kingdom ,
as are CG beasts and gyrospheres
Debbie Ocean (Sandra Bullock) is the
catalyst for another high-concept heist
in Ocean's 8
Ocean's 8
In cinemas: June 22
If the female take on action franchise The
Expendables - dubbed The Expendabelles, naturally
- ever gets off the ground, its gender-reverse
thunder will have been stolen by this spin-off movie
to Steven Soderbergh's Ocean's franchise. Out go
George Clooney and his posse of sharp-suited
tricksters (bar Matt Damon, who returns here
in a minor role), and in come Sandra Bullock,
Anne Hathaway, Rhianna, Cate Blanchett, Helena
Bonham Carter, Dakota Fanning and more to
make up a new gang of con artists. Soderbergh
relinquishes director duties to Gary Ross (The
Hunger Games, Seabiscuit).
With memories of the original trilogy fading fast
( Ocean's 73 was released back in 2007), a revisit
now to the world of glamour and grifting makes
sense, and Ocean's 8 may well prove the perfect
antidote to 2018's roster of SFX spectaculars.
And, as no actual characters are being recast as
female, it will hopefully avoid the tedious, angry
criticism levelled at 2016's Ghostbusters. Although
we can't be certain.
Warner Bros is handling distribution, which we
expect will lead to a UK 4K Blu-ray before the end
of the year. What would be even better is for
Soderbergh's Ocean's... trilogy to also get a reissue,
as the existing 1080p BDs are far from the best the
format has to offer. >
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
24 SUMMER BLOCKBUSTERS
Further ahead
More big movies on the
radar 'til Christmas 2018
Venom
Long in gestation, this Spider-Man
spin-off (confusingly unrelated to
the Marvel Cinematic Universe)
finally arrives in cinemas in October.
Tom Hardy will be growling his
way through dialogue as the
titular anti-hero.
'There's no killing wha
killing what can't be
killed,' said King Willie in Predator2,
a tenet that perhaps explains Fox's
continued efforts to get its killer
alien franchise back in theatres.
At least this time it has an A-list
director (Shane Black) and original
producing team Joel Silver and
Lawrence Gordon onboard. Hunt it
down in cinemas in September.
Slcarlo: Day of the
Soldado
In cinemas: June 29
Sicario director Dennis Villeneuve has moved on to
bigger things ( Blade Runner2049, for one), but this
perhaps unexpected sequel to the 2015 thriller keeps
Josh Brolin and Benicio del Toro in their roles as
CIA man Matt Graver and his black ops specialist
Alejandro. It's hard to imagine either of them signing
up for a quickly produced cash-in, so the clumsy title
that evokes awkward memories of straight-to-video
action sequels is probably a red herring.
The director's chair is now filled by Stefano
Sollima, who previously helmed the brilliant Italian
organised crime series Gomorrah. Sicario writer Taylor
Sheridan is again on scripting duties, and - judging
by the trailers - the extraordinary original score has
also been retained.
While Sony Pictures is handling North American
distribution, Lionsgate will bring the flick to the UK.
Which may mean an Atmos mix across all home
media releases, and not just Ultra HD Blu-ray.
Incredlbles2
In cinemas: July 13
Given the huge explosion in popularity the superhero
movie has undergone since the release of Pixar's
animated smash The Incredibles in 2004, nobody
is questioning the studio for returning to the well for
a belated sequel. And the good news is that this is no
by-the-numbers follow-up. Instead, original writer-
director Brad Bird returns to continue the story he
began 14 years ago, exploring gender roles as Mr.
Incredible (Craig T. Nelson) adjusts to life as a
stay-at-home dad, while his wife Elastigirl (Holly
Hunter) gets on with fighting crime.
With the two Pixar films released on Ultra HD
Blu-ray to date (Cars 3 and Coco) delivering some
of the most eye-wateringly beautiful 4K HDR visuals
to ever grace a home cinema, we're primed for
Incredibles2 to follow suit. Meanwhile, memories
of the DTS-HD MA track that graced The Incredibles'
Blu-ray has us salivating at what this sequel's Dolby
Atmos mix may unleash.
Speaking of The Incredibles, rumours abound of
a 4K release of that film to support the sequel.
Warner Bros returns to the world of
Harry Potter in November for
another prequel written directly
by J.K Rowling. The first Fantastic
Beasts was an unbridled joy (and
made for a great 4K platter) so
fingers crossed the promise of a
bigger role for Johnny Depp doesn't
rip the magic out of this one.
Deed, the boxing flick that saw
Sylvester Stallone's Rocky take
on the role of trainer to upstart
pugilist Adonis Creed, was a surprise
critical and commercial hit. We're
all in favour of another bout,
especially as Dolph Lundgren is
reprising his role as Ivan Drago.
Skyscraper
In cinemas: July 13
Since Die Hard, action fans have witnessed countless
titles riffing on its premise ('It's like Die Hard, but on
a boat!'). With its one-man-fighting-baddies-in-a-
tall-building plot, Skyscraper has gone full-circle.
Presumably the pitch was simply, 'It's Die Hard again.'
Originality isn't everything, though, and in cast
leader Dwayne 'The Rock' Johnson, Skyscraper
has found perhaps the only actor around who can
convince as both an ordinary working man (in this
case, a security guard) and an all-guns-blazing hero.
Neve Campbell, last seen running away from a
rubber-masked murderer in Scream 4, plays his wife.
Trailers have teased a popcorn movie with some
wonderfully over-the-top stuntwork, while director
Rawson Marshall Thurber has opted to shoot
digitally on both Arri Alexa XT and Alexa 65 cameras
- the latter enabling capture at up to 6.5K.
Converted in post-production to 3D, there's likely
to be a stereoscopic 3D disc release down the line.
When it comes to sonics, studio Universal typically
offers a 3D audio mix (either Atmos or DTS:X) across
all HD releases. A Dolby Vision 4K platter could
follow this movie's Dolby Cinema release, too. >
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
SOUND R EVOLUTION
"BASS TO BELIEVE IN"
• Inlaid front panel display, curved metal grille
• 1,200W RMS /4,000+ W peak Sledge amplifier
• 13.5-inch driver: massive dual-ferrite magnet
motor, edge-wound 8-layer voice coil
• High Resolution Analog Devices DSP
• Smartphone control app for iOS® and Android®
(( What the SB-4000 delivers is almost
the textbook definition of great home
cinema bass; deep, clean and fast,
and easily integrated with your
chosen speaker system, j j
HCC April 2018
HOME
CINEMA
Choice
BESTBUY
karma
karma-av.co.uk
Front Row
RERTING
Never has top quality home cinema
seating been so affordable
FrontRow™ Serenity Modular Seating from £1,275.00
• Dual motor for independent control of recliner and headrest • Recliner switches include USB charging ports
• Large Range of Fabric and Leather colours • Optional cup holder accessories
FrontRow™ Classic Modular Seating from £720.00
Modular Design for curved and straight seating configurations
Large Range of Fabric and Leather colours
Recliner switches include USB charging ports
Optional cup holder accessories
Full size paper templates & CAD drawings available
Black leather seating available from stock
All FrontRow™ seating includes a space-maximising inclining mechanism that allows seating to be placed close to a wall and
includes a comprehensive 5 year warranty. A free design service is available to ensure the seating configuration is suitable for
your room. Call for your nearest demonstration dealer.
For further information please call: 01892 552561 or visit www.FrontRow-Seating.co.uk
FrontRow™ Home Cinema Seating, 69 London Road, Southborough, Tunbridge Wells, Kent TN4 OPA
PLAYBACK EXTRA 27
Ant-Man and The Wasp
In cinemas: August 3
This year's final Marvel Studios release is a sequel
to 2015's Ant-Man and, as evidenced by the title,
will be making good on that film's post-credits
tease by allowing Evangeline Lilly's Hope van Dyne
to step up and join Scott Lang (Paul Rudd) in the
superhero business as The Wasp.
Set after the events of Captain America: Civil
War, Ant-Man & The Wasp finds the diminutive
hero on the run from the law and joining forces
with Hope and her genius father Hank Pym
(Michael Douglas). While full details of the plot
are still subject to Marvel's usual levels of secrecy,
we do know that our heroes find themselves up
against a gender-flipped version of the comic
book techno-terrorist Ghost (played by Hannah
John-Kamen). It also looks like we'll get to find out
the fate of Hope's mother, following the news that
Michelle Pfeiffer has been cast as original Wasp,
Janet van Dyne.
One thing we do know for sure is that this
is a Marvel movie we can't wait to experience
on 3D BD. The original's stereoscopic encode
made the most of the film's size-changing
shenanigans, and with returning director Peyton
Reed promising that the sequel will be bigger
(or should that be smaller?) and better, we're
again expecting creative use of the technology.
Mission: impossible
-Fallout
In cinemas: July 26
The sixth Mission: Impossible film marks several firsts
for the series. It's the first to have a returning director
(Christopher McQuarrie also oversaw previous
instalment ...Rogue Nation). It's the first to be shot
using IMAX 3D digital cameras. And it's also the first
to have had production shut down for nine weeks
after its leading man broke his ankle.
If the prospect of watching the precise moment
Cruise cracks his foot in crystal-clear slo-mo isn't
enough to tempt you (the shot in question has
already appeared in the trailer), then there are other
reasons to get excited about Mission: Impossible
- Fallout, and its 4K Blu-ray outing towards the end
of the year. Chief among these are the spectacular
stunts and action sequences that have become the
franchise's bread and butter.
Another reason is the news that Paramount is
prepping the previous five films for debut on Ultra HD
Blu-ray this year. Given that the Blu-ray releases
of the first titles are in need of serious AV upgrades
(they don't even sport lossless soundtracks), the idea
of brand-new 4K masters with remixed Dolby Atmos
(or even DTS-HD MA 5.1) audio is enough to have
us humming the series theme tune in anticipation.
Be wary of any six-film boxset, though - this is one
franchise that may run and run.
In Mission: Impossible - Fallout , Tom
Cruise is still doing his own crazy stunts
Jason Statham and Li Bingbing prepare
for some aquatic action in The Meg
The Meg
In cinemas: August 10
A certain breed of film fan will get as far as 'Jason
Statham vs a giant shark' and pre-order their ticket
for The Meg, but there's potentially more to this
creature-feature than mere B-movie thrills.
Producer Lorenzo di Bonaventura has A-grade
form with the likes of the Transformers series,
Deepwater Horizon, Salt and Only the Brave,
while the film's rumoured $150m budget has us
hoping the inevitable CG beastie FX may stand
up to scrutiny.
And then there's leading man Jason Statham.
While not renowned for his acting chops, he has
undoubted screen presence, efficient stunt skills
and - as an ex-diver who competed for the UK
in the 1990 Commonwealth Games - he should
breeze through the underwater scenes.
The film itself has finally emerged from
'development hell', with rights for its source novel
(1997's Meg by Steve Alten) initially bought by
Disney shortly after its publication. Twenty years
later, thanks to a co-distribution deal between
Warner Bros and Gravity Pictures, we will finally
get the answer to the eternal question, 'Who
wins in a battle between man and 70ft shark?'
Look out for a 4K Blu-ray release late Autumn,
by which time a sequel may have been quickly
greenlit if The Meg swims, rather than sinks, at the
global box office ■
[ ^
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
Watch a Blu-ray on your home cinema and frame
interpolation technology can make it look better than ever.
At least, that’s the ideay^^^^^^S separates the rough
from the smooth
28 FRAME INTERPOLATION
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
MAIN IMAGE: SHUTTERSTOCK.COM/FUJJI
TECH FOCUS 29
/
WHILE CONTRAST, COLOURS and video
processing are important considerations for those
who value picture quality, motion performance
is something that can make or break a television.
After all, the vast majority of content we watch on
TV is moving imagery.
Let's start with the movies we have all come
to appreciate and love. Traditionally, the frame rate
of such material has been 24fps (or frames per
second), a standard that was adopted initially for
financial and technical reasons - it was the slowest
frame rate at which comprehensible sound could be
produced from synchronisation of the optical track
running along the film.
However, over the decades 24fps has become
synonymous with the 'film' look: its dreamy and
surreal aesthetics key to the suspension of disbelief
that allows us to immerse in movies irrespective
of how unrealistic the plot, dialogue and set design
may be. Note that two films that have been released
with higher frame rates (The Hobbit: An Unexpected
Journey and Billy Lynn's Long Half-Time Walk) drew
shocked responses from viewers complaining that
they looked 'fake' - see box out, p30.
As 24 frames per second isn't the fastest of
frame rates, 24fps material will not only contain
some inherent blur, but also appear slightly shuttery
(I try not to use the term 'judder' to describe the
24p strobe effect), especially if magnified on
modern largescreen TVs. These characteristics
may not appeal to some viewers, prompting
TV manufacturers to design frame interpolation
algorithms to provide a clearer and smoother
viewing experience.
The numbers game
Before we delve into frame interpolation, we need
to talk about the panel refresh rate on televisions.
Broadly speaking, there are 60Hz TVs and 120Hz
TVs, with the latter being generally more expensive,
particularly on higher resolutions - the more
affordable 4K televisions (sub-£l,000 at launch)
typically have a native refresh rate of 60Hz. In
countries which use 50Hz power frequency (such as
the UK), these TVs are marketed as 50Hz and 100Hz
displays respectively, but for all intents and purposes
they can do 60Hz and 120Hz too.
Compared with a 120Hz panel, a 60Hz one
suffers from a couple of limitations that will impact
on its motion presentation. The first is seen when
dealing with 24fps content such as movies and
most non-soap dramas these days. Because 60
is not fully divisible by 24, a telecine process known
as 3:2 pulldown splits each frame into fields which
are then displayed alternately in an uneven fashion:
the first field repeated two times; the second field
repeated three times; and so on and so forth.
The outcome is a regular stutter that’s particularly
visible during slow panning shots, otherwise known
as telecinic judder.
On the other hand, a 120Hz panel, as found on
most high-end LED LCDs and OLEDs over the past
couple of years, can present film footage at perfect
multiples of 24Hz using a process called 5:5
pulldown, therefore eradicating such judder.
A 120Hz panel also allows for more options
(for example frame interpolation and black frame
insertion) to enhance the motion clarity and
smoothness of 50Hz/60Hz content, since there
are double the number of frames for such motion¬
boosting technologies to be deployed.
This brings us to motion-compensated frame
interpolation (aka MCFI). This creates an artificial
frame between the original frames to either reduce
motion blur, smooth out judder, or both. But
depending on the implemented MCFI algorithm,
two notable side effects can ensue.
Scrubbing up
The first is the infamous soap opera effect, which
causes 24fps films to look like hyper-smooth,
cheaply shot video, similar to those poor-quality
Australian soaps you pretended to never watch
in the 1980s (hence 'soap opera effect' or SOE).
As mentioned earlier, the historical use of 24fps
has established its qualities to be associated with
high-quality cinematic production, and if you're
a purist, subverting the very defining fabric of film
through the introduction of soap opera affect will
most likely lessen your enjoyment of the movie.
Fortunately, more and more TV brands are now
offering separate controls for interpolating low- and
high-grade motion in their hardware user menus
(more on this later), allowing viewers to improve
motion sharpness without introducing SOE.
Perhaps less avoidable are interpolation
artefacts following the injection of artificial frames.
If you've bought a new TV and watch it out of the
box without adjusting the factory settings, you may
have seen haloing, shimmering, tearing or other
forms of aberrations around objects moving across
a complex backdrop, for example a ball breaking
up as it flies past the crowd in football broadcasts,
or a person walking in front of a brick wall or
leafy hedge. These artefacts are caused by the
incapability of the onboard processing system
(which is almost certainly enabled by default on
modern TVs out of the box) to interpolate frames
with enough precision. There's only so much
guesswork the silicon can do. In general, the more
aggressive the frame interpolation - the more it
aims for a smooth image - the more artefacts that
can be introduced.
It's because of these shortcomings of frame
interpolation that video enthusiasts are more
excited by black frame insertion (or BFI) technology
to boost motion resolution. As suggested by the
name, this technique inserts a black frame between
the original frames to emulate the low-persistence
properties of impulse-type displays. You may be
confused by now, so let me explain.
A TV can broadly be categorised as either a
hold-type or impulse-type display depending on
how the panel is driven. Hold-type displays like
LCDs (including those using an LED backlight) and
OLEDs display each frame continuously until it’s
replaced by the next frame. Research has shown
that it is the persistence of the preceding static
frame in our retina, as our eyes track the movement
on screen, that contributes significantly to what > I
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
30 FRAME INTERPOLATION
'LG is offering black frame
insertion for the first time
in the company's OLED
history on its 2018 fleet'
we perceive as motion blur - referred to as the
sample-and-hold effect.
On impulse-type displays such as CRTs and
plasmas (remember them?), the decay of the
phosphors naturally introduces a fade-to-black
interval which effectively 'refreshes' our retina
and clears out any prolonged frame persistence,
resulting in improved motion clarity. This is
basically what black frame insertion is trying to
achieve, by mimicking impulse-
driven motion on hold-type displays.
Like all pharmaceutical products,
black frame insertion is not without
its own side effects. One is a drop
in light output, but most mid/
high-end TVs in recent years should
have enough brightness reserves
to compensate appropriately. In an industry first,
Sony has this year also debuted a technology
(X-Motion Clarity) on its XF90 series of full-array
local dimming LED televisions, which utilises
the TV's dimming algorithm to locally boost the
brightness of picture segments where black frame
insertion takes place.
More problematic is flicker caused by the artificial
injection of black frames. This may be more
apparent depending on the source frame rate
(on the 2017 Panasonic and Sony OLEDs, 50Hz
material looked more flickery than 60Hz content);
black flash duty cycle; and your own sensitivity.
But if you can tolerate (or even better, don't notice)
the flicker, then you can enjoy heightened motion
clarity without having to put up with soap opera
effect or interpolation artefacts. It is because of the
clamour for black frame insertion among video
enthusiasts that LG is offering the technology for
the first time in the company's OLED history on its
2018 models.
On that note, let's explore the motion-enhancing
technologies found on the four leading TV brands in
the UK.
True Intelligent Auto Motionflow!
LG calls its motion-smooth technology TruMotion,
and before 2018, this was made up of purely
motion-compensated frame interpolation without
black frame insertion. Even the least aggressive
TruMotion preset of Clear introduced noticeable
soap opera effect and interpolation artefacts,
prompting most cinephiles to switch the processing
off for the best results.
The South Korean brand does offer separate
De-Judder and De-Blur controls in the TruMotion
'User' sub-menu to target 24/25fps and 50/60fps
content respectively. If you wish to smooth out
judder in movies, nudge de-judder up gently; whereas
if you want higher motion clarity, use the de-blur
control. By experimenting, it's possible to arrive at
a balanced set of values that increases motion
sharpness without overtly significant soap opera
effect, though look out for the odd stutter or glitch
from time to time.
llnexpeeteh
frame tate±
Peter Jackson's Hobb'i
flicks had a surprise
v -*■ -•
-
. ... - - 4P m*
For his trilogy of Hobbit movies, director Peter
Jackson returned to Middle-earth with a new
weapon - a high frame rate. The first flick in the
series, 2012's4n Unexpected Journey, was shot
at 48fps, and both sequels followed suit.
Not all cinemas screened the movie at 48fps,
however. In fact, most didn't, instead using
a more standard 24fps conversion, meaning most
audiences didn't experience it.
Response to Jackson's groundbreaking
presentation was generally unfavourable. 'It
looks uncomfortably like telly, albeit telly shot
with impossibly high production values,' said film
critic Peter Bradshaw. Yet Jackson was adamant
that 48fps was the right way to go, telling movie
website Den of Geek: '48 frames is by far the best
way to see this film... 24 frames was arrived at in
a very arbitrary way, and it’s become the way
we’ve become used to seeing things. But 24
frames isn’t very good.'
For the movie's domestic media release, it
was only available at 24fps, due to higher frame
rates not being part of the Blu-ray specification.
It's possible a future UHD release could see a
48fps presentation, so those who missed The
Hobbit in HFR at cinemas may one day get a taste
of it themselves.
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
Panasonic's MCFI technology is available through
the Intelligent Frame Creation option in the user
menu, and since 2016 the Japanese company
has also started providing control over backlight
scanning/black frame insertion via a Clear Motion
setting. From my experience testing Intelligent Frame
Creation on the Panasonic TVs I've calibrated, 'IFC
Min' is a good catch-all setting that reduces motion
blur and judder while incurring only the slightest
blink-and-you'll-miss-it soap opera effect and
interpolation artefacts.
For the more adventurous, Panasonic also offers
independently adjustable Film Smooth and Blur
Reduction settings in the Intelligent Frame Creation
'Custom' sub-menu on its latest TVs. Use the former
to smooth out judder in movies, and the latter to
improve motion clarity, especially in fast-moving
sports broadcasts.
Next up, Samsung offers frame interpolation and
black frame insertion on its higher-end televisions,
both found under the Auto Motion Plus sub-menu.
I've always found the default Auto Motion Plus
presets to be overly aggressive, resulting in apparent
soap opera effect and distracting artefacts, but
thankfully the flatscreen giant also offers separate
Blur Reduction and Judder Reduction controls in
the Auto Motion Plus 'Custom' area, allowing users
to achieve higher motion clarity without having
to endure objectionable slickness. The company's
black frame insertion control, namely LED Clear
Motion, can be found here too, and among the
major TV brands, Samsung's BFI algorithm tends
to introduce the least flicker across 24Hz, 50Hz and
60Hz sources.
Sony is the only TV manufacturer out of the
'Big Four' to not offer independently adjustable
de-blur and de-judder settings in its Motionflow
sub-menu. What this means is that to achieve
any meaningful increase in motion resolution on
a Sony Bravia, some soap opera effect is inevitable
however mild, although to be fair it's not as
offensive as that of other brands. Sony's motion
processing is widely considered to be the best in
the industry: even with Motionflow off, slow panning
shots in 24fps films generally look smoothest
on Sony TVs, and should you choose to engage
Motionflow, you'll see less interpolation artefacts
than on rival sets.
Delve into Sony's Motionflow 'Custom' sub-menu,
and you'll find Smoothness and Clearness sliders
which determine the intensity of frame interpolation
and backlight scanning respectively. Increasing the
Clearness value will darken the image, and on certain
Sony televisions, setting Clearness to 'Max' will
activate pure black frame insertion (akin to the
'Impulse' mode on older Sony Bravias) which causes
too much flicker and brightness drops for most use
cases. The combination of Motionflow 'True Cinema'
and the correct Film Mode setting allows users
to recover 24p cadence from 60p sources for
a smoother result without telecinic judder.
A question of taste
There's a lot of tweaking experimentation to be done
then, although at the end of the day, HCC is of the
Auto Motion Plus
Auto Motion Plus
Blur Reduction
- Judder Reduction
■ LEO Clear Motion
Smooth out uneven or
jumpy visual
. processing by
reducing Judder on the
Samsung TVs
allow custom
control of blur and
judder reduction
Key
■ Original frame
■ Interpolated frame
belief that when watching movies, you should
only consider using frame interpolation if your TV
(for example a 60Hz model) is not capable of
reproducing 24fps without judder. Even then, we'd
probably rather put up with occasional judder (which
is normally only visible in slow panning shots) than
with soap opera effect, as this permeates the entire
movie and alters the underlying motion qualities that
define film. Due to the low frame rate, 24fps material
is inherently blurry (just pause any fast-action scene
and you'll see the blur is present in the source) and
slightly shuttery anyway, so frame interpolation
(and black frame insertion, for that matter) won't
provide any sizeable benefit.
Video-based content such as fast-action sports,
on the other hand, stands to benefit from judicious
application of motion-compensated frame
interpolation and/or black frame insertion, simply
because the higher frame rate places more demand
on the end display for a clearer, smoother picture.
For watching sports, a good rule of thumb is to
set your TV’s MCFI control (if present) to its least
aggressive setting (normally one notch above 'Off').
In most cases this should be sufficient to boost
motion clarity without introducing significant
artefacts. Happy experimenting! ■
Frame interpolation adds new 'artificial 1
frames between original frames (above) |
to reduce motion blur. However,
interpolation artefacts caused by
inefficient processing are possible, and
the sort of thing to annoy AV purists!
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
SAVING THE
WORLD FROM
IGH
INITION
SOUND FOR
HIGH DEFIN TION
VIDEO
FIND THE BEST
IN HOME CINEMA AT
OUR DEALERS
LONDON & THE SOUTH EAST
ASHFORD (KENT)
SOUNDCRAFT 01233 624441
DUNTON
HI-FI LOUNGE 01767 448121
EALING
AUDIO VENUE 0208 567 8703
ENFIELD
AUDIO T 0208 367 3132
HIGH WYCOMBE
SOUND GALLERY 01494 531682
WELWYN GARDEN CITY
NINTRONICS 01707 320788
ARCAM
HIGH
HIGH
DEFINITION
JNDFOR
DEFINITION
i/IDEO
FIND THE BEST
IN HOME CINEMA AT
OUR DEALERS
SCOTLAND & THE NORTH
CARLISLE
PETER TYSON 01228 525891
EDINBURGH
HOMESOUND 0181 662 1827
FALKIRK
HI-FI CORNER 01324 629011
GLASGOW
LOUD AND CLEAR 0141 221 0221
KIRKBY LONSDALE
THE MAJIK HOUSE 01524 273578
NEWCASTLE UPON TYNE
PETER TYSON 0191 285 7179
NORMANTON
IDEAL AV 01924 781011
ARCAM
34 DREAM THEATRE/WWW.SON A.TECHNOLOGY
Room reborn
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
INSTALL 35
Check out a seven-seat cinema where attention
to detail and careful planning gets the best from
some state-of-the-art AV hardware
KITCHECKLIST
SONY : VPL-VW550ES 4K HDR projector (with
Panamorph Paladin anamorphic lens); PS4 Pro
LUMAGEN: Radiance Pro video processor
DENON: AVR-X6300H AV receiver
DISPLAY TECHNOLOGIES: Dynamic-2S projector
screen with 4:3/16:9/2.40:1 masking
ARTCOUSTIC: 3 x SL 8-4s (front LCR); 4 x 40-30 SL
4-2s (surround/rear); 4 x Architect SL 4-2s (height);
2 x Control 2 subwoofers; 2 x PA-750 sub amps
SKY'; Q Silver PVR
APPLE: Apple TV 4K; iPad (control)
OPPO: UDP-205 Ultra HD Blu-ray/universal disc
. -3 player (multi-region)
■ JSM NINTENDO: Switch; Wii U
MICROSOFT: Xbox One X
RTI: XP-6 control processor
FOR THIS PROJECT, Cheshire-based installer
SONA was asked to take an existing (and
underused) room and give the owner a setup
worthy of the Sony 4K projector and 11-channel
Denon receiver they'd already invested in, with two
rows of seating, a motorised masking projection
screen for constant height presentation, and
a 'full-fat' 7.2.4 Dolby Atmos speaker system.
To ensure these aims could be reached (while
accommodating some windows that had to be
retained) 3D modelling and speaker placement
calculations were conducted. The finished design
not only includes a new front wall to house screen
and LCR speaker/subwoofers, but redesigned walls
that hide surround speakers and black-out blinds,
giving the space a 'regular' feel when it's not being
used for 4K movie action. >
zsssssssssssgr
Once
projector screen v
from floor to ceiling
new
*-s^*sirsss?si-”
and twin subwoofers
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
36 DREAM THEATRE
An RTI controller and Apple iPad with a custom Ul
drive the system. Whether the room is used for a Sky
Q binge-session or Xbox gaming test, the projector,
screen, blinds and lighting all kick into action at the
touch of a button. Advanced image calibration
comes via a Lumagen Radiance processor, which
also works with a Panamorph anamorphic lens to
deliver constant height, pixel-for-pixel aspect ratio
switching. Smart lighting, a tidy kit rack and plush
seating complete the premium package ■
A Hit the lights!
The room's multizone lighting is controlled
via Lutron Grafik Eye QS hardware
B. Box of tricks
A Lumagen Radiance Pro processor delivers
advanced LUT calibration, and manages aspect
ratios of 4K content before being output to the
Sony projector
C. Atmos on tap
The owner's Denon AVR-X6300H was called
into duty to front the cinema's 7.2.4 Artcoustic
speaker array
D. Touch and go
Choose a source via the iPad's Ul, and the cinema's
RTI controller does the rest, instigating automatic
control over lighting, projector and blinds
E. Perfect vision
The twin-tier seating arrangement offers line-of-
sight for up to seven viewers
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
INSTALL 37
ptTL i
r i
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
HARPENDEN • EDGWARE • BECKENHAM
PERFECT PICTURE, PURE SOUND
With 3 showrooms, 7 demonstration rooms, expertise, experience,
patience and professionalism, for the very best in Home
Entertainment there's no better destination than Musical Images.
Featuring all the latest Home Cinema stars, Pioneer amps and
KEF’s space saving Ci in wall speakers, we promise every customer
3 times award winner
HOME CINEMA CHOICE
“Best Multiroom Installation”
Check out our NEW website
www.musical-images.co.uk
O musical images
O @musical_images
Musical Images Showrooms
126 High Street, Beckenham, Kent BR3 1EB
020 8663 3777 beckenham@musicalimages.co.uk
173 Station Road, Edgware, Middlesex HA8 7JX
020 8952 5535 edgware@musicalimages.co.uk
82 High Street, Harpenden, Hertfordshire AL5 2SP
01582 764246 harpenden@musicalimages.co.uk
Opening times - 9.30am to 5.30pm
HIFI • HOME CINEMA • MULTIROOM AUDIO • HOME AUTOMATION
LIGHTING CONTROL SYSTEMS • A/V DESIGN & CONSULTANCY
Audio Visual Lifestyle Ltd trading as Musical Images. Finance options available, subject to status. E&OE
WWW.HOMECINEMACHOICE.COM 19
REVIEWS
■♦Hardware SONY 55in XF9005 4K HDR TV with XI Extreme processor
BOWERS & WILKINS 5.1700 Series system SAMSUNG 65in Q9 QLED TV NAD 7-channel AVR
with Dirac Room EQ HITACHI Affordable 75in 4K TV VIVITEK Mid-price 4K DLP projector
LG Dolby Vision-capable Ultra HD Blu-ray player CELLO Battery-powered 32in TV & MORE!
Denon's AVC-X8500H ups the AV stakes
with its 13 channels of onboard power.
We rustle up the speakers to match and
listen in - see p52
HCC RATINGS KEY.
Outstanding
Above average
Acceptable
Disappointing
All prices quoted are approximate and may have changed
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
4C SONY KD-55XF9005/£1,700
Direct-lit 4KHDR
LED TV with Android
smarts
Below Sony's A8F
OLEDandZD9
LED flagships
Panasonic 55FX750;
LG 55SK9500
Sony’s first 2018 screen barely puts a mid-range foot
wrong, enthuses Steve May
Sony plays a
peaky blinder
7. A similar handset to
last year's model, but
a new 'Apps 1 key is given
a central position
2. The XF9005 uses a
full array local dimming
(FALD) backlight
It's all about the backlight. You can have the smartest image
processor in the showroom, but if your backlight isn’t up to snuff
then that shiny new LCD panel just isn’t going to impress.
This is one very good reason why AV enthusiasts adore full array
LED systems - even the cleverest edge-lighting tends to betray
itself sooner or later with light pooling and splotchy artefacts.
Unfortunately, direct-lit LED TVs aren't particularly
common, not least because the majority of consumers
equate thinness with quality, and those extra lamps add
girth to a set. It matters not a jot on the high street that
a direct LED-backlit TV will typically do a better job
presenting HDR highlights and deeper blacks.
Thankfully, Sony continues to offer enthusiasts the
option. Last year’s XE9005 was a critical hit, which this
year gives way to the XF9005. The good news is this
update introduces a number of significant improvements
over its predecessor.
For one thing, that critical backlight has been boosted
for better contrast, and the set’s image processor has been
upgraded to XI Extreme, which is trickling its way down
the range to make way for the XI Ultimate later in the
year (probably). It also heralds a new motion handling
technique called X-Motion Clarity.
Making a stand
I can’t quite decide about the design of this 55in TV, to be
honest. The 55XF9005 has an ultra-thin aluminium bezel
and the branding is wonderfully subtle, but I’m not a huge
fan of the non-wobble pedestal feet, which look oversized
and inelegant. However, you may value the generally
rock-solid footing.
Connections include four 4K-ready HDCP 2.2-enabled
HDMIs, a trio of USBs (one a v3.0 for timeshifting onto an
external USB hard drive), mini-jack AV input, digital optical
audio output and Ethernet. The XF9005 also supports
Bluetooth pairing with wireless headphones.
HDR support currently runs to HDR10 and HLG,
with the promise of Dolby Vision via a firmware update.
The sooner Sony can get its DV house in order in the UK,
the better, as the number of discs is growing quickly.
There’s no change on the connected front as Sony
remains committed to the Android TV platform.
Consequently, this set is sans Freeview Play, using a
YouView app to offer integrated catch-up and roll-back
EPG. In use, the Android TV OS remains almost comically
flaky: for example, throwing up messages that it can’t
display live TV (on top of a live TV broadcast), or
complaining it isn’t connected to the internet, before
promptly changing its mind. Perhaps it’s just developed
a dry sense of humour?
Integrated streaming apps include Amazon Prime Video,
Netflix, YouTube, Google Play, Rakuten TV, Mubi and others.
Amazon and Netflix both stream in 4K and HDR, while
both Netflix and Google Play get dedicated buttons on
the remote control. The set also has VP9 decoding for
YouTube 4K material, Chromecast built-in for direct
streaming from Chromecast-enabled apps, and support
for voice control from Google Assistant and Amazon Alexa.
Black beauty
The value of the TV's full array backlight is immediately
noticeable. Screen tonality is smooth and black backdrops
largely uniform. There are one none of the murky grey
puddles witnessed on low-quality edge LED displays.
An X-tended Dynamic Range PRO adjustment allows
the set to turn up and lower the backlight for accuracy
(I opted to leave it on Medium), but there is a limit to the
precision of its backlight dimming. The XF9005 doesn’t
have anywhere near the same number of LED clusters as
found on Sony's ZD9 flagship [see HCC #282], so there
is some blooming around bright objects held on dark
backgrounds (particularly noticeable when you view
off-axis). For the most part, however, images are even.
A key attribute of the XI Extreme processor is image
clarity. The panel exhibits full-fat 4K detail in all viewing
modes; if it’s in the source, you’ll see in on the screen.
A dual database is on hand to aid noise reduction
accuracy and fine detail presentation. And as a Triluminos
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
REVIEWS 41
Mark Hamill gets
up to his old tricks
k \n The Last Jedi
•— on 4K BD
HOME
CINEMA
Choice
RECOMMENDED
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
42 REVIEWS
wide colour gamut set, the XF9005 packs a delicious,
rich colour punch.
There’s a dizzying array of image presets and
adjustments to explore. Of the two cinema modes, Cinema
Home offers a slightly higher average picture level, and
looks rather better. The Standard preset became my go-to
for general day-to-day viewing.
A big surprise, however, is Vivid mode. Forget your
preconceptions: this preset improves clarity and nuance,
and enhances colour depth. The first act of Okja, in HDR
‘On Transformers: The Last
Knight the glinting robots
and not-infrequent
explosions look spectacular'
on Netflix, with its dappled forest scenery, finds the
XF9005 unleashing tremendous detail. In Vivid mode,
that Super Pig looks extra tasty...
Standard image adjustments include colour, brightness
and clarity - the latter an umbrella covering Sharpness,
Reality Creation and noise reduction. Sharpness is best set
at 40 on the sliding scale, which is lower than the default.
There’s an ambient light sensor, but my advice is to turn
this off to maintain image consistency.
Out of the box, the TV’s HDR performance is impressive.
I measured just over 1,000 nits with a 5 per cent window,
dropping to around 750 nits with a 10 per cent window.
Even a full-field SDR screen is delivered at just over 380
nits, which is exceptionally bright. An expansive dynamic
range means there’s far less requirement for tone mapping,
and therefore less chance of image errors.
This inherent vibrancy wows on Transformers: The Last
Knight (4K Blu-ray), where the glinting robots and not-
infrequent explosions look spectacular. When the fireballs
land in the opening medieval battle sequence, there’s
a fitting intensity to their impact.
Sony’s Object-Based HDR Remaster, a non-negotiable
image enhancement (unless you stick to True Cinema),
does a consistently good job improving the dynamics of
regular HD and SDR 4K.
SPECIFICATIONS
3D; No 4K: Yes. 3,840x2,160 HDR: Yes. HDR10; HLG; Dolby Vision (via future
firmware) TUNER: Yes. Freeview HD; satellite CONNECTIONS: 4 x HDMI inputs; 3 x
USB; Ethernet; optical digital audio output; AV input; headphone output
SOUND (CLAIMED): 2 x 10W BRIGHTNESS (CLAIMED): N/A CONTRAST RATIO
(CLAIMED): N/A DIMENSIONS (OFFSTAND): l,228(w) x 706(h) x 69(d)mm
WEIGHT (OFFSTAND): 18.2kg
FEATURES: Built-in Wi-Fi; Bluetooth headphone support; Android TV with
Chromecast built-in; 4K X-Reality PRO with dual database processing, X-tended
Dynamic Range PRO; X-Motion Clarity; object-based HDR Remaster
PARTNER WITH
S0NYUBP-X700: Released
this January, Sony's latest
4K disc spinner (£250) is the
brand's first to offer Dolby
Vision playback - albeit after
a firmware update later this
year. Stripped of analogue
outputs, but SACD playback
is retained.
HDR isn’t just about peak highlights, of course; low-
luminance handling is important too. Only a select few
movies really push the envelope when it comes to
spectral highlights, but a good many more have
information in the HDR10 grade at less than 100 nits,
which can be a real challenge for both LED LCDs and
OLED. Sony attempts to solve the issue with Super
Bit-Mapping processing to allow the panel to present
smoother gradations. Given this is a mid-range model,
the onscreen results are impressive.
The much touted X-Motion Clarity innovation, which
selectively boosts LED brightness depending on the image
to counter the dimming of black frame insertion, works
well. Motion handling across the board (the Motionflow
menu provides various flavours) is generally excellent.
Where the XF9005 does under-deliver is image lag.
Gamers won’t be impressed to learn that in Standard
mode I measured input lag at 95.8ms. And this only drops
to 39.3ms in the dedicated gaming mode, which remains
relatively poor.
Audio, too, is unexciting. It's acceptable for everyday
use, but with down-firing stereo drivers and no woofer
the panel demands to be partnered with something a little
more cinematic for movie night. The power output claim
is a meagre 2 x 10W.
3. The XF9005's twin
desktop feet focus on
stability rather than
aesthetic appeal
Raising the bar
While it’s lagging behind rivals (pun intended) when it
comes to gaming, and the Android TV OS and general
Ul are about as slick as sandblasted concrete, the rest of
the XF9005’s feature set is strong. It’s early days for 2018
screens, but a solid 4K HDR picture performance, excellent
SDR upscaling, trendy design and admirable motion
handling are all reasons to shortlist this model. It sets
a high bar for the 4K mid-range ■
HCC VERDICT
★★★★★
Sony KD-55XF9005
£1,700 www.sony.co.uk
^First-class image processing, dynamic HDR and a
smooth direct LED backlight make this mid-range 4K LED
TV a must-see. Android OS doesn't impress, though.
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
SAVING THE
mm FROM
HIGH DEFINITIO
SOUND FOR
HIGH DEFINITION
VIDEO
FIND THE BEST
IN HOME CINEMA AT
OUR DEALERS
THE SOUTH WEST
BRISTOL
SEVENOAKS SOUND & VISION 0117 974 3727
EXETER
SEVENOAKS SOUND & VISION 01392 213895
READING
SEVENOAKS SOUND & VISION 01189 477093
SLOUGH
EPIC HOME CINEMA 07429 370015
SOUTHAMPTON
AUDIO T 0238 025 2827
ARCAM
'ww.arcam.co.uk
Ed Selley admires the power and control of this moody-looking
seven-channel AV receiver
NAD and Dirac's
lucky seven
NAD is entering the 3D audio premium AVR market
with its T 777 V3. As the name suggests, this is the
latest revision to the 777 platform. However, changes
are significant enough that it could have been marketed
as an all-new model and I wouldn't have felt aggrieved.
At its core, the T 777 V3 is a seven-channel design.
These channels can be allocated as 7.1 or 5.1.2, with
support for Dolby Atmos at the time of review and DTS:X
compatibility in the pipeline.
Of course, these days any premium AVR limiting its user
to just seven channels is going to get some odd looks, so
it's no surprise to see the T 777 V3 featuring phono preouts
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
REVIEWS 45
for 5.2.4,7.2.2 and 7.2.4 support via external power
amplifiers - products that NAD itself is well known for.
Decoding is via six HDMI connections (one of which is on
the front panel). All support 4K passthrough with HDCP 2.2
and HDR10. As with DTS:X, compatibility with Dolby Vision
and HDR10+ formats is in the works via a firmware update.
The HDMI inputs join to two outputs.
The amplification of the T 777 V3 is rated at 80W per
channel which, notionally at least, puts it behind most
rivals. The wrinkle to this is that NAD quotes the 80W
figure as all channels driven into 8 ohms at a low distortion
of 0.08% THD. In reality, the T 777 V3 is probably better
endowed than much of the competition.
While NAD's high-end Masters Series amps use
Hypex's nCore Class D amplification, the T 777 features
a Class AB output stage, connected to a toroidal power
supply and NAD's 'PowerDrive' circuit, which the company
says allows for 'very high dynamic power' while keeping
distortion low.
A row of cooling fans are fitted to the underside of
the receiver but these have either not kicked in during
testing or are impressively silent in use. Indeed, NAD says
its fan circuit has a neat trick, cutting out during a quiet
scene in a movie to stop the sound of gushing air upsetting
the ambience.
Compared to rivals that have nine, 11 or even 13
channels of onboard power, the T 777 V3 is going to be
more expensive to run in ‘full fat’ mode. But even if you
are only planning a smaller configuration, the lure here
is of better-quality amplification.
There's another lure, actually. A big revision to the
specification for this V3 model is the removal of the old
Audyssey EQ system and the introduction of Dirac Live.
Well, sort of. As standard, the T 777 V3 comes with Dirac
Live LE, which performs analysis between 20Hz and
500Hz (where most room nodes are likely to lurk). For an
extra $99, you can upgrade to the full Dirac Live suite and
gain correction between 20Hz and 20kHz. NAD supplies
a calibration microphone and setup software with some
useful prompts.
Another aspect of the receiver's specification that is
noteworthy is support for Bluesound's excellent BluOS
system (Bluesound and NAD both being brands under
the Lenbrook umbrella). BluOS allows for UPnP streaming,
internet radio and access to pretty much any streaming
service you can think of (and some you can’t). It also
permits input, volume and basic settings adjustment
of the T 777 V3. One criticism, however, is that the BluOS
module isn’t built into the chassis, but is instead on a
slightly ungainly looking USB dongle.
This can at least be hidden out of sight. Whether you’ll
want to hide the receiver itself is open to debate. In true
NAD form, it is another grey box but I find myself rather
liking it. The front panel layout is logical and the build
quality is first-rate. You also get an excellent multifunction
backlit remote which makes control simple; one feature
it has that's hugely useful is the ability to adjust the centre,
surround and subwoofer levels on the fly, which can give
muffled dialogue a quick boost without reverting to the
settings menu.
If you’re a masochist, you can use a smaller
‘convenience’ handset instead, which is as dreadful here
as it is on a number of other NAD devices.
Taking everything in its stride
Initially running without any Dirac correction, there are
some aspects of the T 777 V3's performance that are rather
more familiar to the two-channel side of my life than the
AV one. Ask me to find one word to sum up to this AVR's
performance and it would be ‘unflappable.’
This is an exceptionally even-handed and controlled
performer. It manages to unpick even the densest
multichannel soundmix without any apparent struggle.
The aural insanity of the first beach assault in Edge of
Tomorrow (Blu-ray) is conveyed with an immaculate sense
of order and effects placement. Some rivals are able to
convey a little more ballistic energy, but they often sound
ragged by comparison.
In a 5.1.2 Dolby Atmos configuration, the T 777 V3 brings
this same effortless control to Mad Max: Fury Road
(Blu-ray). The detail retrieval it manages as a matter of
course is seriously impressive, and thanks to there being
pretty much nothing in the way of distortion from the
onboard amplification, you can wind the levels right
up with only the potential rage of your neighbours to
contend with. This makes it even easier to enjoy the
finer subtleties of the soundtrack, like the outrageous
noise that Immortan Joe’s Gigahorse makes during the
chase through the canyon. And the advantage of the
NAD’s masterful approach to effects placement is that >
AVINFO
7-channel Dirac EQ
AVR with 11-channel
processing
POSITION:
Below NAD's Masters
Series, above the
T758 V3 receiver
PEERS:
Arcam AVR550;
Anthem MRX 720
The AVR's design
is best described
as'understated 1 ...
2. NAD's backlit
remote is brilliantly
easy to use
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
46 REVIEWS
it is no less effective when viewing things that are not
quite as anarchic. The newsroom sequence in journo
drama Christine (Blu-ray) is relayed with genuine realism
and an ear for detail, again allowing you to slip into the
movie without distraction.
All this control and cohesion means, ironically, that the
impact of the Dirac optimisation isn’t as night-and-day
as you might expect. Running the software helped to
even out a 40Hz room peak in my setup, and a slight dip
in the 200Hz region, and further improves the sense of
soundstage handling and refinement. Yet an important
aspect of Dirac is that applying it doesn’t affect the basic
character of your speakers or rob them of any of their
sense of energy.
The ‘RoomFeel’ Target EQ curve that NAD supplies with
the LE software is worth investigating. Through my Elipson
speakers, there was an increase to the sense of ‘body’
in the performance. You might construe this as adding
warmth, but it doesn’t adversely affect the impressive
speed and dynamics that the T 777 V3 has in spades.
With a larger set of speakers that interact with a room
SPECIFICATIONS
DOLBY ATMOS: Yes DTS:X: No (but promised via future firmware) THX: No
MULTICHANNEL INPUT: Yes. 7.1-channel MULTICHANNEL PRE-OUT: Yes. 11.2 phono
MULTICHANNEL OUTPUT (CLAIMED): 7 x 80W (into 8 ohms) MULTIROOM: Yes. Zone 2,
3 and 4 AVINPUTS: 4 x digital audio (2 x optical and 2 x coaxial) HDMI: Yes. 6 x
inputs; 2 x outputs COMPONENT VIDEO: No VIDEO UPSCALING: No DIMENSIONS:
435(w) x 425(d) x 172(h)mm WEIGHT: 20.5kg
FEATURES: MDC Modular Construction enables future hardware updates; Wi-Fi;
Bluetooth; Ethernet; USB input; RS-232; 12V trigger in/out; Dirac Live LE EQ/room
optimisation (upgradable to Dirac Live) with supplied mic; BluOS integration
(via dongle) for hi-res streaming, multiroom integration and app control; intelligent
cooling fans; HDCP 2.2; Class AB amplification
PARTNER WITH
PSBIMAGINEXA: For Atmos
upfiring speakers, NAD's
sister-brand PSB sells these
dual-driver modules. We rate
them a solid combination
of value and performance
-the £350 per pair price
means adding a quartet isn't
too prohibitive.
feet and wickedly entertaining. This receiver is more
musical than its gruff exterior might have you believe.
Potently powerful
Choosing the T 777 V3 is a balancing act of features versus
ability. For the same money, you can have more channels
onboard, more inputs and be good to go with DTS:X -
the NAD does currently feel slightly like a work in progress.
But put into action, this premium seven-channel AVR is
easy to live with day-to-day, potently powerful and will
drop neatly into most rooms thanks to its advanced
onboard room optimisation. It warrants being on any
more vigorously, or an 11-channel array with all those
shortlist at the price ■
extra reflections to take care of, I imagine that both Dirac
and the target curve will have a greater effect on the
performance, and impart more of a character shift than
has been the case with my audition.
Tying up the T 777 V3’s apparent desire to be all things
to all people, it’s no slouch musically either. Listening to
a hi-res FLAC of David Byrne’s American Utopia on Qobuz
sees this receiver deliver a performance that is light on its
HOC VERDICT
★★★★★
NADT777V3
I £2,500 nadelectronics.com
B Superb sound quality and slick usability should put this
seven-channel AVR on your radar, although the current lack of
DTS:X decoding might be a deal-breaker.
3. For the T 777 V3,
NAD replaces Audyssey
EQ with Dirac
4. A lack of legacy
video inputs makes
this back-plate look
a little sparse
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
SAVING THE
WORLD FHBU
HIGH
SO
HIGH
DEFINITION
JNDFOR
DEFINITION
i/IDEO
FIND THE BEST
HOME CINEMA AT
OUR DEALERS
MIDLANDS
& EAST ANGLIA
CHELMSFORD
RAYLEIGH HI-FI 01245 265245
IPSWICH
SIGNALS 01394 672464
SOUTHEND
RAYLEIGH HI-FI 01702 435255
STRATFORD
MUSIC MATTERS 01789 414533
ARCAM
. www.arcam.co.uk
1 . V
REVIEWS 9
David Vivian auditions a heavy-hitting 5.1 system
that's focused on delivering stunning sound
Big speakers,
big sonics
If you’re going to drop the best part of £7,500 on a 5.1 speaker
system, you’ve every right to expect - as Doc Brown put it in
the expletive over-dubbed print of Back to The Future - some
serious ‘stuff’. And few speaker makers do stuff more seriously
than Bowers & Wilkins.
With its new 700 Series lineup, it appears the UK
company didn't think holding back was an option.
I’ll get to the wealth of trickle-down technology in
a moment but, in essence, the new 700 effectively
replaces the old CM (Compact Monitor) line, and fashions
itself as the affordable alternative to the company’s
flagship 800 Series Diamond range. And if you think
a total spend of £7,346 (and adding £400 for the 705 S2’s
dedicated stands, not photographed) is playing fast and
loose with the meaning of ‘affordable’, bear in mind that
this handsome gang of glossy black boxes undercuts
a single pair of 802 D3s by £8,754. If the 800 Series
Diamond magic dust claim isn’t just marketing fluff,
the omens are surely good.
B&W doesn’t do home cinema speaker packages
with incentivising discounts but it does supply all the
ingredients for a pick ‘n’ mix approach and, but for the
inclusion of an even bigger subwoofer, what you see here
is about as good as it gets for an immersive B&W ensemble
that starts with a 7. Let’s begin with the big, three-way 702
S2 floorstander (£3,300 per pair) at the front, as these
showcase neatly what the new 700 series is all about.
Tech-tastic tweeter
Perhaps the one thing that most obviously mirrors
the 800 Series’ flagship technology is the de-coupled
tweeter that sits on top of the main enclosure in its own
bullet-shaped ‘Solid Body’ housing. Visually, it’s almost
a dead ringer. Inside, however, B&W tasks carbon rather
than diamond to do the 25mm dome’s bidding, which
is one of the reasons the system’s price is altogether
more earthbound.
Performance-wise, this new carbon dome seeks to
bridge the gap between the aluminium double dome used
in the company’s 600 Series range and the diamond dome
that crowns the 800 Series Diamond. In other words, it’s
the best B&W can do without resorting to exotic materials
and unavoidable expense.
This carbon dome has two parts. The front part is a
300-micron aluminium dome stiffened by a PVD (Physical
Vapour Deposition) coat of carbon. This is teamed with
a 300-micron carbon ring bonded to the inner face
of the structure. The resulting stiffness, resistance to
distortion and light mass is claimed to push the first
break-up point to 47kHz, well out of harm’s way unless
you were born on Krypton.
‘What you see here is about
as good as it gets for
a B&W ensemble with an
earthbound price tag 1
As for the de-coupled, bullet-shaped housing, it’s
milled from a solid mass of aluminium to make a hefty
structure that weighs 1kg and is exceptionally inert.
Moreover, it acts as a heatsink and is de-coupled from
the main box in exactly the same way as the 800 Series
Diamond via what looks to be a tiny, but quite stiff, nib of
rubber. It also has the benefit of looking extremely cool,
but makes using these speakers with any Atmos upfiring
module a bit awkward.
The secret sauce
Moving down the speaker, the 5.5in ‘Continuum cone’
midrange driver provides another physical link with 800
models, and confirmation that B&W has shifted away
from Kevlar weave as a diaphragm for its premium lines.
Although the newer woven composite cone material itself
is B&W’s little secret, the underlying concept evolves that
for which Kevlar was first used: overcoming the deleterious
effects of a conventional cone’s transition from pistonic
motion to break-up modes.
B&W calls it ‘optimised and controlled flexibility’, and
the intended upshot is a cleaner, sweeter, more open
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
5C REVIEWS
and neutral mid-band performance. It's hard to say how
much of a helping hand the new midrange driver’s FEA
(Finite Element Analysis)-optimised aluminium chassis
lends to this, but it’s certainly a step up from the heavier
and less-stiff zinc chassis used in the outgoing CM Series.
The driver derives further benefit from a tuned mass
damper on the front face of the chassis to soak up any
remaining resonance in the structure. And, adapted from
the system used by the 800 Series Diamond, it also
enjoys a degree of de-coupling from the main enclosure.
The 702 S2 is a tall and imposing tower, so there’s room
for no fewer than three 6.5in bass drivers - and, again,
elements are trickled down from the 800 Series Diamond.
The principles behind the so-called Aerofoil cone - its
variable-thickness diaphragm profile determined by
advanced computer modelling - are the same, but where
the 800 has carbon fibre skins, the 702 uses paper. And the
sandwich filling, which allows the variable thickness, is EPS
rather than syntactic foam. It’s enough for B&W to claim
nothing less than a ‘dramatic’ uplift in bass performance
from the previous CM Series.
Talented standmount
Surround duties can sometimes be under-appreciated,
to the extent they’re entrusted to the most humble
standmount within arm’s reach. That’s not the case here.
The 705 S2 (£1,800 per pair) is the star standmount
in the 700 Series range and the only other model with
a solid body, top-mounted, decoupled carbon tweeter.
This setup has formidable
power and precision,
seamless integration and a
beautifully open mid-band'
There's just the one rear-facing bass reflex port instead
of the 702 S2’s two, and one 6.5in Continuum midbass
driver to keep the tweeter company but, sampled in stereo
on the end of my reference hi-fi system, this speaker
has talent to burn.
On LFE duty in this 5.1 array, and with a name that
sounds like a modern take on 007’s favourite Aston
Martin, is the sealed DB4S active subwoofer. B&W could
have supplied an even beastlier bass engine (the dual¬
driver DB2D, for instance), but the forward-firing lOin
Carbon Aerofoil driver and 1,000 watts of Class D
amplification of the DB45 is deemed a more natural
fit for the 700 Series - and even without the dual woofer
arrangement of the DBxD models, it still claims a low-end
reach of 10Hz at -3dB.
As well as requiring you to puff out your cheeks and
make a grunting noise as you heave it into position, it’s
a smart sub, too, packing a digital preamp section with
automatic dynamic EQ, plus the option of Room EQ and
custom/preset modes via B&W's DB Subwoofer app
(which also allows for level control via your smartphone).
The finish is piano black gloss here, of course, but the
700 Series’ other styles (gloss white and Rosewood)
are also available.
Finally, the all-important centre speaker. The FITM71 S2
is a sizable, three-way, rear-vented job, with a pair of 6.5in
bass drivers, 4in Continuum FST midrange unit and, yet
again, that new-tech carbon dome tweeter. There’s a
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
REVIEWS 51
smaller two-way HTM72 in the 700 Series armoury but,
to be honest, I like the look (and weight) of this one.
I should mention the very well made and finished
FS-700 S2 stands for the 705 S2s (actually, they can be
used with any of the 700 Series standmounts). I stuck with
my own ancient Slate Audio stands for an initial stereo
audition, but with the whole setup then moved to my
bigger cinema room, I have to admit the dedicated B&W
stands do look a good deal smarter, if not quite as chunky.
Rolling thunder, pouring rain
EQ-ing the beefy DB4S for this large space proved a
doddle, especially with the smartphone app to guide you.
And, what with the generous internal volume and three
bass drivers of the 702 S2s, together with the more than
ample oomph of my Denon AVR-X4300 receiver, I have
a hunch rumbling bass isn’t going to be a problem.
So, in the spirit of thunder and lightning, cue the Blu-ray
of Thor: Ragnarok, not least because the audio track has
attracted some stick in these pages for sounding strangely
hemmed in and underwhelming, a comparatively muted
accompaniment to the larger-than-life, butt-kicking action
on screen. Well, all I can say is, I didn’t really notice. When
Thor and Surtur go for it in the opening scenes, I can almost
feel the heat and flying embers.
Let me put it another way. B&W's 700 Series 5.1 is
simply immense - system Viagra for a sagging soundtrack,
an open window for Dunkirk- level awesomeness when it
presents (we’ll get to that film in a moment). It’s something
of a truism that you can never have enough bandwidth and
you can never have enough resolution, but there’s so much
of each on tap here it’s hard to imagine needing more.
Perhaps the most impressive thing is the sheer,
unadulterated intelligibility. Everything is so easy to
understand and plausible. It sounds as if stuff is in the
room with you: palpable, tactile, full of texture, colour
and dynamic life.
Breaking it down, this speaker ensemble clearly has
formidable resolving power and precision, seamless
integration front-to-rear and a beautifully open, expressive
and lucid mid-band. The clean, extended upper frequencies
are naturally textured and free from grain, gloriously
detailed yet unforced. And the size of the soundstage it’s
capable of weaving - during the beach strafing of Dunkirk
(Blu-ray) for example - almost defies belief.
The subwoofer's most obvious contribution (apart
from giving explosions compelling weight and violence
and indulging the mixing engineer’s wildest infra-bass
fantasies) is its seductively sumptuous yet supple quality
with music. Bruno Mars’ Finesse (CD) has never sounded
more full-on or, indeed, dripping in finesse. Tempo and
rhythm, so often the downfall of AV speaker systems,
is truly nailed here.
It all comes together to thrilling and deeply satisfying
effect with the Blu-ray of Blade Runner 2049. Opinions
might differ over the film itself, but there can be no denying
the potency and compound complexity of the film’s
5.1 mix in the hands of this B&W setup. It’s immersive,
powerful and yet incredibly subtle. During the sequence
with Blade Runner K and his holographic girlfriend Joi
on a rooftop (Chapter 2), the ambient falling rain is so
convincing and the droplet splashes so specific and varied
(acquiring a hollow metallic ring when they fall on an
unseen drainpipe over your shoulder, for instance),
it actually gave me a little shiver.
SPECIFICATIONS
B&W 702 S2
DRIVEUNITS: 1 x lin Carbon Dome tweeter; 1 x 6in Continuum cone midrange driver;
3 x 6.5in Aerofoil profile bass drivers ENCLOSURE: Twin-ported (rear) FREQUENCY
RESPONSE (CLAIMED): 45Hz-28kHz SENSITIVITY (CLAIMED): 9QdB POWER HANDLING
(CLAIMED): 30W-300W DIMENSIONS: 200(w) x 1.087(h) x 337(d)mm
WEIGHT: 29.5kg
B&W HTM71S2
DRIVEUNITS: 1 x lin Carbon Dome tweeter; 1 x 4in Continuum cone midrange driver;
2 x 6.5in Aerofoil profile bass drivers ENCLOSURE: Rear-ported FREQUENCY
RESPONSE (CLAIMED): 50Hz-28kHz SENSITIVITY (CLAIMED): 89dB POWER HANDLING
(CLAIMED): 30W-100W DIMENSIONS: 590 (w) x225(h) x285(d)mm WEIGHT: 18.3kg
B&W 705 S2
DRIVEUNITS: 1 x lin Carbon Dome tweeter; 1 x 6.5in Continuum cone midbass driver
ENCLOSURE: Ported FREQUENCY RESPONSE (CLAIMED): 50Hz-28kHz SENSITIVITY
(CLAIMED): 88dB POWER HANDLING (CLAIMED): 30W-120W DIMENSIONS: 200 (w) x
407(h) x285(d)mm WEIGHT: 9.3kg
DB4S (subwoofer)
DRIVE UNITS: 1 xlOin Aerofoil cone bass driver ENCLOSURE: Sealed FREQUENCY
RESPONSE (CLAIMED): 10Hz-350Hz (-3dB) ONBOARD POWER (CLAIMED): 1,000W
REMOTE CONTROL: No. (But control via DB Subwoofer app) DIMENSIONS: 360(w) x
377(h) x368(d)mm WEIGHT:20kg FEATi/flES; Stereo XLR input; stereo phono
input; 2 x 12V trigger; RS-232; digital preamp with Dynamic EQ; app-based setup
DUNKIRK: This WW2 drama
featured our favourite
Blu-ray soundmix of 2017,
a massively detailed and
precise DTS-HD MA 5.1 track
that dovetails perfectly with
the onscreen visuals. It gets
the best out of B&W's
premium package.
At the other end of the decibel scale, the visceral
intensity of the Las Vegas attack (Chapter 12) still has
me flinching, even though I’ve watched the movie several
times. The sub’s capacity for heavy-fisted damage is
perfectly showcased as it teams up with the concrete-
trashing transient surround effects to deliver mayhem and
gathering rubble with extreme prejudice. Hans Zimmer and
Benjamin Wallfisch’s post-Vangelis soundtrack has muscle
and menace in equal measure, but also a gentle lilting
beauty as Tears in Rain from the original Blade Runner is
reprised in the final scene. It all leaves me exhilarated but
rather exhausted.
2. Both floorstander
and standmount
models feature
decoupled tweeters
3. Got spare amp
channels? The B&W
700 Series speakers
can be bi-wired
4. The HTM71 centre
speaker is a three-way
driver design
Hard to beat
It’s tempting to label this speaker system a diminishing
returns special. Yes, it’s possible to put together an even
more resolute/dynamic/musical speaker package (one
based around B&W’s 800 Series would do the trick) but
I reckon you’d need to spend much, much more to achieve
any significant improvement. £7,500 is a lot of money but,
honestly, it doesn’t get much better than this ■
HCC VERDICT
★★★★★
B&W700Series 5.1
£7,350 www.bowers-wilkins.co.uk
Not for the faint of heart or tight of space, but this
system's bold style and superb sonics win the day. Even at this
price, the 700 Series 5.1 is fine value.
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
DENON AVC-X850OH £3,300
Richard Stevenson finds 13 reasons
to fall in love with this big Denon amp
AU guns
blazing
Denon’s AVC-X8500H has taken the AV amplifier
concept and turned it up to 11. Well, more than that
actually. With a claimed 1,950W spread through its
13 independent channels, plus every key AV feature
currently available, this is the undisputed champion
of AV specification trumps. But do you need so many
channels of power on tap?
Yes, as it turns out. While you can divert some of those
powered channels to a second or third stereo zone, the real
magic is what they can do in your cinema.
Object-based audio formats map sound into your room,
making the most of however many speakers you have.
The more the merrier. Or, rather, the more speakers,
the more accurate the positioning of effects and more
believable the ambience of the movie. Dolby Atmos uses
up to 64 speakers in commercial cinemas, although that
might be trickier to pull off in your home theatre.
Starting with a typical 11-channel (7.2.4) setup, this
new Denon allows you to add an extra two channels with
a number of different placement options. Using them as
front height channels for 7.2.6 could have real benefits in
bolstering front-end solidity. If you have got a very wide
room, you could configure them as front-width channels
in a 9.2.4 set up to ensure a spacious front soundstage.
The Denon’s options are copious but not endless. Within
the initial menu you do have a finite number of speaker
configurations to choose from and that could mean some
fudging is required. I could not simply add front height
speakers to my existing 7.2.4 configuration, which uses four
overhead ceiling speakers. The nearest I could set in the
menu was front-height, mid-top and rear-height speakers.
There are several more unusual configuration options -
including Auro-based setups - but it is not always obvious
how to marry the amp’s configuration to your layout.
And there are bugs in the setup that need ironing out.
For example, you can set six in-ceiling ‘top’ speakers but
that disables Surround Back, so you only get 11 channels.
I also managed to establish a five-channel/surround back/
eight height-channel config, which to those with a spare
hand for some extra fingers, is 15 channels. Flmmm.
While there are 15 sets of terminals on the back, just
to add to the confusion, it’s not until you navigate to the
13-channel
networked AV
amplifier
POSITION
Top of the 2018
Denon range
Anthem MRX1120;
Denon AVR-X6400H;
Pioneer SC-LX901
7. Might it be time for a
Denon remote revamp?
2 There's little visual
difference between
this and the X6400H
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
REVIEWS
54 REVIEWS
HDMI EMU JK /HPCPS.g
HDMi ■!I■ 4K / HDCF2.2 h^gn^.!=
Blue tooth'WKF i
ANTENNA
VIDEO m I VIDEO I COMPONENT V!DEO Eli
AUDIO !!;■
AUDIO
PFIE OUT
HEIGHTS 0|
rn SURROUND BACK H
HEIGHT1 B
MONITOR?
[POWER SUPPLY]
Btffl j 5 A= 1
WARNING :stro(* twzAiiO'OD kotdpbm,
ATTEND ON’RISQUE DE CHOC ELECTHItHJE
•NE PAS OLFVfllfl.
FRONT LI
■
SURROUNDD
Cl
|B
mmmm
IPBiilS
amplifier assignment page that you discover the AVC-
X8500H has disabled the SB channels. The advantage
of the 15 terminals, however, is that you could switch
between an Atmos-style configuration (top speakers)
and an Auro-3D one (height speakers) much more easily
than on previous Auro-enabled Denon models.
The irony in all this speaker menu confusion is that
with object-based audio formats, it really shouldn’t matter
where you place your speakers within reason. Top-spec
hardware should simply measure the room and calculate
where your speakers are, rather than have to be told.
Gripe over, though, because outside of that setup
malarkey, this Denon is a proper stunner.
No more twiddling the dial
When it comes to features, I'll begin with what the
AVC-X8500H doesn't have. This is a short list, and it’s an
AM/FM tuner. As Denon’s naming nomenclature testifies,
the AVC-X8500H is not an AVR. Denon has taken the
decision to oust the FM tuner section completely, so in the
strictest sense this is no longer a receiver. We'll gloss over
that the amp's internet radio tuner can access thousands
of stations, including all your FM favourites. And the fact
that the front display window proudly states 'AV Surround
Receiver' when you boot it up.
Back to what it does offer, and the spec sheet runs long.
This is a 13.2-channel AV amplifier, armed with Atmos,
DTS:X and Auro-3D and able to passthrough 4K FIDR.
It offers networked streaming, Apple Airplay, HEOS
multiroom integration and an 8-in, 3-out HDMI stage.
Other connections are gold-plated and comprehensive.
Build quality is fabulous and the Denon looks just as
good underneath the hood. In here you'll find 32-bit
AKM AK4490EQ DACs and a powerful DSP engine based
on a pair of SHARC dual-core chipsets. No surprise, then,
that the X8500H is a fairy large and heavy beast, and it
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
runs quite toasty warm when pushed, so allow for plenty
of ventilation space.
Setup and room EQ is courtesy of Audyssey’s MultEQ
XT32 FIR-based filter system (not 'parametric' as I have
stated erroneously recently...). More advanced EQ tools can
be unlocked if you invest in the Audyssey Editor app.
Control is via the familiar Denon backlit LCD remote,
the Denon 2016 AVR Remote app, the Denon HEOS app or,
once Amazon Alexa voice control via the Smart Home Skill
arrives through firmware, simply shouting at it.
Other expected touches include IP and RS-232 control
for custom installs. There's also the ability to control the
X8500H with your TV's remote, and a dedicated Smart
Menu onscreen. After a couple of weeks with the amp I also
grew to like the Quick Select keys. These tie up sources and
their preferred sound modes at the touch of a single button.
Solid as a rock
Yeah, but how does it sound? Quite, quite amazing in fact.
This Denon is clean, punchy and dynamic with a solidity to
REVIEWS 55
its imaging that makes even
two-channel recordings sound
wonderfully three-dimensional.
The balance is neutral but
lacks nothing in grunt and drive
when the volume knob gets
turned to the right. That
gorgeously crafted power supply,
visible through the casework,
supplies all those channels
with enough juice not to run
out of steam when the going
gets tough.
Using a 7.2.6 setup with
front height channels, the
Denon mapped Atmos-encoded
material efficiently onto every
speaker. And those front heights
really worked well in filling the
void above the screen in my fairly
long but narrow room.
Doing A/B comparisons with
and without the front heights
in play is a palaver involving
reconfiguring the speaker menu,
but is also quite an eye-opener.
Largescale panning sequences
like the planes going overhead
in Unbroken (Blu-ray) benefit
greatly. The aircraft seem to start further away in the
front distance before they get closer, or disappear further
into the foreground when heading in the other direction.
Dialogue was improved too, the effect reminding
me very much of Audyssey’s DSX front-height channel
implementation. With my centre speaker set on a low
stand, both systems effectively pull the dialogue upwards,
which better centres voices on the screen.
Moreover, the additional front heights deliver a much
greater sensation of three-dimensional sound generally,
increasing spatial height well above the listening plane.
Even with action-fest movies like Justice League
(Blu-ray), where the sound director was clearly paid
on a decibel-per-speaker basis, the effect is noticeable
in enlarging the soundstage.
The insect-like wings of the Parademons are particularly
impressive. Their fast, flighty movement is crafted with
amazing precision in the room, and with your eyes closed
you can virtually point to a creature’s intended location.
They also seemed to fly higher than when running the
system as simply 7.2.4. In short, I found having extra
speakers to fill the void behind and above the main front
array mightily useful in my setup. With a bigger space,
could adding them as additional front width channels
create a similar effect in bolstering the horizontal scale
of the soundstage? Quite possibly.
From 5 to 13
Thanks to the Denon’s cracking processing, mapping more
mundane sound formats onto this mighty 13-channel
system is equally fun. Having originally bought the 3D BD
of Justice League only to discover it packed a vanilla Dolby
Digital 5.1 mix, it was fairly easy to compare the two discs.
The genuine Atmos sound wins comfortably, but the
AVC-X8500H is a master of upscaling 5.1 platters into
something resembling immersive 3D audio. Switching to
SPECIFICATIONS
DOLBY ATMOS: Yes DTS:X: Yes THX: No MULTICHANNEL INPUT: Yes. 7.1 phono audio
inputs MULTICHANNEL PRE-OUT: Yes. 15.2-channel MULTICHANNEL OUTPUT
(CLAIMED): 13 x 150W (into 8 ohms) MULTIROOM: Yes. Zone 2 and 3 AVINPUTS:
4 x composite; 4 x digital audio (2 x coaxial, 2 x optical) HDMI: Yes. 8 x inputs; 3 x
outputs COMPONENT VIDEO: Yes. 3 x inputs; 1 x output VIDEO UPSCALING: Yes. To 4K
DIMENSIONS: 434(w) x 482(d) x 195(h)mm WEIGHT: 23.3kg
FEATURES: Audyssey MultEQ XT32 calibration; Auro-3D processing; hi-res audio file
playback; Wi-Fi; Ethernet; Bluetooth; Tuneln radio; Apple AirPlay; HEOS multiroom
integration; USB input; Audyssey Editor App compatible; Android and iOS app
control; Amazon Alexa voice control (via future firmware); mono-block power amp
construction; compressed audio restorer
PARTNER WITH
OPPO UDP-205: Tag team
Denon's impressive AV amp
with an equally impressive
beast of a Blu-ray player. This
audiophile Oppo (£1,400)
supports Dolby Vision 4K
playback, physical and digital
hi-res audio, and smuggles in
a headphone amp, too.
the Peony Pavilion scene in the DVD of House of Flying
Daggers - another Dolby Digital 5.1 mix - and this amp
brings it alive with added space and punch right down
to the lowest registers of my subwoofers.
(With such older discs I preferred Dolby Surround’s
slightly cleaner and open take on the effect rather than
the heavier upmix of DTS Neural:X, but your mileage
may vary).
Yet it is with Dolby Atmos and DTS:X material that
the Denon really shows its mettle as the class-leading
AV amp of the moment. Spin anything and it beguiles.
The Atmos track on La La Land (UHD Blu-ray) is woefully
shy when it comes to height information throughout, yet
the AVC-X8500H digs into the soundtrack’s subtleties
and nuances with ease. Dialogue is crisp and articulate;
the musical numbers are funky and infectious. Some
scenes in particular are so successful at evoking the mellow
feeling of an LA jazz club that I almost booked myself
a flight out there.
3. As a sign of its
complexity, this
13-channel amp offers
15 speaker terminals
4. Lift the flap to
reveal an HDMI input,
plus headphone and
setup mic sockets
Meet the new boss
After a few weeks it was patently clear that Denon’s
new model sets the current benchmark for integrated
AV amplifiers and does so at a relatively affordable price.
Try to get this level of functionality anywhere else and
you'll face a higher bill and a separate processor/power
amp(s) combination to wrestle with.
It's a brilliant addition to Denon's portfolio, but you
have to decide if you really need it. Whether 13 channels are
going to work for you significantly better than 11 channels
may well depend on the size and shape of your listening
environment. For my long, narrow room, adding front height
speakers was night and day better ■
HCC VERDICT
★★★★★
Denon AVC-X8500H
£3,300 www.denon.co.uk
Denon’s feature-packed 13-channel AV amplifier is
complex to set up but delivers the most immersive surround
sound yet from a single box.
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
5G VIVITEK HK2288 £2,500
projector with HDR
POSITION:
Currently the most
premium Vivitek
projector available
in the UK
PEERS:
Optoma UHD60;
Epson EH-TW9300
Vivitek's handset is
brightly backlit and
sensibly laid out
2.TheHK2288isthe
brand's 4K DLP debut
Vivitek’s first 4K projector puts the brand
back on the map, suggests John Archer
Mid-priced
4K marvel
After finding it difficult in the past to maintain a consistent
foothold in the UK’s notoriously tough home cinema/media
room projection market, Taiwanese brand Vivitek now has a
committed distributor keen to show British movie fans what
its DLP models can do. Which, on the evidence of the well-
priced HK2288, is a heck of a lot.
This projector is the latest in a rapidly growing line of
affordable 4K DLP models using Texas Instruments’ XPR
fast-switching technology. The imaging chip isn't native
4K (it incorporates 4.15m mirrors), but Tl's proprietary
processing claims to deliver two discrete pixels for each
mirror - resulting in a 4K picture. From my experience,
the technology gets closer to a true 4K experience than
any rival ‘pseudo’ technology - and has been certified as
'real 4K' by America’s Consumer Technology Association.
The best thing about 4K DLP technology from a
consumer point of view is its affordability. The Vivitek
HK2288 sets you back just £2,500, and supports
playback of the industry standard high dynamic
range HDR10 format. Even more affordable rivals
are now coming to market, of course...
Sizing it up
The projector is small enough not to overwhelm
either a typical coffee table or your ceiling, but
isn't of the compact, portable ilk. Curved edges
give it a classy appearance, while side-mounted
vents link to its internal cooling fans - be aware
that these make a fair bit of noise with the lamp
set to Boost mode for HDR playback.
Connections are found on the rear panel.
Unusually, there are three HDMI inputs, and
each of these can accommodate 18Gbps data
streams. There’s also a USB port for powering
a Chromecast or other streaming dongle, and
a 3.5mm audio output (the projector carries
a built in 10W mono speaker). However, there's
no 12V trigger output, which is a potential
deal-breaker for anyone already running an
automated screen setup.
Accompanying the PJ is one of the more
helpful remote controls I've encountered.
It's a comfortable size, and its well labelled buttons light
up brightly when pressed.
Setup flexibility is fair for the price, but not outstanding.
Optical zoom extends to 1.5x (providing a 1.39-2.09:1 throw
ratio), and is joined by vertical image shifting. Focusing your
picture is done via an impressively responsive lever on the
lens’s front.
The HK2288’s onscreen menus aren’t very intuitively
organised, but do contain enough adjustments to keep
tweakers happy if you hunt them down. And hunt them
down you should, for two main reasons.
Play time
First, out of the box my pictures contained
a fairly distinct green tone that needed to be
dialled away. Second, to get the best out of
the HK2288 you’ll need to commit to changing
its HDR settings pretty regularly. With its
reasonably high claimed brightness of 2,000
Lumens and promising claimed contrast ratio
of 1,000,000:1, the HK2288 is more capable
than arguably any sub-£3,000 projector of
making HDR fun to watch. But only if you put
in some legwork.
For instance, if you’re watching an Ultra HD
Blu-ray that’s been mastered at 1,000 nits
or less of peak brightness (as most are), you
can get away with selecting the ‘Normal HDR’
picture preset. If, however, you’re watching
a title that’s been mastered at a higher peak
luminance level, you should use the 'Detail
HDR' setting, and additionally reduce the
brightness and contrast levels (to around 43
and 46 respectively).
With this in mind, it would be nice if the
HK2288 does as JVC’s latest projectors do, >
■ m
HDM11 rIDW:' HD Ml2
■ Phut -
hfcd , I
NigllL
□ay
Menu j
4
E;iH
] i H
►
4c
" 1$:9 4-a 10.1C
HU NrS.-.^ 2 36:1
Souris! n^,., , v^ljme
Contest. HDH
Mute I iFnwr: i Elurih
vivitek
o
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
REVIEWS
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
HOME
CINEMA
Choice
RECOMMENDED
58 REVIEWS
and tell you what peak brightness each 4K Blu-ray disc
has been mastered to. But it doesn’t. So all there is to go
on is that Warner and Universal titles are more likely to
be mastered to 4,000 nits than titles from other studios.
As are titles that carry a Dolby Vision master (even
though the HK2288 can’t decode Dolby Vision’s dynamic
metadata). I appreciate that this is hardly a bulletproof
method. You may then want to have a quick look at a 4K
HDR movie and adjust your settings before settling down
to watch it in earnest.
All aboard the HDR train
Any effort you put into optimising the HK2288 for each
title is rewarded with some excitingly good picture quality.
There's a lush brightness here that's particularly
impressive. The snowy exteriors of Murder on the Orient
Express (4K Blu-ray) enjoy a high baseline luminance that
appears much punchier than the picture you get when
watching the same scenes from the SDR 1080p Blu-ray.
There’s also noticeably more intensity to the brightest
parts of the picture - such as the direct shot of the sun
in the film's opening sequence, or the various electric
light sources on the titular train. One shot of a small train
station at night also contains a wider range of light from
the image’s darkest to brightest parts than budget 4K
projectors usually muster.
This brightness opens up Murder ...’s rich colour palette
beyond the reach of the HD Blu-ray - despite the fact
there doesn’t appear to be anything about the HK2288’s
RGBRGB colour wheel and optical system that should
support a wide colour presentation.
Variations in light are well balanced during HDR viewing.
As Poirot walks along the roof of the train against a very
bright backdrop of snow and sunshine, there are still
healthy levels of colour information and detail in his
relatively dark, foregrounded form. He doesn’t just become
a flat silhouette.
Overall black level performance isn’t brilliant, however;
dark scenes tend to look quite grey. This is par for the
course at this level of the HDR projector market, though,
and doesn’t stop the HK2288 from providing plenty of
detail in Murder ...'s night-time scenes.
During my initial few hours with the projector, I was
concerned by how much it could ‘clip’ (lose colour and
detail in) the very brightest image areas. This is where my
earlier advice about adapting the projector to different
SPECIFICATIONS
3D: No 4K: Yes. 3,840 x 2,160 HDR: Yes. HDR10 CONNECTIONS: 3 x HDMI inputs;
powered USB; 3.5mm audio output; RS-232 BRIGHTNESS (CLAIMED): 2,000 Lumens
CONTRAST (CLAIMED): 1,000,000:1 ZOOM: 1.5x DIMENSIONS: 430(w) x 145(h) x
360(d)mm WEIGHT: 9kg
FEATURES: Single-chip DLP projection system; 10W built-in mono speaker; 35dB
cooling noise in Normal lamp mode; 5,000/3,000-hour lamp-life in Default/Boost
lamp modes; multiple HDR presets; colour management; vertical image shifting;
1.39-2.09:1 throw ratio; infrared sensors for remote operation from front/behind
PARTNER WITH
MURDER ON THE ORIENT
EXPRESS: Kenneth Branagh's
recent Agatha Christie
adaptation suffers from
some awkward 'action'
moments, but offers an
image on 4K HDR Blu-ray
that makes them easy
to ignore...
HDR material comes in. If you opt for a more reined-in
light output when viewing the brightest HDR content, the
clipping reduces dramatically. And if you’re careful enough
with the settings, you can achieve this without the picture
becoming depressingly dark.
The HK2288 delivers even the smallest, brightest
light peaks of HDR pictures while suffering only very slightly
with DLP’s colour striping ‘rainbow effect’. And despite
clearly being tuned with HDR in mind, it adapts very well
to standard dynamic range playback where an HDR
source isn’t available. SDR colours still look nuanced
and authentic, and - as you’d hope from a projector
capable of handling HDR brightness levels so well - the
HK2288 has no problem picking out contrast subtleties
from SDR sources.
The agility of its light production, together with little
sign of single-chip DLP projectors’ common fizzing noise
issues and some natural-looking motion handling, also
helps the HK2288 sell its 4K claims. The weave of
Poirot’s exquisite suits and each hair of his extraordinary
moustache are beautifully rendered from the film’s crisp,
clean 4K Blu-ray image.
3. Zoom and lens shift
controls are mounted
on the PJ's top surface
Welcome back
Certainly, Vivitek's HK2288 has a few foibles - the built-in
speaker doesn’t have the scale or projection to be a
convincing accompaniment to the HK2288’s pictures,
for instance; the absence of a 12V trigger is puzzling;
and similarly priced models such as Epson's EH-TW7300
offer far greater control over where the PJ can be placed
in your room. On the other hand, this projector beguiles
with its overall HDR image quality, and is exactly the
sort of forward-thinking, aggressively priced and high-
performance model Vivitek needed to consolidate
its re-emergence on the UK home cinema market.
Consider me impressed ■
HCC VERDICT
★★★★★
Vivitek HK2288
£2,500 www.karma-av.co.uk
So long as you invest a little time in it, Vivitek’s HK2288
delivers as assured an HDR and 4K picture performance as any
affordable DLP projector we’ve seen.
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
Now with more-depth
and more clarity
r\
WHATHI*FI?
AVTech media
AWARDS 2017
AWARDS 2017/18
PRODUCT OF THE YEAR
/ /V V V*V
Best standmount speaker £400-£800
KEFQ350
BEST FLOGR5TAMDlNC
SPEAKER SYSTEM
KEF Q SERIES 5.1.2
The new Q Series hi-fi speakers
The eighth iteration of this successful range continues to be centred
on KEF’s legendary Uni-Q driver array, and is now enhanced with a
new system design, beefier low-frequency drivers and a new damped
tweeter loading tube.The result is superior bass performance and an
even more detailed natural sound. Listen for yourself and experience
pleasure in high resolution.
KEF.COM
OBSESSED WITH HIGH RESOLUTION
SAMSUNG QE65Q9FN £3,800
Justice League on
4KBD finds The
Flash ready for
the fight,
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
BACKGROUND IMAGE: BY SHUTTERSTOCK.COM/NOREEFLY
REVIEWS
John Archer is reminded that OLED isn't
the only premium TV technology in town
QLED TV
fights back
AVINFO
65in4KQLEDTV
with HDR10+
Currently Samsung's
top-of-the-range TV
PEERS:
Sony KD-65ZD9;
LG OLED65E7;
Sony KD-65A1
Samsung probably thought when it unveiled its debut
QLED displays last year that they’d take the world by storm.
Surely punters wouldn’t be able to resist the unprecedented
brightness and colour range delivered by the brand’s new
metal-clad Quantum Dots? But things didn’t turn out that way.
Instead, rival OLED sets, bolstered by performance tweaks and
wider availability, became the year’s ‘must-have’ TV item.
The TV is also
offered in 55in and
75in screen sizes
2. A direct backlight
gives the QE65Q9FN
a bit of bulk
Samsung doesn’t seem to have liked this very
much. How do I know? Because it’s responded with the
QE65Q9FN: the best, most futureproofed TV I’ve yet seen.
This pricey 65in flagship emphatically addresses the
chief issue that hindered the QLED charge last year:
backlighting. All of the brand's TVs in 2017 featured
edge LED arrays, but the QE65Q9FN uses more precise
direct lighting with local dimming. Samsung doesn't
specify the exact number of individually controllable
zones, but I think it's around 400-500, a comprehensive
amount that should limit the potential for backlight
halos/striping cluttering an image.
Samsung has also implemented a new processing
technique that gradually reduces the intensity of a
dimming zone’s light as it approaches its edges, which
should also make defined clouds of light around very
bright objects less obvious.
There have been improvements to the company's
proprietary metal-clad QLED Quantum Dots, too,
resulting in a claimed increase in colour purity and range
- a full 100 per cent of the DCI-P3 colour space, in fact.
Double whammy
These upgrades are delivered while retaining two unique
strengths of 2017’s QLED models: extreme brightness
and remarkable anti-reflection filtering. This screen can
hit brightness peaks on a 10 per cent white HDR window
of 2,400 nits, which is the highest figure I’ve seen on a
consumer television. The screen filter, meanwhile, soaks
up ambient light and reflections from your viewing room
with real efficiency. There’s probably no other TV around
that’s as watchable in a bright living room environment.
Samsung has bolstered its smart TV system
for 2018. For instance, there’s now ‘Smart
Things’ support for monitoring/controlling
compatible appliances on your home network, such as
fridges or robot vacuum cleaners. And more effort has
been made to include broadcast TV in the TV's content
browsing, searching and recommendations utilities.
An onboard Freeview HD tuner is joined by support for
the UK’s main broadcast catch-up TV apps, as well as
4K and HDR versions of Amazon, Netflix and YouTube.
An excellent voice recognition system, meanwhile,
provides both control over your TV and spoken-word
access to a decent universal search system.
As is the norm with Samsung, connections here
are located on an external box.
Physically, the flatscreen QE65Q9FN has a rather
unremarkable silver/grey square-edge design, but at
least this provides a nondescript frame for a new
energy-efficient ‘Ambient Mode’, which lets you fill
the screen with preloaded digital artwork - or one
of your own photos - when you’re not watching it.
You could even take a photograph of your wall and
place that in the TV’s screen to really minimise the
Samsung's impact on your decor...
Possibly this screen's only feature weakness is its
lack of support for Dolby Vision HDR. Instead you get
HDR10, HLG and the relatively new HDR10+ format.
This could be a deal-breaker for some buyers.
However, bear in mind that none of the TVs that
support Dolby Vision will, it seems, support the
rival HDR10+ format. You need to make a choice.
Direct appeal
Does the switch to direct lighting with local
dimming transform Samsung’s QLED
fortunes? You’d better believe it.
Straight away it's clear that this
set's black levels are leagues ahead of >
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
6 REVIEWS
0
those of any 2017 QLED model. The QE65Q9FN delivers
black colours that give OLED a run for its money, even
with mixed images where inky blackness is shattered by
luminance peaks. This means the final scrap between
the assembled heroes and Steppenwolf in the 4K Blu-ray
of Justice League looks nothing short of mindblowing;
a tapestry of incredibly intense HDR whites and colours,
and rich blacks.
And the QE65Q9FN can convey Justice League’s
searing highlights against dark backdrops with scarcely
a hint of backlight blooming. In fact, I believe it does a
better job of controlling light around standout objects
‘Samsung has reminded us
how good LED TVs can be
- this offers the best 4K HDR
picture quality I've ever seen'
than any other LCD TV to date, including Sony’s stunning
ZD9 models. Such ruthless backlight control and
inherent brightness (more than double that of any
OLED) results in a gloriously dynamic, contrast-rich
experience. The screen's peak luminance and canny
processing also ensure intense details - such as the
harsh lights in Bruce Wayne’s jet - look believable rather
than clipped and hollow.
SPECIFICATIONS
3D; No 4K: Yes. 3,840x2,160 HDR: Yes. HDR10; HDR10+; HLG TUNER: Yes. Freeview
HD; satellite HD CONNECTIONS: 4 x HDMI inputs; 3 x USB; RF input; Ethernet; AV
input; optical audio output SOUND (CLAIMED): 40W BRIGHTNESS (CLAIMED): 2,000
nits CONTRAST RATIO (CLAIMED): N/A DIMENSIONS (OFF STAND):! ,405 (w) x 830(h)
x39(d)mm WEIGHT (OFF STAND): 26.7kg
FEATURES: USB multimedia playback and recording; Q Processing engine; Smart
Things smart home support; Eden 2.0 smart system; voice recognition and control;
Ambient Mode for low-powered screen saver; direct lighting with hundreds of
dimming zones; QLED technology; 4K HDR VOD apps; One Connect box
PARTNER WITH
_ SAMSUNG HW-K950:
The HW-K950 is approaching
two years old but remains
the A-lister in Samsung's
cast of soundbars. Atmos-
enabled, with wireless rears
and subwoofer for a 5.1.4
array, this £1,200 system
sounds sublime.
Rounding out this TV's picture charms are a slightly
expanded viewing angle (but by no means the best
around), precise and controlled standard dynamic range
playback, and an improved version of Samsung’s HDR+
system, which converts standard dynamic range content
to something approaching HDR.
It’s not possible yet to do any meaningful comparisons
between HDR10+ and other HDR formats, given that the
only HDR10+ source available is currently Amazon Video.
Shows such as The Grand Tour do look unprecedentedly
good on the QE65Q9FN, though. I suspect this TV's core
image quality is a factor here, of course.
There are a few areas where Samsung could maybe do
more. I couldn’t find any combination of motion processing
features that delivered motion as natural as that available
on Sony’s new XF9005 TV (see page 40). And very
occasionally parts of an image can flicker quite obviously,
as if the TV is struggling to decide which backlighting setup
to use. Samsung claims to be working on a fix for this.
Lastly, I found details being marginally crushed out of
the picture during dark scenes while using the TV’s presets
(except for, perhaps, the Movie one). This is fairly easily
remedied by nudging up the picture’s Gamma.
On a final positive note, this is a powerful audio
performer. Its hidden speakers have healthy volume and
dynamic range, a decent low-end, and create a coherent
sense of audio space that extends well beyond the TV’s
physical boundaries.
3. The desktop stand
doubles as a conduit
for the One Connect
'near invisible 1 cable
The colour of magic
Next up: colour. This 65-incher proves sensational when
it comes to unlocking the impact of Justice League’s
expansive palette. Tones across the board are fantastically
vibrant, benefitting from the colour 'volume' on tap. But
they're stable and balanced too, as opposed to simply
pushed, and the screen displays the smallest tonal shift
or subtle blend. This raises the feeling of innate sharpness
and detail of 4K content.
The QE65Q9FN handles HDR colour blends - even
the difficult-to-manage white clouds around the aliens
in Arrival (Ultra HD Blu-ray) - without any sign of the
distracting striping interference witnessed on previous
Samsung generations.
Let battle commence
With the QE65Q9FN, Samsung has reminded us how
good LED TVs can be. Put simply, it offers the best 4K HDR
picture quality I've ever seen - and ups its appeal via a
well-engineered smart platform and user-friendly features.
The battle for the future of television is back on ■
HCC VERDICT
★★★★★
Samsung QE65Q9FN
£3, 800Hwww.samsung.co.uk
Unprecedented colour and brightness combine with the
LED world’s best backlight controls to deliver the finest HDR
pictures seen to date.
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
Sapphire
SSP from
"Ultimate Range" Only £1,416.00
of Tab Tensioned In-ceiling Screens
For when only the best will do ...
Imagine if . Oo Q
* You had a screen that was almost invisible to
visitors until in use. When you finish viewing
the trap door closes magically to hide the fabric.
* If the motor and the structure was designed to
be whisper quiet.
* If the screen was able to drop down
automatically when you turn on your projector.
* If the fabric was one of the best in the business
for 4K projection giving vibrant colour with a
perfectly flat soft tensioned surface.
* If the product had a 5 year comprehensive
warranty.
Dreams are now
reality!
Model Numbers
VIEWING SIZe
(MM) <L+H>
size
(FEET)
CASINO (MM)
(L+H+O)
ASPECT
SETCZOUWSF-ATR
£020 x 1140
SO" x 45"
2525 x 1 55 x 1TO
15:9
StTC240WS F-ATR
2340X1320
02” x H2”
2935 x 1 55 x 176
ia:9
SETG270WSF-ATR
2670x1500
105" x SO"
3245 x 1 55 x 1 TO
15:9
Available for next day delivery
from many quality retailers and
distributors in UK and Ireland
www.sapphireav.com
EwtsiWS
•steljes
✓ audio
r
SOLAR
YELLOW
FROST
WHITE
r
LAGOON
BLUE
GUN METAL
GREY
VERMILION
RED
ARTISAN
BLUE
COAL
BLAC4
Crystal Clear Sound
with Bluetooth on all products
QR
Code
www.steljesaudio.co.uk
Premier Group (UK) Ltd - Home of
Sapphire, ConxEasy and Steljes Audio
64 LG UP970/£170
Why so Blu?
Does a long overdue Dolby Vision firmware update give
this affordable 4K deck a boost over the competition?
Steve May isn't convinced
A front USB port enables
flash drive media playback
SPECIFICATIONS
ULTRA HD: Yes HDR: Yes. HDR10; Dolby Vision
UPSCALING: Yes. To 2160p MULTIREGION: No,
Region B BD/R2 DVD HDMI: Yes. 2 x outputs
(one audio-only) COMPONENT VIDEO: No
MULTICHANNEL ANALOGUE: No DIGITAL
AUDIO: Yes. Optical audio output
ETHERNET: Yes BUILT IN WI-FI: Yes
SACD/DVD-A: No/No DIMENSIONS: 430(w) x
45(h) x205(d)mm WEIGHT: 1.63kg
FEATURES: USB port; smart portal with
Netflix and YouTube 4K apps; setup wizard;
file support includes MPEG, MKV, MOV, MP3,
AIFF, AAC, FLAC, WAV, OGG and WMA
LG MAY HAVE relentlessly pursued the
premium end of the TV market with its 4K
OLED and LED models, but the UP970 is very
much cut from the same budget cloth as its
previous 2K Blu-ray offerings.
The player is full-width (430mm) but thin.
It's anonymously smart, although clearly a
commodity product. Don't expect to find the
same level of build quality here as on Oppo’s
premium Dolby Vision players. It's more akin
to the Panasonic DMP-UB300 and Samsung
UBD-K8500.
As is LG's long-standing want, the UP970
has little stick-on transport buttons
positioned beside a front-facing USB port
disguised by a tethered cover. There's no
on-body status display, just very discreet
green and red LEDs.
The rear of the deck is similarly stripped
back. There are two HDMI outputs, with the
second designated audio-only for use with
non-4K capable AV receivers. There's also
an optical digital audio output, plus Ethernet
to accompany
AVINFO
PRODUCT.
Bargain-priced 4K
disc player with
Dolby Vision support
i mm
LG's solo Dolby
Vision player
Panasonic
DMP-UB300;
Samsung UBD-K8500
integrated Wi-Fi.
The supplied
IR remote control
is short and dumpy.
And operationally this
player leaves a lot to
be desired. The USB
reader, for instance,
seems unnecessarily
fussy. While some
thumbdrives
were recognised,
others weren’t.
The player's user interface will be familiar
to owners of previous LG Blu-ray hardware,
comprising a strip of horizontal graphics
designated Movie, Photo, Music, Premium and
Settings. Premium is where you'll find just two
streaming services, Netflix and YouTube, both
of which play in 4K.
The settings menu is somewhat coy, and
doesn’t proffer much control over what this
deck can do. When it comes to display output,
there's Auto or forced settings from 480p to
2,160p, plus an HDMI colour option (YCbCr
or RGB). There's no user definable bit-depth
or chroma output.
Picture performance is average - I noted
artefacts vibrating on high-frequency 4K
detail on UHD test platters. The player also
appears to emphasise grain and noise.
You can alter characteristics of the image,
using the supplied output modes (Standard,
Vivid, Movie and User, the latter allowing
you to adjust contrast, brightness, colour
and sharpness), but I certainly wouldn’t
want to entrust image processing to this
particular box.
Dolby touches down
The UP970 now supports both standard
HDR10 and Dolby Vision, although the deck
waited quite some time for DV to land (and
did so after my review period). An early
attempt to deploy firmware late last year was
abandoned, when it inadvertently switched
the region code of all players to the US.
Bizarrely, I actually think the deck looks
its best with standard Blu-rays. CG animation
Astro Boy is all futuristic neon and deep
colours, which the player handles well.
Images are smooth without aliasing.
Terrence Malick's The Thin Red Line tries
valiantly to maintain its lush hues. When the
GIs land at Guadalcanal, there's band-free
colour in the sky, sea and sand. The troops'
helmets reveal pock marks and exhibit
convincing texture.
The UP970 itself isn't the quietest, being
noticeably more noisy spinning UHD discs
than standard Blu-rays and CDs. On the plus
side, it’s at least a speedy loader. A menu-
heavy movie disc goes from tray to menu in
34 seconds, while a simple concert platter
was up and running in just 25.
CD playback is downright poor, with the
UP970 making an indistinct hash of the
soundstage. A classical suite of strings and
oboe had a strange, phasey, drifting quality.
Basically speaking
After the best part of a year in limbo, the
appeal of the UP970 now rests entirely on
its Dolby Vision support and its bargain £170
(or thereabouts) price tag. Unfortunately
these factors alone don't make up for its
many budget shortcomings. Image quality is
below the best, build quality basic and audio
performance underwhelming ■
HCC VER DICT ★★★★★
E£170 www.lg.com/uk
T Compatible screen owners will be
tempted by this budget deck's Dolby Vision
playback, but overall it's uninspiring.
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
HITACHI 75HL16T64U/£1,350
65
Hitachi's XXL TV
The size and price tag of this 4K HDR flatscreen certainly make
it look tempting on paper. But can it keep its appeal once
John Archer has put it through its paces?
THE APPEAL OF the Argos-exclusive Hitachi
75HL16T64U is brutally simple. It gives you
75 inches of native 4K, HDR-capable pictures
for just £1,350. It quickly becomes apparent,
though, that its bigscreen bargain status
comes with some pretty hefty performance
strings attached.
For starters, the design is largely uninspired.
The frame is wider than most and wears a dull
black finish, while its feet are just there to do
a job rather than look stylish.
The rear of the TV sports four carry handles
- the first time I’ve seen these outside of the
commercial display world for years. They do
aid setup, though, even if they make wall¬
hanging the set pretty much impossible.
Connections are decent for the
75HL16T64U’s money, with highlights being
three HDMI inputs and
two USBs. Two of the
HDMIs handle 4K HDR
feeds, but they don’t
have the capacity to
retain HDR support
when playing the
60fps images of Billy
Lynn’s Long Half-Time
Walk (4K BD). The
only HDR format
supported is HDR10.
Surprisingly for its
price, this megascreen
offers a decent smart TV platform that
includes support for Netflix and YouTube,
as well as the catch-up TV portals for all
of the UK’s main services within the Freeview
Play wrapper.
The Netflix app supports 4K and HDR,
but YouTube only seemed to work in HD SDR.
Note that there’s currently no Amazon Video.
Making hard work of HDR
The most important thing you need to
know about the 75HL16T64U’s picture
performance is that it’s pretty much a bust
with high dynamic range. The set can’t sustain
nearly enough average or peak brightness
to deliver a true HDR effect. It also clips quite
severely, robbing the brightest HDR areas of
almost all detail.
Watching Elisa’s night-time journeys to
work in The Shape Of Water on 4K Blu-ray
reveals a pretty dramatic lack of contrast with
HDR content. Dark areas appear washed out
and grey, and there’s some obvious yellow
backlight ‘creep’ in the corners and sides
of the image.
The Shape Of Water’s rich, thematic colour
palette also catches the TV out. Despite
the panel claiming to support a wide colour
gamut, colours are flat, murky and unnatural.
They’re affected, too, by an unpleasant
yellowy undertone that I could find no means
of completely calibrating away.
AVINFO
Affordable 75in LCD
TV with 4K HDR
S
The most premium
screen in Vestel’s
Hitachi-branded
UK range
PEERS.
Hisense
H75N6800UK
SPECIFICATIONS
3D: No 4K; Yes. 3,840x2,160
HDR: Yes. HDR10 TUNER: Yes. Freeview HD
CONNECTIONS: 3 x HDMI inputs (2 x 4K/HDR
capable); 2 x USB; RFInput; Ethernet SOUND
(CLAIMED): N/A BRIGHTNESS (CLAIMED):
N/A CONTRAST RATIO (CLAIMED): N/A
DIMENSIONS (ONSTAND): l,684(w) x 1,026(h)
x370(d)mm WEIGHT (ON STAND): 37kg
FEATURES: Built-in Wi-Fi; USB multimedia
playback; network multimedia playback;
SmartVue smart engine; Freeview Play
built-in; noise reduction; skin tone and
colour shift options
The smart platform includes a 4K HDR Netflix app
While the set struggles badly with HDR, it’s
better with 4K SDR than you might perhaps
expect. Such pictures - as delivered, for
instance, by Better Call Saul on Netflix - are
crisp and sharp, and are impacted surprisingly
little by motion blur. Colours gain a more
natural feel, and, ironically, feel richer too.
Black levels, though, are still a problem.
So much so that it’s not just dark sequences
that look greyed over; pretty much any
interior scene has its colours muted and
depth reduced by the amount of greyness
pervading the screen. You can still see pools
of excess lighting in the corners, too.
Other issues noted during my tests
were limited viewing angles, some so-called
‘dirty screen effect’ during pans across bright
skies or football pitches, and pretty basic 4K
upscaling that leaves HD sources looking
rather soft and noisy.
The 75HL16T64U’s sound is respectable,
however. It can go decently loud, benefits
from a fair amount of bass, and handles
treble details without sounding harsh.
Sizing it up
If you’re motivated by screen size and screen
size alone, then thanks to its 4K sharpness
and decent SDR colour performance, you
could consider buying Hitachi's 75HL16T64U.
Partner it with a product that’s good at
stripping HDR out of 4K Blu-rays, such as one
of Panasonic’s premium 4K players, or stick
to an SDR diet, and the sheer vastness of
its panel may make up for its average blacks.
But an inability to handle HDR material
in any pleasing way may lead to a reluctant
conclusion no home cinema fan likes to
reach: that sometimes size isn’t everything ■
HCC VERDICT
Hitachi 75HL16T64U
£1,350 www.argos.co.uk
★★★★★
] While it’s better than you might expect
with 4K sources, this megascreen comes a
cropper with HDR and has average black levels.
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
66 WWW.CELL0ELECTR0NICS.COM/E300
Cello C32277T2
There's no need to scare kids witless with campfire stories anymore, says Steve May
THIS TV FROM UK manufacturer Cello
isn’t just another portable. It’s battery-
powered, which basically means you
can take it on the road or install it in
the garden on a balmy Summer night.
Fully charged, Cello quotes an impressive
10-hour usage when the screen runs on
its most eco of settings.
Everything you need, plus a bit more,
is in the box. The set even comes with two
long-lead LED lights which plug directly
into the back. These are bright enough to
illuminate a tent or patio.
To the rear you’ll find two HDMIs and a PC
VGA input. There are four USB ports, two for
media playback or recording onto an external
hard drive. The other two can recharge a
smartphone, or power a streaming dongle
if you’re setting up in a Wi-Fi hotspot. It's nice
attention to detail.
The onboard USB media player handles
music and movies, provided the file types
aren’t too fancy. I had no problem playing
WMV, MPEG, AVI and MOVs, although MKVs
weirdly played without audio.
The panel resolution is720p, and contrast
is rated at 4,000:1. Given that it isn’t
intended for image-critical viewing, this is
mostly fine - a bigger display might demand
a Full HD pixel count, but would then be far
less portable.
There's a 22in model available too
Picture vibrancy depends on your
chosen Power Save mode. This offers
a default option of 6-10 hours use,
which significantly dims the screen, or
4-6 hours use, which is a little brighter.
There’s also a full-brightness Daytime
mode. It’s only worth running the most
economic of power modes when you
really need the extended battery.
The idea of a battery-powered TV
may sound a bit nutty, but this package
works flawlessly in the wild. Image quality
isn't the major attraction, but the power
saving options are generous and it has useful
features. Caravanners should love it ■
HCC VERDICT ★★★★★
Cello C32277T2
-* £300 ■ www.celloelectronics.com
WWW.AIRPULSEAUDI0.COM/E800
Airpulse Audio A200
These speakers' premium build and ribbon tweeters have Steve May grinning all over
WHILE THE BRAND may not be familiar,
the designer behind Airpulse Audio might be.
Phil Jones helped found British hi-fi outfit
Acoustic Energy, and was responsible for
a run of high-performing designs. These
studio-style active monitor speakers are
built from comparable sonic DNA.
Build quality and cosmetics are
unmistakably premium: the cherry wood
cabinetry has a lush, satin-lacquer finish that
is definitely living room friendly.
Built into the enclosures are 5.5in midbass
drivers with stiff aluminium cones, and
horn-loaded ribbon tweeters.
These tweeters are key to the Airpulse
Audio A200’s outstanding detail. A CD rip
of Blondie’s Sunday Girl is conveyed as fresh
and punky; the scritch of guitar and percussive
detail sounding as exciting as a night on the
town in 1970s New York.
Connectivity is good. The integrated amp
on the 'master' speaker (which links to the
'slave' via a supplied cable)
links to two analogue inputs
(one balanced), plus two
digital (optical and coaxial)
audio ports. There’s also
Bluetooth aptX support for
direct streaming. A claimed
2 x 10W drives the ribbon
tweeters, with 2 x 55W
feeding the woofers. The rear
panel section has volume,
bass and treble knobs, all
offering a tactile incremental
movement. A remote makes
source switching simple.
While the A200s expend most of their
energy above 50Hz, that doesn’t mean they
can’t rock. Sweet Leaf {Black Sabbath),
remastered in MQA for the Ten Year War
boxset, is pure excitement with engaging
stereo imaging. The speakers are high-res
audio capable, handling signals up to 192kHz.
Audition these if you want active speakers
that outperform the usual wireless suspects
when it comes to scale and resolution ■
HCC VERDICT ★★★★★
Airpulse Audio A200
-» £800 www.airpulseaudio.com
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
SAMSUNG
tter.
n simplicity.
Our clever near-invisible optical cable makes it simple to connect
all your home entertainment, so you can place devices discreetly
elsewhere. It's amazing how something you can barely see
makes your QLED TV even more pleasing on the eye.
QLEDTV
The Next Innovation in TV
Find out more about QLED TV at Samsung.com
Power cable not shown.
Great Savings
iX F900STVpro«
AKHORPfeW**
VWC’ 1 w'.
ujds4w*r$ 1
1
fwm*9
ESnOW*^
nirnkilr
llPISVjiii
Room reborn
when you subscribe to Home Cinema Choice today
13 issues delivered to your door
Great savings on the shop price
Download each new issue to your device
A 74% discount on your Digital subscription
Access your subscription on multiple devices
PRINT
SUBSCRIPTION
13 issues delivered to your door
Great savings on the shop price
Never miss an issue
DIGITAL-ONLY
SUBSCRIPTIONS
/ AVAILABLE
ONLINE...
SUBSCRIBE TODAY
SUBSCRIBE SECURELY ONLINE
^ http://hcc.secureorder.co.uk/HCC/HCC0518P
TERMS & CONDITIONS: Offer ends 17th May 2018. *Discounts may vary dependent on payment method selected. Please see www.homecinemachoice.com/terms for full terms & conditions
IN EVERY ISSUE
Kit reviews, movies and TV,
installs, accessories,
insight, opinion,
competitions + more
CALL OUR ORDER LINE
(5)0344 243 9023 (quote ref HCC0518P)
_Lines open Mon - Fri - 8.00am - 8.00pm GMT & Sat - 9.30am - 3.30pm GMT
UK Calls costs 7p per minute plus your phone company’s access charge. Overseas calls will cost more
HOME
CINEMA SUBSCRIPTION ORDER FORM
DIRECT DEBIT SUBSCRIPTIONS UK ONLY
Yes, I would like to subscribe to Home Cinema Choice
□ Print + Digital: £13.25 every 3 months
□ Print: £10.99 every 3 months
YOUR DETAILS must be completed
Mr/Mrs/Miss/Ms..
Address.
. Initial.Surname-
Postcode .Country..
Tel.Mobile.
Email.D.O.B.
1 WOULD LIKE TO SEND A GIFT TO:
Mr/Mrs/Miss/Ms.
Address.
.Initial.Surname.
; Postcode.
.Country.
INSTRUCTIONS TO YOUR BANK/BUILDING SOCIETY
Originator's reference 422562
Name of bank.
Address of bank.
< 3 >
.Postcode.
Account holder.
Signature.Date..
Sort code
Account number
Instructions to your bank or building society: Please pay MyTimeMedia Ltd. Direct Debits from
the account detailed in this instruction subject to the safeguards assured by the Direct Debit
Guarantee. I understand that this instruction may remain with MyTimeMedia Ltd and if so, details
will be passed electronically to my bank/building society.
Reference Number (official use only)
Please note that banks and building societies may not accept Direct Debit instructions from
some types of account.
CARD PAYMENTS & OVERSEAS
J
Yes, I would like to subscribe to Home Cinema Choice, for 1 year
(13 issues) with a one-off payment
UK ONLY:
□ Print + Digital: £56.00
□ Print: £47.00
EUROPE & ROW:
□ EU Print + Digital: £77.00
□ EU Print: £68.00
□ ROW Print + Digital: £77.00
□ ROW Print: £68.00
PAYMENT DETAILS
□ Postal Order/Cheque □Visa/MasterCard □Maestro
Please make cheques payable to MyTimeMedia Ltd and write code HCC0518P on the back
Cardholder's name.
Card no:
(Maestro)
Valid from.
Signature.
.Expiry date.
.Maestro issue no.
.Date.
Offer ends 17th May 2018. MyTimeMedia Ltd & Home Cinema Choice may contact you with information about our other
products and services. If you DO NOT wish to be contacted by MyTimeMedia Ltd & Home Cinema Choice please tick
here: □ Email □ Post □ Phone. If you DO NOT wish to be contacted by carefully chosen 3rd parties, please tick here: □
Post □ Phone. If you wish to be contacted by email by carefully chosen 3rd parties, please tick here: □ Email
POST THIS FORM TO: HOME CINEMA CHOICE,
MY TIME MEDIA LTD, 3 QUEENSBRIDGE, THE LAKES,
NORTHAMPTON, NN4 7BF
Please visit www.homecinemachoice.com/terms for full terms & conditions
CODE HCC0518P
70 COMPETITION
v system
WORTH
£ 1,0000
OP FOR
GRABS!
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
Q ACOUSTICS 7000i 5.1 SLIM 71
Competition rules
1. The first entry drawn at random will win the prize. 2. Only one entry per person/household;
multiple entries will be discarded. 3. Entrants from the UK only. 4. Employees of MyTimeMedia
Ltd and companies supplying competition prizes are not eligible to enter this competition.
5. Please ensure your personal details are correct, as they will be used to contact you if you
win. 6. No alternatives, cash or otherwise, will be offered to the winner as prizes. 7. The editor’s
decision is final. 8. Comp winners' info available upon request. 9. The closing date for entries is
May 24,2018.
Be in with a chance of winning the Q Acoustics
7000i 5.1 Slim by answering the following film
related question:
Q: Which Monty Python actor succeeded Desmond Llewelyn
as Q in the James Bond film franchise?
A) JOHN CLEESE B) ERIC IDLE C) MICHAEL PALIN
HOW TO ENTER: Simply email your answer (either A, B or C) to competitions®
homecinemachoice.com with the subject line ‘Q 1 . You must include your name, address and
contact telephone number.
THE CLOSING DATE for this competition is May 24,2018. Please read the terms and
conditions (below) before sending in your entry.
IN THIS ISSUE we're teaming up with
Q Acoustics to give away a 7000i 5.1 Slim
speaker package worth £1,000! The latest
evolution of the UK speaker expert's premium
sub/sat package, it combines class-leading
performance with a smart, discreet
design (available in black or white finishes).
And it could be yours...
Return to slender
The Slim revamps Q Acoustics' previous
7000i packages with a new 7060S subwoofer
designed to make the system even easier
to accommodate in your viewing room.
Measuring only 6in deep, and using a sealed
box design, you'll have no trouble finding
space for it, while the 8in driver, onboard
150W amp and 35Hz frequency response
rating deliver tight, well-controlled,
cinematic bass.
Joining the 7060S in this multichannel
array are Q Acoustics' neatly styled satellite
speakers. Each model, whether it's the
7000LRi for front and surround channels,
or the 7000Ci centre speaker, features a
two-and-a-half way driver arrangement,
mounting a pair of 3in midbass units either
side of a ring radiator tweeter.
Each satellite features an integrated,
rotatable foot that conceals the speaker
terminals, and cleverly doubles as a discreet
wall-mount. Combined with the svelte
subwoofer, you have a package that oozes
design class and installation flexibility.
Optional stands are available for the 7000
satellites, plus a wall-mount bracket for
the 7060S.
Reviewed in HCC #284, we found the
7000i 5.1 Slim to be a chip off the old Q
Acoustics block, describing it as 'sweet¬
sounding'. Performance is excellent, with
seamless integration throughout
the soundstage delivering panning
effects with aplomb. The array
has consistent tonality and digs
out clear, crisp detail from movie
soundtracks, while the bass hits
from the 7060S blend in perfectly.
The cabinets may be relatively
small, but the overall experience
is big and deliciously convincing.
If you fancy being in with a chance of
winning this smart-looking, high-performance
5.1 package, simply answer the question below
correctly - and good luck! ■
For more information on Q Acoustics' range of
loudspeakers, soundbars and audio accessories,
visit www.qacoustics.co.uk
'Combine the curved cabinets
with the svelte subwoofer,
and you have a package that
oozes design class and
installation flexibility'
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
72 REVIEWS
LONG-TERM TEST
Focal Sib Evo
Dolby Atmos 5.1.2
build and sonics. This isn't the case here: Focal's array
carries an £1,100 asking price and for the most part lives
up to expectation.
Unpack the Sib Evo Dolby Atmos 5.1.2 and you're
greeted by weighty enclosures that seem impressively
constructed. They sport full-frontal grilles to protect their
drivers, a neat Focal logo on each cabinet, and - while not
seamless in construction - can stand up to the odd bump
and knock. I know this, because I dropped one of them.
At their heart the speakers are two-way models, using
5in midbass drivers and 0.75in tweeters for a full-range
performance. The front L/R pair also carry additional
3in upfiring drivers.
The supplied subwoofer, while not a complete match
in terms of aesthetic finish, is of the type that makes
installation a breeze. Only 30cm high and with a front
port and downward-firing woofer, it's easy to shift
around your room should you want to experiment with
placement. I found it performed admirably in a front
corner position.
TIUEONTEST: Seven months REVIEWER: Mark Craven
AVINFO
PRODUCT:
Atmos-equipped
sub/sat speaker
package
POSITION
Focal's premium
smallscale system
Samsung FIW-K950;
Wharfedale
Diamond 11 HCP
LAST SUMMER, THE French audio company Focal
entered the arena of Dolby Atmos speakers with a sub/sat
system - an idea that no other brand had apparently
considered at the time. The likes of KEF, ELAC and PSB
had targeted those with speaker setups already in place
with upfiring Dolby Atmos modules. Here was a 5.1.2 option
designed for those who wanted an entire package.
Eight months on, the Sib Evo Dolby Atmos 5.1.2 remains
the only Atmos-equipped sub/sat system you can buy
(to the best of my knowledge). How long before other
companies follow suit?
What’s good about it?
There are various sub/sat systems available that cater
to those on tight budgets, and some are guilty of reaching
so low in terms of pricing that the joy of a discrete
multichannel package becomes obscured by poor-quality
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
REVIEWS 73
Up and running, the system makes a clear case for
Dolby Atmos audio, even on this smaller scale. AV purists
may tell you that a quartet of ceiling-mounted speakers
is the only way to go, but that's a viewpoint that ignores
the lifestyles and budgets of the majority of film fans.
This system just needs a seven-channel AVR, a bit of
effort regards calibration, and a good Blu-ray to show
what it can do.
This package makes a clear
case for Dolby Atmos audio,
with a tangible impact from
its height-channel drivers'
There's a precision and poise to its overall delivery
that's easy to like, and which serves as a reminder that
this isn't a budget option. High-frequency details are
crisp but not crass, and the drive and nuance of those 5in
midbass drivers a major attraction. The crossover to the
Sib Cub Evo subwoofer is well handled.
Atmos impact from this system's duo of height-
channel drivers can be surprisingly tangible. Again and
again I've experienced 'lift-your-head' moments as Atmos
effects are thrown skywards - a recent runout of horror
flick Annabelle: Creation found this 5.1.2 setup cranking
up the tension with spine-tingling, creaky FX from around
and atop the soundstage. It doesn't challenge the
largescale experience of a premium floorstanding package,
but it's genuinely impressive how this compact array can
place you amidst a soundmix.
What’s not so good about it?
The most obvious drawback here is the overall size of
the cabinets - mainly the left and right enclosures with
their Atmos upfiring drivers. They're neither small
enough to really disappear into a home entertainment
system, nor carry the imposing style of standmount
SPECIFICATIONS
Sib Evo Dolby Atmos
DRIVE UNITS: 1 x 5in Polyflex midbass; 1 x 0.75in soft dome tweeter; 1 x 3in full-range
Dolby Atmos driver ENCLOSURE: Rear-ported Dolby Atmos speaker FREQUENCY
RESPONSE (CLAIMED): 65Hz-25kHz (90Hz-20kHz for Atmos driver) SENSITIVITY
(CLAIMED): 90dB POWER HANDLING (CLAIMED): 25W-200W DIMENSIONS: 295(h) x
195(w)xl90(d)mm WEIGHT: 3.25kg
Sib Evo
DRIVE UNITS: 1 x 5in Polyflex midbass; 1 x 0.75in soft dome tweeter ENCLOSURE:
Rear-ported FREQUENCY RESPONSE (CLAIMED): 70Hz-25kHz SENSITIVITY (CLAIMED):
90dB POWER HANDLING (CLAIMED): 25W-200W DIMENSIONS: 252(h) xl62(w) x
162(d)mm WEIGHT: 1.8kg
Sib Cub Evo (subwoofer)
DRIVE UNITS: 1 x 8.25in downfiring Polyflex woofer ENCLOSURE: Front-ported
FREQUENCY RESPONSE (CLAIMED): 35Hz-150Hz ONBOARD POWER (CLAIMED): 200W
REMOTE CONTROL: No DIMENSIONS: 305(h) x 208(w) x 299(d)mm WEIGHT: 8kg
CONNECTIONS: LFE input; stereo phono input
speakers that you'll want to show off. Equally, positioning
them at ear-height, to best aid their ceiling reflective
driver, makes them less easy to find space for than most
satellite speakers, where often an optimum position is
forgone in favour of a neat installation. Ideally, you'll want
to either wall-mount or standmount them (Focal sells its
own Hip Evo stand).
Bare-wire speaker terminals across the range may
have you tweaking your own cabling and - at least at first
- cursing the fiddling required to lace up the L/R models,
which feature both front and Atmos terminals. Once this
has been done, of course, you're unlikely to have to do it
again for a while.
While the sound performance of the Sib Evo Dolby
Atmos 5.1.2 is generally bang on the money, other packages
that have been through my room have thrown a light on its
dry, analytical nature. In particular, Wharfedale's Diamond
11 HOP [see HCC #279] showed a warmer tone - and
more rambunctious approach to LFE - than this more
cool, calculated setup. So while I've consistently loved its
detailed and lean sound signature, a little bit of unbridled
aggression wouldn't go astray.
Another niggle here is that there's no obvious path to
a 5.1.4 setup. You can buy additional Atmos speakers as
a pair, but this actually gets you a 7.1.4 setup.
Should I buy it?
I'd suggest the Sib Evo Dolby Atmos 5.1.2 really has only
one potential buyer - the home cinema fan seeking to
replace a 5.1-channel sub/sat package (or soundbar
system) with something a little more state-of-the-art.
If that's you, you have to give it consideration, not least
because adding standalone Atmos speakers to any existing
sub/sat array is going to be a style compromise with its
own placement issues to overcome.
What this well-performing package offers is a one-stop
Atmos upgrade. The asking price isn't inconsiderable, but
there's plenty here to admire ■
7. Backing up the
satellite speakers is
the 8.25inSibCub
Evo subwoofer
2. The L/R speakers
pack a top-mounted
3in Atmos driver
HCC VERDICT ★★★★★
Focal Sib Evo Dolby Atmos
£1,100 www.focal.com/uk
Focal's Sib Evo system is the ideal Atmos upgrade for
sub/sat owners, offering an assured sound performance and
a robust, classy construction.
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
MARATA VISION SONY 4K
VPL-VW760ES
Atrilumindb
DISPLAY
SttU^iei Jt-tMl RnllBCtlva OitplJW
• NEW Native 4K HDR LASER Projector
• 4K Resolution: 4096 x 2160
• Laser Light Source
• 2000 ANSI Lumen Brightness
• Up to 20,000 Hours Maintenance Free
• HDR Compatibility
• Exceptional Dynamic Contrast
• 4K Motionflow and Reality Creation
T: 01923 495595 F: 01923 495599 E: info@marata.co.uk www.marata.co.uk
Marata Vision 20 Greenhill Crescent, Watford Business Park, Watford, Herts, WD18 8JA. UK
OPINION
Digital Copy
As a well-known UK home electronics retailer struggles to stay afloat, Mark Craven sings
the praises of shopping with your eyes and ears rather than your keyboard and mouse
IT'S NOT BEEN a great year so far for the UK high
street, with retailers and restaurants all posting dire
financial warnings or falling into administration. And
in the latter camp is Maplin, a business that I expect
some of you are familiar with.
I was never a frequent shopper at Maplin, but
clearly remember the last time I went to one of its
stores. It was a Sunday, and I was in urgent need of
a phono cable to hook up a subwoofer. Maplin is
where I ended up.
For those who never experienced this UK
technology retailer, it always felt to me like the
middle ground between PC World and a specialist
independent shop, where big-brand soundbars
and headphones would clamour for shelf-space
alongside Ethernet switches and home security
widgets. When it was placed in administration
at the end of February, it had over 200 stores.
The reasons given for Maplin's demise are
varied, and not just, 'It's impossible to compete
with Amazon 1 . Increased costs of imports, following
the devaluation of the pound since June 2016, plus
withdrawal of credit insurance, have been suggested
as factors. Yet I'd also imagine the consumer shift
away from bricks and mortar retail has taken its
toll on a business with such a physical presence,
selling products that, for the most part, don't
demand a 'see-before-you-buy' mentality.
A visit to Maplin wasn't like going
to the furniture department at John
Lewis - it was like walking around a 3D recreation
of a mail-order catalogue.
Maplin may yet rise again, as FIMV has done,
or it may go the same way as Blockbuster. Either
way, its administration is another reminder that
names that have long been part of the UK retail
landscape can come a cropper.
In the palm of your hand
Can the rest of the home electronics industry prove
more resilient? I certainly hope so, as a future where
all purchases are made online doesn't excite me
much - and not just because any business model
that asks the customer to accept a delivery 'between
9am and 5pm' is guaranteed to annoy.
When I buy things, I generally like to have a look
at the thing I'm buying. There's a rough correlation
between how expensive something is and how
eager I am to see it, of course -1 wouldn't buy a
house before poking my head in the airing cupboard
- but even cheap items I like to pick up and prod.
It's why I still buy books in bookshops.
And when it comes to AV kit, I'm a huge believer in
experiencing something first-hand. No speaker/amp
combo sounds the same, and no TVs look the same,
and everyone has a personal preference.
Get down to your local AV retailer (or even a
not-so-local AV retailer) and you should be able
to experience what you want to buy, ask questions
and get sensible, informed answers.
What you do next is up to you. Rather than
handing over your bank card, you might consider
feigning indifference, heading home and trying to
buy the same thing at a cheaper price from an online
seller. I've been told by a number of AV specialists
that this sort of thing happens from time to time.
It's easy to understand. We're all keen to save money.
But - and it's a big but - if everyone did this, the
next time you want to listen to a 5.1 speaker package,
that shop and its fantastic demo room might not
actually be there any more. We value our home
cinema hardware. We should also value the retailers
that put in the effort to sell it to us ■
Do you have a favourite AV retailer?
Let us know: email letters@homecinemachoice.com
his food shopping
online, as it's the
only way to make
sure he doesn't
'accidentally' buy a
two-litre tub of
clotted ice cream
MAIN IMAGE: SHUTTERSTOCK.COM/MICHAELASBEST
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
76 OPINION
Film Fanatic
Anton van Beek blames an entire decade for ruining the Oscars, and wishes the organisation
behind these awards wasn't so afraid of reflecting mainstream passions
THE AWARDS SEASON is over for another year
and, no matter how happy we were to see Guillermo
del Toro’s The Shape of Water nab the Academy
Award for Best Picture, it has shown yet again
just how divorced these events have become from
popular tastes.
Do I believe that The Fate of the Furious or Wonder
Woman should have been in the running for the
Best Picture Oscar? No. But since the number of
nominations in that category pretty much doubled
in 2009 (from five to ten, but now apparently settled
at nine), you'd think there'd be space
for more films along the lines of
Christopher Nolan’s Dunkirk ; ones that
manage to straddle that middle-ground between
box office success and critical acclaim.
It hasn't always been this way. And putting
together the list of discs that would be included in
this issue's Collecting... Best Picture Winners feature
[see pi06] hammered that home.
Right up through the 1960s the Academy Awards
established a history of celebrating populist films,
handing over its Best Picture prize to An American in
Paris, From Here to Eternity, Around the World in 80
Days, The Bridge on the River Kwai, Ben-Hur, West Side
Story, Lawrence of Arabia and The Sound of Music.
Meanwhile, films that found themselves nominated
in the same category included Double Indemnity,
The Bells of St. Mary’s, The Treasure of Sierra Madre,
High Noon, The Quiet Man, Shane, Seven Brides for
Seven Brothers, The Guns of Navarone, Cleopatra,
How the West Was Won, Mary Poppins, Bonnie and
Clyde and Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid.
Even during the 1970s, that revolutionary era
where a new breed of tyro filmmakers subverted the
traditional methods of production, we still witnessed
films likes Airport, M*A*S*H, Deliverance, American
Graffiti, The Sting, The Exorcist, The Towering Inferno,
Jaws, Rocky and Star Wars competing for the top
prize. The odds of a genre blockbuster in the same
vein as Jaws or Star l/l/arsdoingthe same thing today
is almost unthinkable.
The decade of disaster
So where did it all go wrong? A look at films that
were nominated and/or won the Best Picture Oscar
over the decades throws up a simple answer: the
1980s happened.
For whatever reason, throughout the '80s the
focus of the Best Picture gong shifted away from
straight-up cinematic hits to 'prestige' pictures like
Dangerous Liaisons (pictured) and Out of Africa,
and intimate dramas such as On Golden Pond and
Children of a Lesser God. Steven Spielberg's Raiders
of the Lost Ark and E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial were the
only exceptions to this dreary state of affairs, but
they arrived at the very start of the decade (1981
and 1982, respectively), and they failed to grab
the coveted prize anyway.
You can shock yourself viewing a list of all the
movies nominated by the Academy during the 1980s.
Was this organisation really trying to tell cinemagoers
that Fatal Attraction was one of the five best films
released in 1987? For your reference, that would be
the same 1987 that gave us Lethal Weapon, Predator,
The Untouchables, Full Metal Jacket and RoboCop.
Yes, more populist fare has been rewarded over
the past couple of decades (such as Gladiator in
2000), but things could still be a lot better. It's time
the Academy realised there's plenty to enjoy about
blockbuster movies, and there's no shame in glorying
in a film's box office success ■
Would you like to see more blockbusters nominated for Oscars?
Let us know: email letters@homecinemachoice.com
is proud that of the
50 films nominated
for the Best Picture
Oscar during the
1980s, he only has
eight among his
disc collection
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
Audio Express
Hot Deals on top brands, plus FREE overnight* delivery!
Prices Include VAT • Choose Your Own Delivery Date •
Acoustic Energy 108
150 Watt Sub (black or walnut)
Q Acoustics 3000 (5.1)
(Mint, Open Box)
£379 £159 ) (-£775- £550 )
2 Year Guarantees • Authorised Dealer For 30 Years
Q Acoustics 3050 (5.1)
(Mint, Open Box)
^£H6fr £830 )
Canton InCeiling 865 (1 pair)
In-ceiling Atmos Speakers
£399 £189 j
Q Acoustics M2 Sound base
(Mint, Open Box)
1 £399- £229 )
Denon AVR-X4400H
9.2 Network Receiver
( i£1499- £849 )
Yamaha RX-A1070
7.2 Network Receiver
( -£1299
£999 j
Yamaha RX-A2070
9.2 Network Receiver
( £1699 £1349)
www.audio-express.co.uk nisi
Naim mu-so Qb (Official Naim
Manufacturer Refurbished)
Naim mu-so (Official Naim
Manufacturer Refurbished)
r t
P
u
R
E
S
T
E
R
E
Q Acoustics Concept 20
(Mint, Open Box)
( £37 9 £275 j
Naim Uniti Atom
Cyrus Lyric (Stealth)
Cyrus ONE + Google Chromecast
(Mint, Open Box)
CD/DAC/DAB / Network Amp
Audio (Mint, Open Box)
£1999
£1699 )
£3750
£1799j
£729
£579 j
O Acoustics 3050
(Mint, Open Box)
Focal Aria 926
(Open Box)
t £1999 £1399J
* Overnight delivery ■ terms and conditions apply; please see website for details.
pay withamB^on ■^
Audio Express
Over 1400 five star customer reviews
"Shop with confidence!"
-—■ESSilEE! PayPal
Audio Express\
1 _ J*
Google J
^ RATING y
/Audio Express^
★★★★★
\trustpilot
\ RATING J
Audio Express (Creative Audio) * 9 Dogpole, Shrewsbury, SY1 1EN • 01743 241924 • 01743 236055
78 OPINION
In The Mix
When it comes to HDR, Jon Thompson says you ain't seen nuthin 1 yet. But can the electronics
industry afford to make its consumers wait around for much longer?
ONE OF THE technologies on display at CES this
year which earned excited coverage in the press was
Micro LED. Samsung had a prototype screen called
The Wall'. It's perhaps more revolutionary than
you might have thought - the first new display
technology for around ten years.
The last major revolutionary launch was OLED,
not by LG which is carrying the flag these days, but
by Sony, which debuted an llin screen back in 2007
- ten years before its bigscreen A1 successor.
Don't hate me, but I reckon we are seeing the end
of life of OLED, as it can't deliver the performance
needed for today's display technology HDR.
It's never going to achieve the brightness of the HDR
specification, and relies on tone mapping; you really
need a 2,000-nit brightness, if not 4,000 nits, to do
the format justice. Tone mapping is useful for
projection, as you are never going to have 1,000 nits
in a dark room. One reason being that it's dangerous
for your eyes and will cause blinding headaches.
We're currently witnessing a kind of HDR-lite from
OLED TVs. At the same time, as it stands virtually no
content is captured in true HDR either. Instead, HDR is
created in the grade, where the dynamic range of the
photography is stretched. (Film-originated material
gives a better result than digitally captured content
due to film's better ability to capture highlights,
looking good pushed to about 2,000 nits).
What we are going to see eventually on a wider
scale is content capture at full dynamic range, and
if you think you have seen HDR, it'll be time to think
again. Such content appears very natural and not
'pushed' in the way a lot of UHD Blu-rays look.
The first true HDR content will probably be sports,
as it's a natural fit, and drama-based productions
will change as momentum occurs and teams adapt
to HDR workflows.
Back to Micro LED. This extreme brightness display
tech is about to get some real traction, as it appears
Apple is now developing it for use in its products. Like
all displays, it's often easier to start by making a small
version than a big one. I wouldn't be surprised if it's
three-to-five years before we see largescreen displays
using this technology available to buy, with a lot of
prototypes shown in the meantime.
Really, though, we need them now. HDR can
have that wow factor, which is why it's always been
viewed as the 'next step' in home cinema. Micro LED,
or Sony's CLEDIS system, should stop people giving
up on HDR as a gimmick because they are not seeing
what it can truly do.
At the moment it's poorly implemented (and
confusing consumers via its different flavours) and
not delivering what it says on the tin. An HDR TV
needs to be truly high dynamic range,
not a just-a-bit-brighter SDR display.
Creatives are so concerned that you can't achieve
true HDR at home that a lot of films are not even
really HDR despite the disc claiming they are. Blade
Runner2049 is only mastered at 181 nits MaxCLL.
Any display can achieve that without using tone
mapping, which is something that scares creatives as
each manufacturer does it differently. No filmmaker
wants their movie messed up by bad picture
processing if they can help it.
By the time true HDR displays start to arrive,
I hope manufacturers won't have blown all the
consumer goodwill. The only way to sell real
high-brightness displays is to tell you that your
previous display wasn't bright enough in the first
place. Your current HDR TV may look great, but it
really should look even greater ■
What has been your favourite HDR experience so far?
Let us know: email letters@homecinemachoice.com
When he's not in
his screening room,
tweets about
7 1 .H
Hollywood gossip,
■ _ y 1
movie-making and
ffl
digital mastering at
/*
@johnnyfocal
r m -yy/JL
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
• STORES NATIONWIDE
• DEMONSTRATION ROOMS
• EXPERT IMPARTIAL ADVICE
• UNRIVALLED PRODUCT RANGE
SEVENOa<S
SOUND & VISION
OFFERING THE VERY BEST SOUND, VISION
AND SERVICE FOR OVER 45 YEARS
ONLINE
INSTORE
SMARTHOME
www.ssav.com
stores nationwide
www.ssav.com/smarthome
OPTOMA UHD51 £1499.00
4K Ultra HD Projector
Packed with the latest technology and features, this compact UHD projector
boasts High Dynamic Range (HDR) compatibility, HDCP 2.2 support and
sophisticated PureMotion frame-interpolation processing which eliminates
motion blurring or image judder. An RGBRGB colour wheel provides
accurate, true to life colour rendition of 100% Rec.709 - perfect for recreating
the big-screen experience at home.
DENON AVC-X8500H £5299.00
AV Amplifier
The Denon Flagship AVC-X8500H powers the next generation of home theatre
with the world’s first 13.2 channel AV Amplifier that supports the latest
immersive audio formats, including Dolby Atmos, DTS:Xand Auro-3D. Built-in
HEOS technology supports Amazon Alexa* and takes music listening to the next
level with wireless whole-home audio.
*The Amazon Alexa feature becomes available in Spring 2018.
PANASONIC DP-UB820 £399.00
4K UHD Blu-ray Player
The Ultra HD Blu-ray Player UB820 faithfully reproduces the director’s
intended images. Unique chroma processing technology maximises the
beauty of 4K HDR content. Network functions also enable enjoyment of various
types of 4K content. Panasonic’s HCX picture processor the result of years of
picture know how and collaboration with Hollywood studios*, are captured in this
Chip tO deliver preCISe colourand picture definition. *Supervised by Panasonic Hollywood Laboratory.
SOME BRANDS/PRODUCTS ARE NOT AVAILABLE AT ALL STORES. SPECIAL OFFERS ARE NOT IN CONJUNCTION WITH ANY OTHER OFFER (NICWAOO).
ADVERT VALID UNTIL 17/05/2018. E&OE
click 3c
collect
by
www.ssav.com
ARCAM • FMJ AVR550 • AV RECEIVER
Dolby Atmos 7.1.4 capable AV receiverthat is equally at home with
high resolution surround sound or two-channel music.
Also Available: ARCAM FMJ AVR390 & FMJ AVR850
NAD • T 758 V3 • AV RECEIVER
Dolby Atmos and BluOS enabled AV receiverwith Hi-Res
audio playback and 4K Ultra HD full support.
Also Available: NAD T 777 V3
DENON • AVR-X6400H • AV RECEIVER
Premium 11.2 channel AV surround receiverwith the latest
audio formats including Dolby Atmos and DTS:X.
Also Available: DENON AVR-X4400H
SONY • STR-DN1080 • AV RECEIVER
With flexible speaker solutions, DTS:Xand Dolby Atmos support, the
STR-DN1080 delivers mighty cinematic surround sound.
Also Available: YAMAHA RX-V683
YAMAHA • RX-A670 • AV RECEIVER
7.2-channel receiver with Dolby Atmos and DTS:X support,
along with Spotify, Bluetooth, AirPlay and MusicCast.
Also Available: YAMAHA RX-V483 & RX-V583
YAMAHA • RX-A1070 • AV RECEIVER
7.2-channel receiver MusicCast, Dolby Atmos and DTS:X
support, along with Spotify, Bluetooth, AirPlay.
Also Available: YAMAHA RX-A870 & RX-A3070
BLUESOUND • PULSE SOUNDBAR
Not only does the PULSE SOUNDBAR not require a subwoofer
to get full natural sound, but it also includes BluOS, Bluesound's
powerful wireless multi-room streaming music app, it’s also an all-
in-one music system that rivals many high-end audio systems.
Q ACOUSTICS • M2 • SOUNDBASE
Delivers stunning TV and audio sound performance from
its 80w amplifier, unique BMR™ wide dispersion sound
technology and built in subwoofer.
KEF • Q50A • DOLBY ATMOS ENABLED SPEAKERS
Designed to bring Dolby Atmos sound into the home using precision
ceiling reflection when placed on top of Q Series speakers.
SONOS • PLAYBAR
SOUNDBAR & WIRELESS SPEAKER
£699
This plug-and-play unit incorporates 9 integrated amplified
speakers. Simply connect it to your TV with the supplied optical
cable to deliver an epic home cinema sound in your own living
room. PLAYBAR can also expand your existing Sonos system.
jm
£017 |
SONY • HT-ST5000
SOUNDBAR/SUB
The Sony HT-ST5000 Dolby Atmos Soundbar
with Subwoofer features 7.1.2 channels,
Hi-Res Audio and wireless streaming. Google
Chromecast and Spotify Connect come built
into this soundbar so you can enjoy music and
movies as they were intended.
PSB • IMAGINEXA • DOLBY ATMOS ENABLED SPEAKERS
Specifically designed to be used as the "elevation" or "height"
speaker in a Dolby Atmos system.
TRADE UP TO
DOLBY ATMOS
& SAVE £200
TRADE IN YOUR OLD SPEAKERS
AND SAVE £200 WHEN YOU
PURCHASE A FOCAL SIB
EVO DOLBY ATMOS
5.1.2 AV SPEAKER
PACKAGE.
DOLBY
ATMOS
Price excluding trade in £1099. Offer available in store only.
T&Cs apply. Not in conjunction with any other offer (NICWAOO).
SONY • VPL-VW260ES • 4K SXRD PROJECTOR
A fantastic option for movie lovers who want an incredible
cinematic experience at home, far beyond the reach of TV.
OPTOMA • UHD65 • 4K DLP PROJECTOR
This projector, incorporating Ultra HD 4K resolution, brings
movies to life with thrilling detail, colour and contrast - taking
entertainment to the next level.
click& b y
collect www.ssav.comwww.ssav.com/smarthome
SAMSUNG B
QLED TV
QE55Q9FN • 55" 4KUHDTV
Pure colour and the best blacks with Samsung’s 2018 Q9F
QLED TV. See nothing else. The Q9F combines HDR 2000 and
Ultra Black Elite to deliver Samsung's best picture quality to
date, a high accolade from the most awarded brand for picture
quality 4 years running. Only Samsung QLED technology
delivers Certified Ultra HD Premium picture quality with 100%
colour volume* displaying overa billion colours that are true-to-life.
The Q9F is the ultimate movie screen illuminated with the highest
HDR brightness levels contrasted with the deepest blacks.
*100% colour volume measured to DCI-P3 Standard.
Also
Available
FREE 5 YEAR
WARRANTY
LG OLED TV HI Thl " a
OLED55C8PLA • 55” OLED 4K UHD TV
Featuring LG's processor a9, an Intelligent Processor - Optimized for
OLED TV, this exclusive processor allows for clean and sharp images with
accurate colour and even more detailed HDR images. OLED pixels create
an astonishingly accurate and wide colour range which is presented on the
perfect black background only available from self emitting pixels. LG TV
can recognise major High Dynamic Range formats such as HLG, HDR 10,
Dolby Vision™ and Technicolor So you get the HDR experience, no matter
what HDR entertainment you're enjoying.
Available B3 E3 FREE 5 YEAR WARRANTY
Panasonic Uk pro |
HDR
TX-55FZ802 • 55” OLED 4K UHD TV _
The FZ802 OLED Series brings Hollywood Grade Picture &
Razor Sharp Style to your home. This elegantly designed TV
is a picture powerhouse. It combines the peerless contrast
capabilities of 4K HDR OLED screen technology with new
Studio Colour HCX picture processing that's been tuned
by a Hollywood colourist to ensure you always get to see
pictures exactly how their creators intended. The FZ802
supports multiple HDR formats, such as HDR10, HDR10+
and Hybrid Log Gamma.
FREE 5 YEAR
WARRANTY
C? OLED
Also Available
B3
SONY
KD-55AF8 • 55” OLED 4K UHD TV
See how Sony's latest OLED screen, processor and sound
technologies come together for breathtaking 4K HDR TV
entertainment. With over 8 million self-illuminating pixels,
you'll see perfect blacks, incredible contrast and authentic
colour in a blur-free image, with a wide viewing angle.
Exclusive to Sony specially designed actuators invisibly
vibrate the TV panel to create amazing sound coming directly
from the screen, for a perfect unification of audio and picture.
Also Available
FREE 5 YEAR FTHI
WARRANTY H DR
SONY
KD-65XF9005 • 65” 4K UHD TV
Also Available
IE1 E51IE1
FREE 5 YEAR
WARRANTY
OPPO • UDP-203 • 4K UHD BLU-RAY PLAYER
Provides an unmatched A N experience to home cinema
enthusiasts and is the ideal source to complete the ultimate
home cinema and sound room.
Also Available: SAMSUNG UBD-M9500
OPPO • UDP-205 • 4K UHD BLU-RAY PLAYER
Drawing from over a decade's worth of experience in
high fidelity audio performance, the UDP-205 is the
perfect choice for discerning enthusiasts.
Also Available: LG UP970
SONY • UBP-X700 • 4K UHD BLU-RAY PLAYER
Find yourself at the heart of every movie and series.
4K Ultra HD Blu-ray shows everything in finer detail than
ever before, so you feel like you're seeing the real thing.
Also Available: SONY UBP-X800
FOR THE LATEST PRICES AND OFFERS VISIT WWW.SSAV.COM OR CONTACT YOUR LOCAL STORE
Bishop’s Stortford 01279 506576
Bristol* 0117 974 3727
Brighton 01273 733338
Bromley 020 8290 1988
Chalfont St Peter* 0845 5046364
Cambridge 01223 304770
Chelsea* 020 7352 9466
Cheltenham* 01242 241171
Epsom* 01372 720720
Exeter* 01392 218895
Guildford 01483 536666
Holborn* 020 7837 7540
Kingston* 020 8547 0717
Loughton 020 8532 0770
Maidstone 01622 686366
Norwich* 01603 767605
NEW Nottingham 0115 988 1703
Oxford 01865 241773
Reading* 01189 477093
Sevenoaks 01732 459555
NEW Solihull 0121 709 0606
Tunbridge Wells 01892 531543
Wetherby 01937 586886
Witham (Essex) 01376 501733
Yeovil* 01935 700078
NEW STORES OPENING IN 2018
For store details, opening hours and
brands stocked visit www.ssav.com
•THESE stores are franchised and operate under
A LICENCE AGREEMENT TO SEVENOAKS SOUND &VISION
Read the
latest issue of
SEVENOAKS
SELECT
digital interactive
magazine today!
www.ssav.com/select
Please Note: Some brands/products are not available at all stores. Special/added
value offers are not in conjunction with any other offer (NICWAOO).
SEVENOa<S
ADVERT VALID UNTIL 17/05/2018. E&OE
SOUND & VISION
8i 4DX HOME CINEMA THROUGH HEADPHONES
Feedback
Got an axe to grind? Need to comment on current tech? Want to share your knowledge with
our readers? Team HCC is here to help
Can I improve my AV setup?
Hi. As a regular reader of Home Cinema
Choice, I like reading about all the latest
speaker systems and receivers and related
AV equipment, even though most of the
technical details go over my head.
My setup is based around the fact that I
have to wear headphones. It's usually late
at night when I get to watch films and not
having a dedicated room means that for now
speakers are not an option.
I have a basic setup. An Epson EH-TW6700
projector fires onto a wall painted with
Smarter Surfaces projector screen paint.
I use a Sony BDP-S5200 Blu-ray player and
Panasonic RP-HTX7 headphones. I plug the
headphones into the back of the projector.
My question is: how do I go about improving
this basic system, in particular the audio?
Would buying better headphones be sufficient,
or do I need to buy an external headphone
amp or an AV receiver? I was looking at
Blue Microphones' Sadie headphones, which
feature a built-in amp. Would these alone be
enough to beef up the sound? Should I be
plugging my headphones into the Blu-ray
player rather than the projector?
Simon Daly
Jon Thompson replies:
You're right, Simon:
this is a basic setup
-just a player and a
projector! Yet while
you could no doubt
improve things
visually (by
considering a
dedicated screen,
for instance), boosting
audio should be your first port of call.
The only audio output your Blu-ray player
has (in addition to HDMI) is a coaxial digital
out. You want to find a way to use this, as
plugging your headphones into your projector
is not going to be good for the simple fact
a projector will have a lot of high-frequency
noise floating about from the power supply
and the lamp.
A smallscale DAC/headphone amp with
a coaxial input will let you take the audio
straight from your player (remember to set its
output to PCM) and onto your Panasonic cans.
There are various budget options available,
including one I found on Amazon called the
SMSL M3 for £75. This is no doubt a cheap
and cheerful solution, but perhaps worth a
The HD-DAC1 - a great building block
punt. If it's not to your liking you could always
return it.
An alternative would be to look at
something more expensive in the shape of
Marantz's HD-DAC1 (£500). This gives you a
very good digital preamplifier, with the inputs/
outputs you need, and is a great building block
for adding other sources. And any other BD
player you may get with either an optical or
coaxial output will also hook up fine.
A final option is to simply look at some new
headphones (and I'd suggest the Marantz
HD-DAC1 probably deserves an upgraded set),
but I'd still be wary of feeding any straight
from the audio output on your PJ.
I've been in my loft...
Hello all. Having read articles about old
technology, and at a loose end, I decided
to dig out my VCR from the loft. I also
found a copy of Suspiria to try it out.
I connected the VCR to my TV and sat
back to watch - I had forgotten how good
the opening credits are. Even in stereo
the rolling thunder sounded awesome!
Needless to say the Blu-ray is on my
to-buy list.
On another subject, reading Wendy
Hiley's letter [HCC #284] makes me
realise I must have married the wrong
woman!
John Ellison, via email
Mark Craven replies: With vinyl resurgent
in hi-fi circles, some have wondered
whether VHS might also be due a
re-appreciation. But while I understand
the nostalgia value, let's be honest
- it was a bit rubbish. Wasn't it?
Suspiria 's latest BD is based on a 4K scan
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
LETTERS B3
3D BD deserves better
Well done Anton! Myself and a mate have
been having bouts of mental hysteria over
the lack of Dolby Atmos soundtracks on
3D Blu-rays in particular [see Film Fanatic,
HCC #283].
We invest £5,000 on AV systems and then
find we have to buy the 4K upgrades - not
so much for the picture, but for the sound.
I can't watch a film if there's no multi¬
dimensional soundtrack, I just lose interest,
but I love the Atmos sound as it's so
enthralling and powerful. It adds so much
to the movies I love. You give them a roasting
mate, we'll back you up. Wonderful mag
- I've been reading for many years now.
Is it really over 20? I'm getting old!
Glenn
3D BD deserves better, II
I couldn't agree more with Steve Fyles
[Feedback, HCC #284] about pairing 3D
with Dolby Atmos, DTS:X or Auro-3D.
I remember reading about UHD and how
great it was going to be in 3D. No need for
active glasses! Passive will do because of the
resolution hike! That was until the Blu-ray Disc
Association decided it wasn't going to happen.
Disappointment number one. Then they
decided that 3D sound was only going onto
the 'flat' discs. Disappointment number two.
These people are really out of touch with
what film buffs want. They want us to buy
both formats.
I have setups for both formats. If 3D is
available I buy that over UHD. As Steve says
there's more of a wow factor with 3D. 4K is
okay if it's mastered right. Back-catalogue
stuff is a bit naff.
Frederick Elliott
Anton van Beek replies: Whatever the reason
behind it (and I wouldn't be surprised if it was
often being done to allow space for foreign-
language soundtracks in order to create
pan-European releases), the decision to drop
existing Atmos or DTS:X soundtracks from 3D
Blu-rays is one of my biggest frustrations as a
home cinema fan. And it's nice to see - just as
I presumed in my column - that many of you
feel exactly the same way.
That there's no way for me to enjoy the
native 3D photography of Gravity (the only
way to experience the film as it was meant
to be seen) paired with its native Dolby Atmos
sound design, outside of popping the 3D disc
in a Blu-ray deck attached to a screen, the 2D
Atmos disc in another player hooked up to
your speakers and pressing 'Play' on both at
the same time, is utterly ridiculous.
Sadly, outside of an industry-wide rebirth
of 3D spurred on by James Cameron and the
eventual home entertainment release of his
long-overdue Avatar sequel, I really don't see
the situation changing either.
Star Letter...
Movies in your face!
Regards the article about IMAX and the
section on premium film experiences
[HCC #284], I reckon Cineworld's 4DX
is one of the best ways to enjoy your
action film of choice. As long as it’s the
second time you’re watching it.
The main reason for this is that the 4DX
experience can be a distraction from the
film's narrative, especially if your seat is
shaking, you’re getting water sprayed in
your face and the cinema suddenly smells
like it’s on fire.
For those that haven’t yet strapped in
to the 4DX rollercoaster, as well as a 3D
screening, you get chairs that move in three
dimensions, vibration plates and ticklers
in the base and back of the seat, air jets
behind your head and neck, water sprays
above and in front (for those that don’t
like the idea of water, this can be turned
off at the chair) and scent sprays. Then,
depending on the theatre, you can also get
fog, wind, rain and snow, as well as strobe
lighting to enhance scenes that need, well,
flashy lights.
Add all this together and you can see
how it may be a distraction and take you
away from the movie. However, for what
you lose, you make up for in the physical
and sensory experience.
I went to see Star Wars: The Force
Awakens in 4DX at Cineworld Sheffield.
When a Stormtrooper fired his blaster in the
opening battle on Jakku, and a gush of air
whooshed past my ear, I grinned in
satisfaction. Then we had the seat rolling
and pitching as we joined Poe in his X-Wing,
Mark Craven replies: Just to add to Anton's
defence of all things 3D, I should counter
your view that back-catalogue 4K discs
don't impress, Frederick. Sure, there have
been some poor-quality legacy releases
{Terminator2: Judgement Day being a good
example), but there have also been poor-
water misting in
my face as he
flew near the lake,
and the kicks
and rumbles of
the whole seat
asTIE-Fighters
exploded.
Even the scent
sprays (used on
three or four
occasions) helped bring me
into the action. You smell the burning metal
of mangled ships, or the dampness of the
Takodana forests when Rey first meets
Kylo Ren.
So there are pros and cons to 4DX, and
I’m sure the experience will differ depending
on how well the motion/effects track is
created by the developers. I also found
that there were times where movement in
the seat didn’t bring anything to the party.
But if you ask me would I go again, even with
the extra cost (and risk of spilled popcorn),
then I would have to say yes.
Simon Young
Mark Craven replies: That seems both fun
and annoying Simon. I've had some great
D-Box experiences in the past, but found the
pitch and roll a distraction at times. Air in my
face and phantom smells sounds even more
disruptive. But you've almost convinced me
that I need to check it out.
Star letter-writer Simon grabs a copy of The
Shannara Chronicles: Season Two on Blu-ray.
Based on the bestselling series of fantasy books
by Terry Brooks, this second season of this TV
show finds The Four Lands in chaos once again
when the evil Warlock Lord returns from the dead.
The Shannara Chronicles: Season Two is available
to own on DVD and Blu-ray from April 30, courtesy
of Studiocanal.
quality releases of modern movies (such
as Ware raft).
In fact, there are some back-catalogue
releases that I would rank as among the best
the format has to offer, including Bridge on the
River Kwai, which looks sumptuous for a
movie of such vintage, and Crouching Tiger,
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
© 2017 VIACOM INTERNATIONAL INC. AND SONAR ENTERTAINMENT DISTRIBUTION, LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. THE SHANNARA CHRONICLES AND ALL
RELATED TITLES, LOGOS AND CHARACTERS ARE TRADEMARKS OF VIACOM INTERNATIONAL INC. SPIKE IS A TRADEMARK OF SPIKE CABLE NETWORKS INC.
84 PICK ME A NEW PJ/READY, STEADY, GO!
Hidden Dragon. Of course, both these titles
appear dearly derived from their film origins,
with noticeable grain, and I concede that if
I was to show an AV newbie a 4K HDR disc to
highlight the benefits of the format, I would no
doubt opt for a modern, clean-looking title
such as Passengers or Dunkirk.
Should I stick with JVC?
Not sure if you remember me. You featured
my cinema room in your magazine a few
years ago - we live out in Italy and have
a JVC X70 PJ, amongst other bits.
We’re going to be moving house later this
year so I’ll be kitting out a new, dedicated
room and I wonder if you could advise me.
We have the JVC projector which I think is a
six-year-old model now. Since then JVC has
released the X75, X700, X750, X7000, X7500
and the current X7900. My question is, is it
worth upgrading?
Based on your reviews, the current models
are starting to look good with HDR material,
although at a guess it might be a year or two
before they really nail it. Mine has a claimed
brightness of 1,300 Lumens whereas the
X7900 is pumping out a claimed 1,900.
Ours still looks wonderful with Blu-ray
but the newer ones presumably look even
more wonderful.
Plus there are now some 4K models
available from Sony, Optoma and others.
You’ll know that the JVC has great black levels;
would we miss that if we went for an Optoma
or Sony? Would JVC's DLA-X5900 be better
than ours or should I stick with a 7XXX variant?
Cheers, and thanks for a brilliant magazine.
Marcus
John Archer replies: It is definitely worth
upgrading now that 4K and HDR are an
established and brilliant part of the AV world.
If money is no object, Sony’s laser-based
VW760ES is the best home cinema 4K/HDR
projector without spending stratospheric
amounts of money. But this still costs £15,000.
As a more affordable option, JVC's
DLA-X5900 is outstanding. For the first time
JVC has combined its traditional black level
prowess with an effective HDR performance,
while its e-Shift technology does a better
job than previous iterations of delivering
a 4K-esque image despite not boasting
a native 4K resolution.
Although we haven’t yet tested the X7900,
its superior specifications suggest it will be
worth the extra over the excellent X5900.
Especially with HDR playback.
While some of the new breed of affordable
DLP projectors are exceptional value, you’ll
likely find their contrast unsatisfactory given
your JVC history.
Cue Sony’s VPL-VW360ES. While its
black levels aren’t up to the standards of JVC,
they’re perfectly respectable. Sony is also
clever about how it adjusts HDR for a
projection environment, and most importantly
of all, it delivers true 4K pictures that look
notably sharper and cleaner than JVC’s e-Shift
4K images.
My gut feeling is that you will feel more
all-round satisfied with one of the JVC models.
But do at least demo the X7900/X5900
alongside a Sony VW360ES if you can.
Is speed of the essence?
I was thrilled to see my letter published in
HCC #284 but even more fascinated at
Keith's letter in the same issue, which not
only gave an opposite and challenging view
but considerable food for thought - his Star
Letter was thoroughly deserved!
There were several moments after reading
Keith's letter where I seriously thought: would
there be a time when I would consider
discarding my AVR and multichannel speaker
package for a soundbar solution? In fact Keith
gave me the most compelling case to consider
a soundbar ever. Never say never, as the saying
goes. But for now I’m going to stand by my
multichannel setup.
However, what puzzled me most was
Keith's statement about how quick it is to get
his soundbar ready to rock compared to the
slowness of his Sony AVR. I find that by far the
most time-consuming part of switching on my
kit (and I confess I use a Harmony remote with
a pre-programmed activity) is probably
waiting for the BD player to boot and load a
disc. (Although my Panasonic DMP-UB700
is much faster than my DMP-BD10A ever was.
Do you recall those Profile 1.0 days? My wife
used to point out how much quicker it would
be to just watch a DVD...).
If I am watching a movie on Netflix or
Amazon Prime (through my 4K Fire TV) then
of course things are a little quicker, and Keith
also appears to mostly stream movies.
So in the interests of science or nonsense
(I forget which), I've clocked my setup at 31
seconds from first (Harmony) button press to
movie-ready (for Blu-ray), although this is not
including 'disc load time' because firstly, the
performance of the disc player is not pertinent
here, but mostly because it takes me some
time to get out of my armchair, remove the
cellophane from the Blu-ray, find my glasses
and insert the right disc because otherwise I'll
just end up watching the 'Special Features'
or the DVD version that came with it.
However, I did manage to clock a blistering
23 seconds for the 4K Fire TV. I say blistering
but I have no idea what constitutes blistering,
although I can state that in both cases my
Denon AVR was ready to rumble after 10.8
seconds! Is that good?
I already know I've shot myself in the foot
as I can guarantee all the soundbar owners
with stopwatches have now had a go and are
gleefully punching the air, having shaved off
many vital seconds. But is this really a factor?
I think soundbars have a great many pros (as
well as cons) that would sway people to either
avoid a multichannel setup completely or trade
up for one, but is the time taken to switch on
your kit really one of them? How else will you
make sure you have had enough time to get
your drinks, snacks and nibbles ready?
Ian Forster m
Contact us...
Write to HCC, AV Tech Media Ltd, Suite 25, Eden
Flouse, Enterprise Way, Edenbridge, Kent, TN8 6HF,
or email us at letters@homecinemachoice.com
Please note: we cannot guarantee to print/answer all
the letters we receive. Sorry.
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
COMPETITIONS B5
WIN! Great Blu-rays up for grabs...
Just email your answer to Competitions@homecinemachoice.com to be in with a chance to win
Buck Rogers in the 25th
Century: The Complete
Series
Get ready for a blast from the past as the
full 33-episode run of this classic sci-fi TV
series explodes onto Blu-ray. Buck Rogers
in the 25th Century: The Complete Series is
out now, courtesy of Fabulous Films Ltd./
Fremantle Media Enterprises and we've
got two Blu-ray boxsets to give away!
Question:
Which actress starred as Colonel Wilma
Deering in the series?
Answer:
A) Pamela Hensley B) Erin Gray
C) Jamie Lee Curtis
Email your answer with 'Buck Rogers' as
the subject heading - and don't forget to
include your postal address!
Amazon Women
on the Moon &
Nightmares
Two cult-favourite 1980s
anthology movies make
their UK Blu-ray debut
in April, courtesy of 101
Films. Amazon Women on the
Moon is available now, with Nightmares
following on April 23 - and we've got three
pairs of the two Blu-rays up for grabs!
Question:
Which of the following didn't direct some
of Amazon Women on the Moon ?
Answer:
A) John Landis B) Steven Spielberg
C) Joe Dante
Email your answer with 'Amazon Women'
as the subject heading - and don't forget
to include your postal address!
Rawhead Rex
An ancient demon terrorises
the Irish countryside in this
unforgettable '80s monster
movie, which arrives on
Blu-ray on May 14, courtesy
of Arrow Video. In addition
to a new 4K restoration of the film,
the Blu-ray is also packed with bonus goodies
- and to celebrate the release we've got five
Rawhead Rex Blu-rays to be won!
Question:
Rawhead Rex is adapted from a short story
by which famous horror author?
Answer:
A) Stephen King B) Clive Barker
C) Shaun Hutson
Email your answer with 'Rawhead Rex' as the
subject heading - and don't forget to include
your postal address!
Molly's Game
The operator of an exclusive
high-stakes poker empire
finds herself targeted by
the FBI in this remarkable
true story. Molly's Game is
available to own on Digital
Download from May 4, followed
by DVD and Blu-ray on May 14, courtesy of
Entertainment One Ltd. To mark the release
we have five Blu-rays to give away!
Question:
Molly's Game marked the directorial debut of
which award-winning screenwriter?
Answer:
A) William Goldman B) Diablo Cody
C) Aaron Sorkin
Email your answer with 'Molly's Game' as the
subject heading - and don't forget to include
your postal address!
Terms & Conditions
1. Entrants must be aged 18 or over and resident in the United Kingdom. 2. Employees of MyTimeMedia Ltd and companies supplying competition prizes are not
eligible to enter. 3. No responsibility will be accepted for delayed, mislaid, lost or damaged entries. 4. Only one entry per household; multiple entries will be discounted.
5. Prizes will be awarded to the first correct entries drawn at random after the closing date. 6. No alternatives, cash or otherwise, will be offered to the winner as prizes.
7. The editor’s decision is final. 8. Comp winners' info available on request. 9. The closing date is May 24 2018.
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
86 READER'S ROOM
Certified: AV-Holic!
HCC reader Mark got some family help to build this outdoor movie theatre. Now he's dazzling
friends with its 4K visuals, 3D audio and Alexa-powered smart control
Welcome to the AV-Holics Hall
of Fame - introduce yourself!
My name is Mark Burton, I’m a Director for
a local recruitment agency.
How long have you been into
home cinema?
I purchased my first plasma screen in 2003
- a 42in Fujitsu - and since then I have been
hooked! I bought my first projector the
following year, and had my first dedicated
cinema room about 10 years later.
Upon moving to a new house in 2016, one
of my prerequisites when finding a suitable
home was somewhere that would give me
the ability to have a proper cinema room,
taking things to another level. However,
things panned out slightly differently when
moving in. The garage I had planned on
converting wasn’t suitable, so, with the
help of my dad, I decided on building
a completely new structure outside.
What’s in your AV setup?
Things have moved quickly since building
the cinema in the Summer of 2017. Only last
Mark even made the projector
screen for his 'Burtyplex 1
Easter the building didn’t even exist. A lot
of research and hard work and it's now
totally finished.
Quite proud to know that, with the help
of my dad, we've built the whole building
ourselves - not just the external structure, but
also the acoustically transparent black velvet
curtains, 19 acoustic panels, AV unit and
projector screen.
My current list of equipment for vision is
a JVC DLA-X7900 projector, Oppo UDP-203
UHD player, Radiance Lumagen 4440 scaler,
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
AV-HOLIC 87
Sky+HD, Roku Streaming Stick+ and Xbox
One X, with a DIY variable masking screen
(16:9 and Cinemascope).
For sound I have a full 7.1.4 XTZ Cinema
Series Dolby Atmos speaker setup with
Arendal Sub 3, Denon AVR-X720 0 AVR and
an IOTA seven-channel power amp.
Finishing things off for comfort are a
Logitech Harmony Remote with Alexa, Philips
Hue lighting, Mitsubishi Zen air-conditioning
unit and Premiere three-seater cinema
seating from Drinkstuff.
What was the last thing you
added to your system?
This seems to change on a weekly basis! Only
recently I’ve replaced an Epson EH-TW9300
projector with the JVC model, and the Arendal
subwoofer replaced a pair of outgoing
Monolith subs from BK Electronics.
rain delays
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
88 READER'S ROOM
Are you thinking of upgrading
anything else?
I’d like to say no, not at the moment, but
then again only three months ago I had no
intention of changing projector or changing
subwoofer. I'm now about to get a second
Arendal Subwoofer 3.
What's your favourite bit of kit
and why?
That’s a really difficult question to answer.
I’m not sure I have a favourite as such, although
my projector and speakers are very special.
For my application, I think I will struggle to
improve on performance without seriously
breaking the bank. If I was to choose one thing
that adds performance to my room, I think it
would actually be my acoustic panels. Since
adding them, the soundstage in my room has
massively improved. This is an area that I feel
a lot of people disregard, although it is probably
the most important part of the room.
Do you stream movies/TV from
Netflix/Amazon/Sky etc?
Yes, I have Amazon Prime and Netflix
membership. I use these through the Roku in
my cinema room and direct through my Sony
65in A1E OLED in my living room.
How often do you settle down
for movie night?
I try to use my room at least two or three times
a week. This is usually for films, but I will also
watch football in there as well.
What movies/discs do you use
to show off your system?
The recent release of Interstellar on Ultra HD
Blu-ray is absolutely incredible. The scene
where Cooper enters the black hole is
definitely my new go-to scene. When
showing people this, the reaction is always
the same: they always seem to forget they
are watching a film and actually feel like
they are in the spaceship with Coop.
The surround mix and bass on it is fantastic.
You can feel the pressure build up in my room
as the scene progresses.
Other go-to discs include The Dark Knight
(Ultra HD Blu-ray), Oblivion and, for Dolby
Atmos purposes, Mad Max: Fury Road.
And what are your Top 5
favourite flicks?
Five isn’t many to choose from, although Aliens
and Terminator2 will always make it. Other
noteworthy favourites in no particular order
include The Dark Knight Trilogy (I know, not
one film), Heat, Predator, Die Hard and The
Silence of the Lambs.
What do friends and family
think of the cinema room?
They all love it! My girls (10 and 11) think it's
amazing and always want to show it off to their
friends, and I’m sure my 10-month-old boy will
be my movie buddy when he gets older!
Anyone who comes to have a demo is
awestruck at the quality of the sound, picture
and the whole experience. They all say they
will now feel that the local multiplex will be
a step backwards. Unfortunately, I don’t think
pictures will ever do a dedicated room justice.
Until you experience one, they are very difficult
to explain how good they are! ■
Share your cinema system in the mag!
If you want to be in HCC, you'll need to send us some hi-res images of your cinema room. Here are a few tips...
1. Go big. Set your camera to take images at
the largest possible size, and at the highest
resolution. Don't worry about cropping or
resizing - we will make them print-ready.
2. Get in focus. Make sure your photos are
as sharp and clear as possible. If you have
one, use a tripod, or place your camera on a
flat, steady surface and take pictures on a
delay. The sharper they are, the bigger we
can print them.
3. Let some light in. While we tend to watch
movies in the dark, our cinema systems look
their best when they are lit. If you can shoot
with natural daylight, do so. If your room
doesn't get a lot of light (a garage conversion,
for instance) then switch on whatever lights
are fitted. Avoid using flash wherever possible.
4. Be thorough. Send photos of as much of the
room as possible. Images of both the front and
back of the room, the kit rack, speakers,
seating, disc shelf, movie poster art... The more
the merrier.
5. Don't be shy. Send a picture of yourself!
6 . Show us more. Got pictures of your room
before it was a cinema? Or snaps of work
being done? We love to see these, too.
Now what?
Email your images to
letters@homecinemachoice.com with
the subject heading 'AV-Holic', and provide
your answers to the relevant questions above
- then we'll be in touch!
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
HARPENDEN • EDGWARE • BECKENHAM
% V '*
III
3 times award winner
HOME CINEMA CHOICE
“Best Multiroom Installation”
THE BEST IN HOME
ENTERTAINMENT
Whatever you're looking for, from a radio or
headphones to the very latest TVs, Home
Entertainment systems and Home Automation
installations, Musical Images is a trusted, local
expert you can rely on. For the finest brands,
caring service and true expertise there’s no
better choice for your entertainment.
Come in and see us soon.
Store
HIFI • HOME CINEMA • MULTIROOM AUDIO • HOME AUTOMATION _
LIGHTING CONTROL SYSTEMS • A/V DESIGN & CONSULTANCY
Musical Images Showrooms Opening times 9.30am - 5.30am. Monday - Saturday. Closed on Wednesdays
www.musical-images.co.uk
O musical images
O @musicaljmages
126 High Street, Beckenham 173 Station Road, Edgware 82 High Street, Harpenden
Kent BR3 1EB Middlesex HA8 7JX Hertfordshire AL5 2SP
Tel: 020 866 33 777 Tel: 020 8952 5535 Tel: 01582 764246
beckenham@musicalimages.co.uk edgware@musicalimages.co.uk harpenden@musicalimages.co.uk
Audio Visual Lifestyle Ltd trading as Musical Images. Finance options available, subject to status. E&OE
https://hfn.setureorderc^
https://hct.secureordewo.Uk/htt/BAR/#digltal
xo.uk/hfc/BAR/#digital
https://hft.secureorder.
• Download each new issue to your device
• A 74% discount on your Digital subscription
• Access your subscription on multiple devices
Home Cinemas « Home Automation & Control TV, Audio & WiFi Distribution Lighting
Full Design & Installation
home
cinema
www.KentHomeCinema.co.uk
01892 535007
CUSTOM
ELECTRONIC
□E$3GN a
INSTALLATION
ASSOCIATION
CEDIA
An uncompromising approach to Home Cinema
Home Cinema ■ Home Automation ■ Music ■ Lighting ■ HVAC ■ Custom Design & Installations
PROGRESSIVE^
HOME TECHNOLOGY 0^0
www. p regressive- ht.com
01892 860801
CEDIA
MEMBER
WWW.HOMECINEMACHOICE.COM 91
PI AY BACK
-►Software HIGHLIGHTS THE SHAPE OF WATER Award-winning fantasy
makes a splash THREE BILLBOARDS OUTSIDE EBBING, MISSOURI Acclaimed drama packs a
punch on Ultra HD Blu-ray JUMANJI: WELCOME TO THE JUNGLE Fun and games in this family-
friendly sequel/reboot JUSTICE LEAGUE Are these 4K heroes in a league of their own? & MORE!
It's the moment home cinema fans have been
waiting for: the Star Wars franchise has made
the leap to Ultra HD Blu-ray. Find out if The Last
Jedi sets a new AV benchmark for the format
as we take the 4K platter for a spin on p94...
HCC RATINGS KEY.
Outstanding
Acceptable
Disappointing
Star Wars: Thi
rdr>* Walt Disney-»Ultn
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
There's nothing fishy here
Guillermo del Toro's Oscar-winning fantasy deserves to be a monster hit on UHD Blu-ray
HOC VERDICT
The Shape of Water
t Twentieth Century Fox
ClJHD Blu-ray & Region
E £30 (US Import)
WThis4Kencode'5
HDR and wide colour is p
suited to del Toro's paint
ABD
; use of
erfectly
erly vision.
★★★★★
★★★★
★★★★
OVERALL: ★★★★
Picture.
Audio:
Extras.
The Shape of Water
Try summarising Guillermo del Toro's latest movie
to someone and it'll sound like the very worst kind of
student film. A romantic fairy tale set in an Art Deco
world, about misfits falling in love, where one of the
misfits is an actual monster who looks like he's
walked straight off the set of The Creature from
the Black Lagoon ? It ain't Fast and Furious, certainly.
Yet so beautifully written and sensuously filmed
is The Shape of Water that any resistance to its
apparent tweeness lasts for all of five minutes.
This is cinema at its enchanting best, and as such it
deserves the many awards that have been lavished
on both the film itself and its writer-director.
Picture: Despite only getting a 2K cinema release
from a predominantly 3.4K shoot, The Shape of
Water's 4K transfer does a much more effective job
of delivering its beautiful lighting, sets and imagery
than the accompanying 1080p Blu-ray.
There's noticeably more detail in the beautifully
crafted costumes and wonderfully detailed sets,
as well as the remarkably realised skin of the film's
‘creature 1 . There's precious little CGI in play here,
and it shows.
There's also a more defined sense of space in
the film's whimsical locations, and these image
enhancements help you forge a more intimate
relationship with del Toro's vision.
The Ultra HD Blu-ray's biggest treat, though, is the
gorgeous effect its wider colour and light ranges have
on the film's fantastical world. Every frame looks
more dynamic and rich, enhancing the dream-like
atmosphere and making the film's world an even
more irresistible - if occasionally icky - place to be.
Audio: Accompanying The Shape of Water's
impressive visuals is a DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundmix.
This is a little disappointing; we could imagine
an Atmos or DTS:X track really enhancing the
sense of height and space in the film's laboratory
locations, or making Alexandre Desplat's score even
more hypnotic.
To be fair, though, even in this 5.1 guise the score
meanders artfully around every channel, dialogue
is always impressively contextualised, and there's
a rich, uncompressed, clean feel to everything.
Extras: All The Shape of Water's extras are found on
the (Region A-locked ) Full HD Blu-ray that is packed
alongside this 4K US import - and while it doesn't
sport the sort of heavyweight assortment of goodies
we've come to expect from previous Blu-ray releases
of Guillermo del Toro's films (the major surprise
being the lack of a commentary track), there's still
some good stuff here to get stuck into.
The highlights kick off with a half-hour Making of...
documentary covering all the main aspects of the
film's creation, from production design to score and
the development of the creature. There are also
short featurettes detailing the filming of two key
scenes; an interview with artist James Jean (who
created much of the film's gorgeous concept art);
and a fascinating ‘masterclass' with a theatre full
of film students where del Toro and other crew
members discuss making a monster movie.
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
The Snowman Ferdinand
Pitch Perfects
PLAYBACK 93
Universal Pictures -> All-region BD
£25
Twentieth Century Fox Region B BD
£25
Universal PicturesAll-region BD
£25
It was always likely that
Hollywood would try to
bring one of JoNesbo's
bestselling crime novels
to the screen, but who
would have thought it would make as big
of a hash of it as this? Rushed into
production (director Tomas Alfredson
claims he didn't have the time to shoot
around 15 per cent of the screenplay), the
film is an incomprehensible mess of
abandoned subplots that fails to realise
the cinematic potential of Nesbo's novel.
This BD sports a suitably cool and crisp
Full HD encode, while the DTS-HD MA 7.1
mix is pleasingly immersive. Extras are
limited to five short promo featurettes.
The classic children's
book The Story of
Ferdinand (about a bull
who would rather smell
flowers than compete
in bullfights) gets a fairly charmless CG-
animated update courtesy of the studio
responsible for the Ice Age films. While
the 'toon itself is unlikely to excite you,
this Blu-ray should hold your attention
with its bright, colourful and perfectly
rendered 2.40:l-framed Full HD encode.
The disc's DTS-HD MA 5.1 track is no
slouch either, delivering plenty of action
across the soundstage. Bonus goodies
are plentiful, although they're almost
entirely aimed at little kids.
Struggling to adjust to life
outside college the Barden
Bellas reunite for one last
musical tour in this final
instalment of the comedy
series. It's not as sharp as
the original, but Pitch Perfect 3 does at least improve on its
immediate predecessor and finds a few new beats to add to
the formula. The undoubted highlight of this BD release is an
effortlessly fluid and wide-ranging DTS:X soundtrack that takes
the a capella musical numbers to new heights; the AVC 1.85:1
Full HD encode is also richly detailed and clean. A pair of
chat-tracks head up a sizeable set of extras.
★ ★★★★ ★★★
★ ★★★★
-> Three Billboards Outside
Ebbing, Missouri
Writer/director Martin McDonagh's drama about a
mother seeking justice following the murder of her
daughter has been pretty omnipresent on the recent
awards circuit - and its acclaim is deserved. Despite
being a little overtly theatrical at times, it remains
a powerful, brilliantly-acted smalltown America
drama that holds up well to repeat viewings.
Picture: Three Billboards... was shot at 2.8K, and
only received a 2K digital intermediate for cinematic
release. Hardly surprising, then, that the image
on this 4K Blu-ray isn't the sharpest around, lacking
the detail and crispness of the best-looking releases.
That said, the picture does improve
on the 1080p transfer. The lush
landscapes look slightly more defined
and three-dimensional, while close-ups
reveal more refinement in the actors'
care-worn faces.
The HDRIO upgrade also means that
sunny exteriors appear naturally bright
and vivid, while artificial light sources
have a more life-like intensity.
The red hue of the titular billboards
is far more punchy, yet the enhanced
colour grading of the 4K Blu-ray also
makes skin tones look more authentic.
There are a couple of issues. First, a
few sequences - such as the opening
one in the mist - appear slightly noisier
than they do on the Blu-ray. Second,
some exterior shots are infiltrated by
A sign of the times for HDR
Martin McDonagh's unforgettable drama makes quite an impression in 4K
a mild yellow undertone. Overall, though, the 4K
picture justifies the disc's extra cost.
Audio: Three Billboards... only gets a DTS-HD MA 5.1
mix on both its 4K and 1080p discs. Even so,
we didn't find the movie lacking from an audio
perspective; it's hardly an action blockbuster, after
all. What you do get sounds clean and open; it's alive
with ambient details, and revels in Carter Burwell's
haunting score.
Extras: For a relatively low-budget release, Three
Billboards... gets a solid set of extra features. Pick
of the pack is a 30-minute Making of... documentary
that includes lots of behind-the-scenes footage
and an excellent breakdown of the film's pivotal
scene. There are also five deleted scenes.
Also, be sure to set half-an-hour aside for Six
Shooter - a darkly comic (and Oscar-winning) 2004
short film by McDonagh that redefines the idea of
somebody having a bad day.
Frances McDormand's Mildred takes
the law into her own hands
HCC VERDICT
Three Billboards Outside
Ebbing, Missouri
E Twentieth Century Fox
E|§HD Blu-ray & All-region BD
E £30 (US Import)
J This brilliantly acted drama
enjoys a respectable 4K showing.
★★★★
Iciriri
OVERALL ★★★★
Movie:
Picture:
Audio:
Extras:
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
94 STAR WARS: THE LAST JEDI 4K
A new hope for AV?
It's all change in a galaxy far, far away as Disney dips its
toes into Dolby Vision HDR
Star Wars: The Last Jedi
The Force Awakens, with its familiar narrative beats
and cast of returning favourites, was undoubtedly
the ideal first movie for Disney as it sought to reignite
fan passion in all things Star Wars. Follow-up flick
The Last Jedi successfully takes the series into
something of a new direction. As it surely had to.
Plot-wise, the movie (written and directed by Rian
‘Looper ’ Johnson), picks up where Force Awakens
left off, with Rey (Daisy Ridley), meeting up with
Jedi veteran Luke Skywalker at his remote island
hideaway. Meanwhile, Poe (Oscar Isaac) and Finn
(John Boyega) are embedded with the Resistance
fleet as it flees from First Order ships and new series
baddies Kylo Ren and General Snoke. Johnson’s
script then balances the action between Rey’s Jedi
training and the Resistance escape, before pulling
plot-lines together for the expected climax.
Actually, two climaxes.
You’d have to have been living in a swamp on
Dagobah to not know that The Last Jedi upset some
Star Wars aficionados when it hit cinemas last
December. The main gripes didn’t solely concern the
overall narrative, however; also Johnson’s approach
to the material. This is a flick unafraid to lay on
moments of broad humour, and unafraid to take
its characters and themes in unexpected directions.
While The Force Awakens was built upon nostalgia,
The Last Jedi jettisons a lot of the past.
To be honest, we can’t see what all the fuss
was about. Johnson and Disney have crafted a
thoughtful, spectacle-laden blockbuster that drives
the saga story forward, carefully homages the past
(check out Rey and Kylo Ren’s Return of the Jedi-
esque elevator ride) and fleshes out its trio of
young leads. It also gives Mark Hamill, as Skywalker,
a real chance to shine.
Picture: Not content with making The Last Jedi
the first Star Wars film on 4K Blu-ray, Disney has
delivered it in Dolby Vision and HDR10 versions.
Both look much better than the FID Blu-ray
- although they're not quite consistent enough
to qualify as reference-grade.
For instance, while many close-up shots are
markedly crisper and more detailed than on the
FID Blu-ray, some largescale shots look little if any
sharper - despite the transfer being derived from
a native 4K digital intermediate. This inconsistency,
together with some slight variance in the amount
of grain in the image, is likely not helped by the film's
special effects presumably not being rendered in
native 4K. Or by the use during filming of a mixture
of 35mm, 65mm and digital cameras.
For most of the time, though, The Last Jedi on 4K
Blu-ray gives you the most detailed look at the Star
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
PLAYBACK 95
Wars universe ever seen on a home entertainment
platform. Even better, it does so with unprecedented
dynamism and vibrancy.
The use of high dynamic range and wide colour
technologies isn't actually the most strident we've
seen on a 4K platter, but it easily succeeds in making
all those familiar Star Wars image highlights erupt
off the screen like never before. Space battle
explosions and laser fire ping from the blackness
of space with eye-watering intensity, while lightsaber
duels are given extra intensity from the injection of
extra brightness and colour.
This is all especially true if you can view The Last
Jedi in its Dolby Vision guise, where the format's extra
scene-by-scene image data boosts the dynamic
range of the most contrast-rich scenes (especially
the space battles); provides subtler toning in the
most richly coloured scenes; and handles the
brightest gleams of Captain Phasma's armour
with noticeably more authority.
Audio: Disney has gone ‘full Dolby' for its first
Star Wars 4K Blu-ray, partnering its Dolby
Vision visuals with a Dolby Atmos soundtrack.
Annoyingly, though, this soundtrack isn't
quite as explosive as we'd have liked.
It's mixed a little quietly, meaning
you'll find yourself cranking your setup
higher than normal to unlock its
charms, and more noticeably
doesn't use the format's height
layer as much as expected from a
film featuring huge 360-degree
battles and sets. There are
moments of thrilling,
heavy bass, but these
are few and far
between. For the
most part the
dynamic
range actually feels a little constrained
when compared to, say, the bombast
of this month's Justice League track.
That said, surround channels are
expertly used for both general ambience
and precise location effects, cocooning
you in the movie's environments, and
it's a consistently lively and nuanced
soundtrack. It's a pleasure, too, to hear
John Williams' superb score cleanly
and immersively mixed around your
speaker array.
Extras: This fan-dividing movie is
accompanied by a great set of extra
features. Rian Johnson delivers a
worthwhile commentary track that
benefits from him being the film's
writer as well as director. There's also
an outstanding 95-minute Making
of... documentary (The Director
and the Jedi) that follow's the film's
gestation, development and filming
in excellent, access-all-areas
detail, plus a separate 10-minute
exploration of Johnson's take
on The Force'.
Wrapping things up are
in-depth looks (ranging from five
to 15 minutes) at the making of
three key scenes, a fabulous clip
of Andy Serkis acting as General
Snoke before being covered by
special effects, and 15 deleted
and extended scenes.
Also note that the Digital
Copy with this US version (but
not the physical disc) includes
the ability to view the movie in
isolated score mode.
HCC VERDICT
Star Wars: The Last Jedi
Walt Disney UHD Blu-ray &
All-region BD £37
W Disney's first Star Wars 4K
release is a visual treat, and loaded
with quality extras.
★★★★
★★★★*
OVERALL:
Movie.
Picture.
Audio:
Extras.
>
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
96 JUMANJI: WELCOME TO THE JUNGLE/FAR CRY 5
Arcade Action
Bigscreen home entertainment isn't just about movies
anymore. Rik Henderson checks out a videogame vying
for time on your home cinema system...
pushing the boundaries of the first-person-shooter genre. Far Cry 5
does neither. It is, however, an excellent game and a stunningly
beautiful one to boot.
If you were a big fan of Far Cry 4 you will find much here that is
familiar and, even, directly lifted from that previous title. But while
this fifth instalment brings very few new tricks to the table, it gives
players an enormous open-world environment to roam and
hundreds of missions and side quests to undertake. It is a huge
game and no mistake.
This time the action has switched to the United States and a
corner of Montana that is terrorised by a local religious cult: Project
at Eden's Gate. This cult is run by a malevolent leader in Joseph
Seed who, along with several family members, has kidnapped
the local populace, taken their lands and rules with a cruel fist.
It's therefore a far darker setup than Far Cry 4, although there
are lighter tones in some of the side missions to brighten the mood
at times. As with the last few Far Cry games (and most Ubisoft
open-world games, full-stop) you must complete missions and
take outposts to expose the map. You also need to take on specific
boss battles and defeat each member of the Seed brood in order
to get to Joseph himself.
There's also the cornucopia of collectables and side tasks
that mean little to the main narrative but extend your playtime
dramatically. Indeed, should you decide to take on everything the
game has to offer, you could well be playing for weeks on end.
And that's no bad thing.
Visually, Far Cry 5 is spectacular. The rendered landscapes of
Montana are rich in detail and the use of HDR is perfect. The green
grass is vivid, blue skies also, and corn fields are bursting with
yellows and browns. Explosions and fire effects are even more
brilliant in tone and a decent TV will make them sing.
If you have an Xbox One X you get the biggest treat. The game
runs at a full native 4K resolution (3,840 x 2,160) and is incredibly
crisp. The PS4 Pro maxes at 2,880 x 1,620, which is better than
the standard PS4, but all versions still look great. You won't be
disappointed no matter the format.
★★★★★
Britannia: Season 1
Sony Pictures Region B BD
£36
If you're the sort of person who
prefers a more serious TV
historical drama then you
should steer clear of this recent
Sky production. Set during the
Roman invasion of Britain, the
series serves up a heady mix of violence and mysticism that is
more indebted to Game of Thrones than I, Claudius. However,
if you buy in to the show's comic book-esque brand of lunacy
then there's plenty to enjoy. Sharp, colourful 1.78:11080p visuals
partnered with pleasingly dynamic DTS-HD MA 5.1 sonics help
make it easy to savour on Blu-ray.
★ ★★★★
Outlander: Season Three
Sony Pictures All-region BD
£45
Following the same pattern as
its second season, this latest run
of 13 episodes is split between
two arcs - the first focusing on
reuniting time-displaced lovers
Claire and Jamie, the second on
sending them on a fresh adventure. This time around, though,
it's a bit more unbalanced, stretching the former arc too far and
not giving the latter arc the space it really needs: at least the
chemistry between the leads is as strong as ever and helps
paper over these issues. Also distracting your attention
somewhat is the typically excellent AV performance and
generous selection of extras this Blu-ray release rustles up.
Amazon Women on the Moon
101 Films-»Region B BD & R2 DVD
£20
Based around flicking between
TV channels late at night, this
1987 sketch movie may be a
pretty inconsistent affair, but
when the parodies hit their
targets (as in Carl Gottlieb's
Son of the Invisible Man, John Landis's Blacks Without Soul and
Joe Dante's Bulls**t or Not?) the results are truly side-splitting.
Despite Universal's iffy track record with DNR application on its
back-catalogue HD masters, the one licensed to 101 Films for
this release retains a film-like appearance throughout. Fun
extras include a chat-track, two interviews and six cut skits.
/
k
k
* 1
lit*
9
_ A
★ ★★★★
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
Playing games with nostalgia
This enjoyable videogame-era franchise reboot delivers a flawless 1080p encode on Blu-ray
Jumanji: Welcome to
theJungle
During detention, four high school teenagers - nerdy
Spencer (Alex Wolff), self-centred Bethany (Madison
Iseman), football jock 'Fridge' (Ser'Darius Blain) and
loner Martha (Morgan Turner) - find a vintage video
game console. Within moments of turning it on they
are sucked into the Jumanji game world, appearing in
the forms of the avatars they had chose to play as.
Spencer is now the muscular explorer Dr. Smolder
Bravestone (Dwayne Johnson), Bethany the
cartographer Professor Sheldon 'Shelly' Oberon
(Jack Black), 'Fridge' the diminutive zoologist
Franklin 'Mouse' Finbar (Kevin Hart) and
Martha the lethal Ruby Roundhouse (Karen
Gillan). Only by completing the game and
recovering the mystical Jaguar's Eye jewel
from the evil Professor Van Pelt (Bobby
Cannavale) can they hope to return to
the real world.
Cleverly updating the board game
concept from the original 1995 Robin
Williams film is only one of the many
treats this canny sequel-reboot has in
store for modern audiences. From the
good-natured fun it has with its archetypal
characters to the over-the-top action
scenes, it captures the spirit of 1980s
family films like The Goonies - albeit
with a more self-reflexive sense of
humour (and much less screaming).
Add in some really great gags and enjoyable
performances and it's easy to see why strong word-
of-mouth propelled Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle
to become one of the biggest box office smashes of
the past 12 months. A feat we have no doubt it will
soon repeat with this home entertainment release...
Picture: Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle arrives on
Blu-ray with a reference-quality AVC 2.40:l-framed
1080p encode. Shot on location in Hawaii, the movie
is bursting with vibrant colours, while the natural
brightness only serves to show off the flawless
definition and sharpness of the imagery. Black levels
are also perfectly presented, ensuring that even
darker locations such as the Bazaar and the tunnels
under it (Chapters 7 and 8) are perfectly portrayed
and never lose any clarity.
Audio: From motorbike mayhem to rampaging
rhinos, the disc's DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack
is an extremely active affair. The soundscape
frequently envelops with dynamic surround
elements and meaty bass. As good as this
is, however, we imagine the original Dolby
Atmos incarnation would be even more
immersive - but yet again Sony has
decided to only make this available
to buyers of its 4K disc.
Extras: Apart from losing out on the
Atmos mix, the other disappointing
aspect of this Blu-ray is the collection
of extras. All you get are a gag reel; five
run-of-the-mill Making of... featurettes;
and a spoof Jack Black music video.
From geek to hunk at the push of a
button - aren't videogames great?
HCC VERDICT
Jumanji: Welcome to
the Jungle
E Sony Pictures ^All-region BD
£25
J A sparkling hi-def outing for
this fun film - although the lack of
Atmos audio disappoints.
★★★★
★★★★★
★★★★
icici
OVERALL :★★★★
Movie:
Picture.
Audio:
Extras:
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
9fl EARTH: ONE AMAZING DAY/THE AWFUL TRUTH
Not as amazing as the original
Feature film re-edit struggles to wow, despite some supposed AV enhancements
Earth: One Amazing Day
This 90-minute nature film from the BBC Earth team
responsible for Planet Earth II plays very much like
an Americanised excuse (it's narrated by Robert
Redford and backed by a near-incessant easy-
listening music track) for repurposing lots of footage
from that acclaimed documentary series.
Restructuring the material around a day in the life
of our planet opens the door to some new insights,
though, and watching beautiful scenery and wildlife
in 4K HDR never grows old. Meanwhile, the relatively
short running time and easier narrative makes it a lot
more child-friendly than the original Beeb show.
Picture: Curiously, we weren't as consistently blown
away by Earth: One Amazing Day's 4K HDR picture
quality as we were by that of Planet Earth II.
Close-ups of animals still reveal far more fur and
feather detail than you get on the 1080p Blu-ray, and
HDR makes bright locations look more lifelike. But
wider shots tend to look slightly soft/compressed,
and the disc's HDR10 pass appears less controlled.
This 4K Blu-ray is still the optimum way to watch
the film, though. This is especially true if you can
handle the disc's Dolby Vision pass, which delivers
more refined colours in dark areas and, in doing so,
slightly enhances the overall sense of detail.
Audio: Earth: One Amazing Day on Ultra HD Blu-ray
features a Dolby Atmos soundtrack, as opposed
to the DTS-HD MA 5.1 mixes that accompanied
Planet Earth II on the format, and it's great to
hear this deliver some genuine height effects.
For instance, during underwater sequences water
laps above you as well as behind and to the side.
Even better, the soundmix is precise enough to place
specific animal noises at the right height and
position in front of you.
It also tries harder than Planet Earth II' s audio
to use ambient and creature sounds to create a
sense of living, breathing, three-dimensional spaces.
Unfortunately, these sometimes feel rather forced
- as do some obvious Foley-created effects.
The score, meanwhile, is liberally mixed around
the Atmos channels, but is overused and feels
cloyingly dated. As a result, it's more likely to distract
you than enhance your immersion.
Extras: All of Earth: One Amazing Day's HD extras
are also found on the 4K Blu-ray. They comprise a
15-minute behind-the-scenes featurette, plus short
vignettes about the filming of the Narwhal, fighting
giraffe, White-Headed Langur, penguin and sloth
sequences. Worth a watch, but there's nothing really
substantial here.
Is this the ultimate creature feature?
Heimat: Limited
Edition Boxset
Second Sight -> Region B BD
£80
Subtitled 'A Chronicle of
Germany', Edgar Reitz's
15-hour TV drama
follows the life of a
family from a small
German village between 1919 and 1982.
Restored from the original negative and
presented in its cinema version (which
joins pairs of shorter episodes together
to make feature-length instalments),
Heimat looks sensational on Blu-ray;
the 1.66:11080i encodes cope equally well
with the series' black-and-white and
colour visuals. A disc of extras includes a
look at the restoration process and Reitz's
'Hunsruch Villages...' documentary.
★★★★★
The Awful Truth
The Criterion Collection Region B BD
£28
The Criterion Collection
V \ has recently become
7 i something of a haven
\ -^1 for fans of Cary Grant's
screwball comedies.
Directed by Leo McCarey, this 1938 film
is another treat for fans, with Grant and
co-star Irene Dunne on sparkling form
as the warring husband and wife going
through a divorce. While bonus features
aren't all that extensive (just a pair of
informative video essays, a 1978 audio
interview with Dunne and a 1939 radio
adaptation), the 4K restoration of the
film itself is a joy to behold, revealing
excellent stability, authentic black levels
and well-resolved film grain.
★★★★
Otley
Indicator^ All-region BD
£16
This 1968 comic spy
thriller from writing duo
Ian Le Frenais and Dick
Clement finds Tom
Courtenay's feckless,
couch-surfing layabout Gerald Arthur
Otley somehow getting caught up in a
conflict between two espionage agencies,
both of which believe he knows far more
than he's letting on. This off-kilter comedy
comes to Blu-ray with an impressive 1.85:1
encode that only really takes a turn for the
worse during a sequence in a Tube station
(and that is entirely down to the different
film stock that was required). Once again
Indicator offers up a terrific array of extras,
including a chat-track and interviews.
★★★★★
Breathless
Second Sight -> Region B BD
£20
Jim McBride's 1983
US remake of Jean-Luc
Godard's French New
Wave classic may not
be held in the same sort
of critical regard as the original, but taken
on its own terms it's an enjoyable piece
of pop cinema that is arguably a lot more
fun to watch. Although the pleasingly
colour-saturated 1.85:1 encode featured
on this UK Blu-ray looks very reminiscent
of the 2015 US release, Second Sight has
improved on Shout! Factory's essentially
barebones Region A platter by including
an interview with actress Valerie Kaprisky
and an impassioned defence of the film
from critic Mark Kermode.
★★★★★
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
CHORD
Get the best from your movies, TV and games with the
latest addition to the award-winning Chord Company
C-series range of cables.
The new, ultra slim and flexible Chord Company
C-view HDMI cable . Designed for high performance
and easy installation at an affordable price.
Available now in 0.75m, 1.5m, 2m, 3m, 5m, 8m, 10m
lengths. Prices from £35.00 (UK RRP)
Designed in England by The Chord Company Ltd,
Millsway Centre, Amesbury SP4 7RX, UK. For full
technical specifications and to find your nearest retailer,
please call us on: +44 (0) 1980 625700 or visit:
www.chord.co.uk
Connect with us
AVTech media
AWAHD5 2D16I17
Not doing its heroes justice
After the highs of Wonder Woman, this team-up flick brings the DCEU crashing back to Earth
-►Justice League
In the wake of Superman's death, the alien warlord
Steppenwolf spies an opportunity to attack our
world. Realising they have no chance of stop him
by themselves, Batman and Wonder Woman recruit
a trio of new metahumans to help...
When Wonder Woman hit the bigscreen last year
it looked like the DC Extended Universe had taken
a turn for the better. Sadly, any expectations that
Justice League would continue this course correction
are quickly dashed. What should be the pinnacle of
DC's cinematic achievements to date instead comes
across as a complete mess.
The fact that credited director Zack Snyder left
the film due to a family bereavement, only to be
replaced by Joss Whedon (who rewrote chunks of
the script and oversaw reshoots), means that it's
not especially surprising that Justice League is tonally
inconsistent. What is more of a shock is how
half-finished the film looks. From the lacklustre VFX
to the uneven performances, it feels like an edit suite
salvage job that has been rush-released into cinemas
before it was ready. Which is definitely not what you
hope for from a blockbuster title with an apparent
$300m budget.
Picture: Justice League was shot on various media
at multiple resolutions, with Warner Bros ultimately
creating a 2K-resolution cinematic version. This is,
presumably, the source of this 4K Blu-ray image.
Sharpness and detail are sometimes so high,
though, that it's hard to believe you're not looking at
HCC VERDICT
B Warner Bros.EllHD Blu-ray &
All-region BD £35
fflYet another cinematic
misstep for DC's superheroes, but
at least it looks pretty in 4K.
★★
★★★★
★★★
OVERALL: ★★★
native 4K. The detail apparent in the heroes' suits,
for instance, is little short of wondrous.
The UHD BD also features aggressive use of HDR
and expanded colour. Inky blacks nestle alongside
extreme peak whites, suggesting this is another DC
title that's been mastered to 4,000-nit peaks.
Although the packaging doesn't mention it, Justice
League flies onto 4K Blu-ray in both Dolby Vision and
HDR10 iterations. Dolby Vision's baked-in dynamic
metadata enhances the visuals with an expanded
range and greater colour finesse. Yet the FIDR10
version is also a sight for sore eyes.
Only some obviously sub-4K visual effects
take the shine of an impressive presentation.
Audio: The film comes with a Dolby Atmos mix that
serves up no shortage of effects flying around the
soundstage, and has a low-end that packs a wallop
worthy of Superman. But when it comes to the type
of discrete height details that mark out the very best
Atmos mixes, outside of a couple of sequences,
Justice League simply appears unable (or unwilling)
to deliver the goods.
Still, it boasts much greater dynamic range than
Thor: Ragnarok's soundtrack (see #284), so it has
that in its favour.
Extras: As you might expect, there's nothing in the
extra features selection concerning Justice League's
troubled production. Instead we get two deleted
scenes relating to missing hero Superman; four
scene breakdowns; and six featurettes investigating
the characters, production design and comic book
history of the League.
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
PLAYBACK 01
The Beast from
20,000 Fathoms:
Premium Collection
Warner Bros. -> All-region BD & R2 DVD
£15 (HMV exclusive)
An atomic test at the
North Pole unleashes
a prehistoric monster
which quickly heads off
to wreak havoc in New
York City in this vintage creature-feature.
The first of this month's double-header
of dino-tastic Ray Harryhausen classics,
The Beast from 20,000 Fathoms crawls
onto Blu-ray with a good-looking 1.37:1
1080p encode that is only held back by
the nature of the film's optical effects.
While there are no new extras, we do get
the handful of goodies that appeared on
the film's old DVD release.
★★★★★
The Buck stops right here...
Kitsch sci-fi series makes for an enjoyable blast from the past on Blu-ray
Damnation Alley
Signal One
£20
Region BBD&R2 DVD
Released in the same
year as Star Wars by the
same studio, this post-
apocalyptic road-trip
feels like the product of
a completely different era in filmmaking.
Closer in tone and style to a Bert I. Gordon
B-movie (only none of them were ever
this tedious), it's a string of missed
opportunities. The fact that barely a
single scene goes by without some sort
of optical effect also ensures that it looks
pretty rough on Blu-ray - although the
DTS-HDMA6.1 mix does a fair job of
replicating the original 'Sound360'
soundtrack. Illuminating extras include
two chat-tracks and three interviews.
The Valley of Gwangi:
Premium Collection
Warner Bros. All-region BD & R2 DVD
£15 (HMV exclusive)
Cowboys and dinosaurs
clash in this enjoyable
genre mash-up that
serves as yet another
showcase for stop-
motion effects pioneer Ray Harryhausen,
and here his wonderful creations are
joined on screen by an engaging cast who
make the most of the film's King Kong-
like story. Given that the Dynamation
technique used to bring the creatures to
life means they'll never look perfect, the
2K scan that underpins this HD release
holds up rather well (the dinosaur models
have certainly never looked better). Bonus
features, though, are disappointingly slim.
Murder on the Orient
Express [4K]
Twentieth Century Fox-» UHD Blu-ray
& All-region BD-» £30
While this UHD Blu-ray
release can do nothing
about the narrative
flaws in the recent
all-star adaptation
of the classic whodunnit, it certainly does
wonders for the film's lavish production
design. Shot on 65mm at 2.40:1 and
finished on a 4K Dl, this UHD Blu-ray's
2160p encode is nothing less than
stunning, with the considered use of
HDR grading adding an extra level of
opulence. The upgrade to Dolby Atmos
audio is another big plus point for the
platter, bringing noticeable height and
depth to the soundstage.
★★★★★
★★★★★
Buck Rogers in the
25th Century:
The Complete Series
In 1987 NASA launches the last of its deep-space
probes, piloted by Captain William 'Buck' Rogers.
A freak accident results in the ship being thrown
off course and Buck being perfectly preserved in
suspended animation, only to be found and awoken
500 years later, when he returns to a world he barely
recognises or understands.
The second and best of producer Glen A. Larson's
attempts to cash-in on the success of Star Wars on
the smallscreen (the first being Battlestar Galactica),
Buck Rogers in the 25th Century is a blast of late
1970s sci-fi fun packed full of disco design, skin-tight
costumes, cute robots and an endless parade of
guest stars (including Jack Palance, Jamie Lee Curtis
and pretty much the entire rogues' gallery from the
'60s Batman TV series).
It's also surprisingly cheeky, never taking itself
too seriously and serving up the largest number
of double entendres outside of a Carry On... flick.
Sadly, the second (and last) season's
attempt to shake up the formula sees
things take a something of a nosedive.
Yet even then the show still has the
flirty onscreen chemistry shared by
leads Gil
Gerrard (Buck)
and Erin Gray
(Colonel Wilma
Deering) to fall
back on.
Picture: Despite being based on Universal's pre¬
existing broadcast HD masters, with no additional
clean-up work undertaken for this release, Buck...
looks surprisingly good on Blu-ray. Presented in their
original 1.37:1 aspect ratios, the 1080p encodes are
vibrant and detailed, with excellent contrast and
black levels. The various optical effects shots knock
it down a step, looking understandably softer and
showing a less refined grain structure.
Audio: The LPCM 2.0 stereo sounds as good as you
could hope for. While there's really not much in the
way of discrete L/R effects, the all-important
dialogue and music elements are perfectly
presented without any damage or distortion.
Extras: The only extras on offer are the theatrical
release version of original TV movie The Awakening
(with its 'sexy' title credits sequence), plus alternate
syndicated presentations of the two-part stories
Flight of the War Witch and Journey to Oasis.
HCC VERDICT
Buck Rogers in the 25th
Century: The Complete
Series
E Fabulous Films All-region BD
£60
E The show looks great in HD,
but a few more extras would have
been welcome.
Movie:
Picture:
★★★★
★★★
ici
OVERALL: ★★★
Audio:
Extras:
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
Lara Croft was incredibly proud
of
Paramount dusts off a couple of Angelina Jolie action movies for a Dolby Vision upgrade
HOC VERDICT
Lara Croft: Tomb Raider -
2-Movie Collection
I Paramount UHD Blu-ray &
All-region BD £50
W couple of forgettable,
if inoffensive, action movies given
inconsistent 4K transfers.
Movie:
Picture.
Audio:
Extras:
★★tH
iciri
ll: ★★★
Lara Croft: Tomb Raider
- 2-Movie Collection
Re-released on 4K Blu-ray to coincide with the recent
resurrection of the Tomb Raider franchise, these two
Angelina Jolie vehicles both fit equally well into the
'better than your average game-based film but
still rather forgettable 1 box. Neither is a giant of
the action-adventure genre, and while Jolie has the
onscreen charisma the character demands, the plots
for both movies have all the finesse and intrigue of...
well, something based on a computer game.
Picture: For this 4K upgrade, Paramount delivers i
HDR10 and Dolby Vision encodes of both titles.
It's just a shame neither looks consistently
brilliant in either iteration.
2001's Lara Croft: Tomb Raider is the
most frustrating in this regard. Some shots
(especially daylight exteriors and contrast-
rich close-ups) are breathtakingly good, with
scads of detail, while others are soft and
slightly grubby.
The cautious addition of HDR and wide
colour to Simon West's original also leaves
the imagery looking very natural; more so
than Jan de Bont's 2003 sequel, which
enjoys a slightly more aggressive HDR
facelift. The baseline brightness level on
the follow-up is comfortably higher, and
peak highlights such as the reflections in
Lara's eyes are more intense than pretty
much anything in the first film's transfer.
There's a far less grainy look to the sequel's
imagery too, suggesting that we're viewing an
upscale of the 2K digital intermediate it received
on its cinematic release. This more consistent 'finish'
is welcome - but there are also areas where the
second movie's transfer is worse than the first.
The image generally feels softer and there aren't
any moments where this 4K presentation suddenly
takes your breath away. Colours sometimes look
a little forced, too - although the Dolby Vision
version finds a better balance, while delivering
more subtle light information in dark scenes.
It's especially effective in injecting extra
contrast during the film's climax.
Audio: These 4K platters forgo remixed Dolby
Atmos or DTS:X tracks in favour of DTS-HD
Master Audio 5.1 efforts. Both are pretty
decent, with a dynamic delivery, good
levels of clarity and a fair amount of
detail. Yet the first has a harshness to it,
and neither give your subwoofer the sort
of work-out you might expect with such
action-oriented films.
Extras: The only extras included on the
two UHD discs are commentaries from
the relevant directors. The remainder
of the archival extras for Lara Croft: Tomb
Raider can be found on the accompanying
1080p platter, but those for sequel ...Cradie
of Life are nowhere to be found - which
may leave die-hard fans wanting to import
the US version instead.
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
PLAYBACK 103
The Avengers:
Tunnel ofFear
Studiocanal-»R2 DVD
£18
A lot has been written
about lost episodes of
Doctor Who, but there
are plenty of other TV
shows that only exist
in an incomplete form. This DVD release
of a rediscovered episode of The Avengers
brings the tally of complete episodes
from its first series up to three - and
while Tunnel ofFear is hardly a lost classic,
it offers a revealing look at the show's
original incarnation and how removed it is
from the version we know so well. As well
as the 52-minute episode, the DVD also
houses interviews, reconstructions and
a 2016 audio adaptation of the story.
★★★★★
JoJo's Bizarre
Adventure: Season 1
Manga Entertainment -* Region B BD
£40
This insanely popular
anime series lives up to
its name with a nutty
multi-generational tale
of the Joestar family
and their fight against the vampiric forces
unleashed by an ancient stone mask. This
three-disc Blu-ray set collects the first two
story arcs - Phantom Blood and Battle
Tendency - across 26 episodes of crazy
characters, violence and shouting (trust
us: it's a lot more enjoyable than it
sounds). The set's colourful 1.78:11080p
encodes are partnered by raucous LPCM
2.0 mixes - just do yourself a favour and
steer clear of the terrible US dubs.
★★★★★
Blood Harvest
88 Films All-region BD
£12
Tiny Tim (of Tiptoe
Through the Tulips
fame) stars in this
low-budget slasher
curio from 1987. There's
an odd atmosphere to Blood Harvest
that makes it strangely compelling,
despite the awful acting and clunky
plotting. Heavily cut by the BBFC when
originally released, this Blu-ray presents
the film in its full gory glory via a
gloriously grainy HD transfer of the
director's 'original 16mm vault elements'.
Extras include behind-the-scenes
footage and a lengthy home movie
of Tiny Tim performing with the Great
American Circus in 1987.
★★★
Slaughterhouse Rock
88 Films -> Region BBD
£12
A young man drags
his friends to Alcatraz
after being tormented
by nightmares linked
to the prison island.
There he teams up with the ghost of a
rock star (played by Toni Basil) to stop
the demon who has possessed his
brother. As wonderfully daft as this
sounds, Slaughterhouse Rock ends up
less than the sum of its parts. However,
if you're in the mood for a spot of dumb
late '80s horror, then this Blu-ray's 1.78:1
1080p encode does the best it can with
the film's gloomy visuals, while the LPCM
2.0 audio sounds rather good with the
Devo-tastic soundtrack.
★★★★★
A celebration of saints and sinners
The BFI shines a light on the early films of Derek Jarman with this handsome new boxset
Fans of avant-garde cinema will find it hard to resist
this boxset collecting together the first six feature
films by uncompromising British artist, filmmaker
and activist Derek Jarman.
Recounting the tale of St. Sebastian's martyrdom,
Jarman's debut feature Sebastiane (1976) shocked
audiences with its explicit homosexuality and
violence. Joining it on the first platter is In the Shadow
of the Sun (1981), a non-narrative tapestry of
repurposed early '70s Super 8 home movies,
all set to a soundtrack by Throbbing Gristle.
The remaining four films each get a Blu-ray
disc to themselves. Featuring a young Adam
Ant and Toyah Wilcox, punk classic Jubilee
(1978) finds Queen Elizabeth I and occultist
John Dee visiting the shattered Britain of the
1970s. Meanwhile, Shakespeare gets the punk
treatment in Jarman's take on The Tempest (1979).
The Angelic Conversation (1985) is another of his
non-narrative visual collages, this time with Judi
Dench reading Shakespearean sonnets over the top.
Finally, Caravaggio (1986) features Nigel Terry, Dexter
Fletcher, Sean Bean and Tilda Swinton in a (wilfully
anachronistic) fictionalised re-telling of the life of
the 16th Century painter.
Picture: All six features have been newly scanned
and restored in 2K from original film elements for this
release - although the actual quality of the 1080p
presentations varies significantly depending on the
source materials. Shot on 35mm and framed at
1.85:1, the real standout here is Caravaggio.
Sebastiane, Jubilee and The Tempest also
hold up very well, although their 16mm
origins naturally result in a much coarser
and more prevalent grain structure. Despite being
sourced from 16mm and 35mm materials
respectively, In the Shadow of the Sun and The
Angelic Conversation are at the mercy of the
distressed, lower-res source material.
Audio: All the films in the set bar one are graced by
modest LPCM mono soundtracks. The Angelic
Conversation breaks from this with a surprisingly
dynamic LPCM stereo track that serves as a fun
counterpoint to the unusual visuals.
Extras: The BFI has collected a fine array of features
including new and archival interviews; a selection of
short films; film-specific image galleries; trailers;
and even a look at two unfilmed Jarman projects.
Rounding out the package is an exclusive 80-page
book of writing about the movies.
Tarman: Volume One
1972-1986
HCC VERDICT
Jarman: Volume One
1972-1986
E BFI Region B BD
£70
J The BFI celebrates a unique
filmmaker in style with this packed
boxset. Roll on Volume Two...
Movie:
Picture,
Audio:
Extras:
★★tH
★★★
★★★★★
11:
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
104 BLADE OF THE IMMORTAL/LEGEND OF THE MOUNTAIN
Prolific director hits the big 100
Miike Takashi shows no signs of slowing down with this slice of samurai cinema
Blade of the Immortal
When his sister is killed by a gang of 100 men seeking
the bounty on his head, rogue samurai Manji (Kimura
Takuya) slays them all, but is mortally wounded in
the process. As he lies dying, Manji is visited by a
mysterious old woman who infects him with 'blood
worms' that repair his injuries - and in the process
condemn him to everlasting life. Five decades later
the reclusive Manji is tracked down by Rin (Sugisaki
Hana), a young girl who seeks his help in killing the
group of samurai who murdered her father.
Touted as director Miike Takashi's 100th film (the
actual number is very tricky to gauge), Blade of the
Immortal finds him teaming up with producer Jeremy
Thomas for a third samurai film - this time based on
a popular manga series. It doesn't reach the same
heights as 2010's sublime 13 Assassins, but is still
a magnificent action movie.
Book-ended by audacious fight scenes that pit its
hero against hordes of enemies, the bulk of the film
essentially boils down to a series of one-on-one
scraps between Manji and increasingly grotesque
foes. This episodic structure is its biggest failing,
but has no doubt been inherited from the source
material. Even so, the ensuing swordplay is
exhilarating - and when the film draws all of its
various threads together, it throws in an extra twist
or two, making you reassess your opinions of key
characters in unexpected ways.
Sombre yet exciting, thoughtful yet action-
packed, Blade of the Immortal is another triumph for
one of Japan's most exciting filmmakers. Here's to
his next 100...
Picture: Blade of the Immortal hacks and slashes
its way onto Blu-ray with a sharply-rendered 2.40:1
1080p encode. Following the black-and-white
opening sequence, it transitions to colour and fills
the screen with richly-saturated primaries
(particularly reds). Clarity is also excellent, revealing
finely wrought environmental textures and intricate
details in costume fabrics.
Audio: A DTS-HD MA 5.1 mix serves up plenty of
zippy effects during the big fights, but is otherwise
a fairly front-heavy affair that prefers to use the
surrounds for more subtle, ambient effects.
Music and dialogue are both rendered flawlessly.
Extras: An impressive array of extras from Arrow
Video. There's an interview with the director; a
commentary by critic Tom Mes; two featurettes
about shooting the opening and closing fights;
85-minutes of cast interviews; the trailer; a stills
gallery; and a booklet of essays.
Hard to believe this film comes from
the director responsible for Visitor Q
Legend of the Mountain
Eureka! The Masters of Cinema Series
Region B BD& R2 DVD £18
A young scholar tasked with
translating a Buddhist sutra
finds himself the target for
ghostly forces in King Hu's 1979
supernatural masterpiece.
Finally available to own in
its original 192-minute cut, Legend of the Mountain has been
newly restored in 4K from a first-generation interpositive for
this Blu-ray release and the 2.40:1 Full HD encode offers a
beautiful rendering of the films' atmospheric photography -
although a frequent teal-bias results in some rather milky-
looking blacks. Informative extras include two video essays
about the movie and its director, plus a 32-page booklet.
★ ★★★★
One-Armed
Swordsman
88Films- RegionBBD
£15
A landmark release in
the history of Chinese
cinema, the box office
success of this 1969
Shaw Brothers film
ushered in a new, more violent and
bloody style of wuxia swordplay movies.
Despite issues revolving around colour
registration and clarity (not all of which
are source-related), the 2.35:l-framed
1080p presentation offered up by this UK
Blu-ray is watchable and on a par with
FID incarnations of similar films of this
vintage. A commentary by Bey Logan and
a chat with genre buff David West make
for worthwhile extras.
★★★
The Final Master
Cine Asia Region BBD
£18
The power struggle
for control of the
martial arts schools
in the city of Tianjin
during the 1930s is
turned into something altogether more
confusing in director Xu Haofeng's
needlessly muddled period thriller.
Still, as baffling as the film may get
at times, its fight scenes are never less
than gripping and will ensure you stick
with it. This Blu-ray not only delivers a
kick-ass 2.40:1 Full HD encode, but unlike
the same label's earlier Wolf Warrior II
Blu-ray (reviewed in HCC #283) it
serves up a lossless (DTS-HD MA) 5.1
Mandarin soundtrack.
★★★★★
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
(i t v HomE dNEnm
Let's Get Technical...
Wisdom P4i Wisdom L2 Cinema
In-ceiling speakers. surround speakers-
We have eight There are four in our
in our Cinema Cinema showroom
showroom.
Datasat RA7300 power amplifier
Lumagen RadiancePro UltraHD Video Processor
Datasat RS20i audio processor
During our days of operating Commercial Cinemas
we desired to present films in the best way possible
choosing the best 35mm/70mm projectors with top
quality anamorphic and backing lenses.
On the sound front we went with Dolby Stereo, together
with surround speakers as all other formats had fallen
out of favour.
So today, again we seek to create the best cinema
environment with the latest 'laser' 4K projection; top
of the range sound speakers and processing.
As before, we boost the surround system with better
quality speakers, but advances in speaker technology
take this to a whole new level.
The result is magnificent, adding to the latest cinema
releases with Directors embracing greater use of the
surround facilities and now with 3D overhead sound
included.
To experience the magnificence of these new wonders
ring us for an appointment.
DIGITAL SOUND Hollywood's home cinema
WISDOM'
Sound processor for the true 4K
audio experience. Top quality sound,
as you have never heard it before.
The world's first 4K laser.
Projecting your images in perfect
colour and stunning brightness
4K Video Processor. Rendering and
'upscaling' to give the very best
possible image.
For cinema and music sound.
Simply the world's best sound
No multiplex can compete.
City Home Cinemas, 750 Sidcup Road,
London SE9 3NS. Tel: 020 8860 9363
(ITV IME (MEM
Email: info@cityhomecinemas. co.uk
www.cityhomecinemas.co.uk
106
est Picture winners
With the Oscar-winning The Shape of Water now available to import on 4K Blu-ray, Team HCC
rounds up 20 other movies that have grabbed the top prize at the Academy Awards...
Ben-Hur
Charlton Heston stars in this 1959
Biblical epic about a Jewish prince
who is betrayed by a childhood
friend and sent to work as a slave
on a Roman galley, only to escape
and return home with revenge on
his mind. Culminating in a jaw-
dropping chariot race, Ben-Hur
is one of the grandest, most
spectacular films ever made.
Get it: The 'Ultimate Collector's
Edition' released in the US in 2011
partners the same all-region BD
available in other territories with
an art book and a reproduction of
Heston's journal from the shoot.
Midnight Cowboy
The only film with an 'X' rating to
ever win the Best Picture Oscar,
1969's Midnight Cowboy tells the
story of a naive wannabe cowboy
(Jon Voight) who ends up turning
tricks in New York City and the
friendship he strikes up with an
ailing con-man (Dustin Hoffman).
A difficult but fascinating watch,
and one of the key parts in the
development of the New Wave
cinema that would come to the
fore in Hollywood in the 1970s.
Get it: A new 4K restoration of the
film makes its UK Blu-ray debut
on May 28, courtesy of Criterion.
The Bridge on the
River Kwai
Alec Guinness, William Holden
and Jack Hawkins star in this
1957 WWII drama about British
prisoners of war forced to build
a railway bridge across the river
Kwai by their Japanese captors.
What follows is a gripping clash
of principles and discipline,
realised by undisputed
master of the bigscreen
epic, David Lean. .
i
Get it: Sony's Ultra
HD BD looks great
and packs remixed
Atmos audio.
No Country for
Old Men
Having almost done it with Fargo
in 1997, filmmaking siblings Joel
and Ethan Coen finally nabbed
the Best Picture award 11 years
later with this nihilistic, noir-tinged
neo-Western based on the novel
of the same name by
Cormac McCarthy.
Get it: Disney's Region
A-locked US Collector's
Edition has the most
extras, but if that's
not an option then the
UK disc still looks and
sounds superb.
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
PLAYBACK EXTRA 107
Lawrence of
Arabia
The second film directed by David
Lean to make this list, this sweeping
1962 T.E. Lawrence biopic explores
his experiences fighting a guerilla
war in the Arabian Peninsula during
WWI and the psychological toll
it took on him. Beautifully directed
by Lean and boasting a career-
best performance from Peter
O'Toole in the title role, Lawrence of
Arabia is moviemaking at its most
epic - and yet the film never loses
sight of the humanity at the core
of its story.
Get it: Sourced from an 8K scan/
4K intermediate, Sony Pictures'
50th Anniversary Edition Blu-ray
is undoubtedly the best version
available right now (and can be
yours for less than £10 these days).
But can a 4K Blu-ray release be too
far off? We hope not.
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
The Sting
In 1973, four years after headlining
Butch Cassidy and The Sundance
Kid, Paul Newman and Robert
Redford reunited with director
George Roy Hill for this frothy con
artist thriller, hoodwinking Robert
Shaw's mob boss - and the
audience - as they set about
making off with $500,000.
An intricate plot, evocative period
setting and fabulous soundtrack
(featuring Scott Joplin's rag-time
classic The Entertainer) make it
a pitch-perfect movie.
Get it: Universal's Blu-ray, now
available for under £10, offers
a pleasing DTS-HD 5.1 mix and
so-so image quality.
Casablanca
Arguably the greatest love story
ever committed to the silver
screen, Michael Curtiz's 1952
masterpiece is one of those
movies that you can put on at
any time and get sucked into
watching all the way through
again. As the famous misquote
goes, 'Play it again, Sam... 1
Get it: The HMV-exclusive
Premium Collection BD supports
its stunning 4K restoration with
countless bonus bits. If that's not
extravagant enough, you could
import the US 70th Anniversary
Gift Set, which includes coasters
and a faux-leather keepsake box.
Get it: Based on a 4K restoration,
the Criterion Collection Blu-ray
is the definitive version.
Titanic
James Cameron's 1997 box office
sensation retells the story of the
sinking of the R.M.S. Titanic from
the point of view of two young
lovers from very different social
backgrounds - Leonardo
DiCaprio's penniless artist Jack
and Kate Winslet's posh totty
Rose. As ghastly as that sounds,
Cameron comes good with his
staging of the disaster itself,
which pulls out all of the stops
to immerse you in the chaos.
Get it: Pick up Fox's four-disc 3D
Collector's Edition for the chance
to savour the film's surprisingly
effective stereoscopic conversion,
along with a boat-load of extras.
It Happened
One Night
Clark Gable and Claudette Colbert
star in this 1934 precursor to the
screwball comedy from director
Frank Capra. Colbert plays a spoilt
socialite on the run from her
disapproving father and Gable the
out-of-work reporter who sees
a juicy story in helping reunite her
with her husband. Quick-witted
and fast-moving, it was the first
film to ever win the 'Big Five'
Oscars (Picture, Director, Actor,
Actress and Writing) - a feat
matched by only two others.
108
Wings
From breathtaking aerial stunts to
the romantic rivalry that forms the
heart of its story, this 1927 silent film
about two World War I flying aces
- whose friendship is threatened by
their love of the same woman - has
something for everyone. Wings is
also notable for being the first ever
recipient of the Academy Award for
Best Picture - and more recently
director Rian Johnson referenced
a famous dolly shot from the movie
in the Canto Bight casino city scene
in The Last Jed /.
Get it: Some prints of the film were
released into cinemas in 1927 with
a synchronised soundtrack of music
and sound effects. A DTS-HD HR 5.1
recreation of that track, overseen
by legendary sound designer Ben
Burtt, is just one of the highlights
of the film's superb Masters of
Cinema Series UK Blu-ray.
The Lord of
the Rings:
The Return of
the King
There's a sense that the Academy
was rewarding Peter Jackson's
entire Tolkien project when it
celebrated this fantasy epic in
2003 - it's not the best of the
trilogy and is in need of a tighter
edit. Still, this remains a prime
slice of big-budget filmmaking.
Get it: With the Extended Edition
trilogy Blu-ray boxset now
deleted, you may as well invest in
the 30-disc Extended Hobbit/LotR
megabox and set aside an entire
weekend to digest it all.
The Sound of
Music
With its unforgettable mixture
of nuns and Nazis set to some of
musical writing team Rogers and
Hammerstein's very best work,
it's no surprise that The Sound
of Music is one of the best-loved
Hollywood musicals of all time.
Get it: Fans should hunt for a
copy of the 'Limited Collector's
Set' that hit the US back in 2010.
On top of the same beautifully
restored Blu-ray that is available
on these shores, it adds the CD
soundtrack, a reproduction 1965
souvenir programme, a 100-page
scrapbook and a 'My Favourite
Things' music box.
Platoon
The most visceral part of Oliver
Stone's Vietnam war trilogy, this
1986 drama witnesses the horror
and idiocy of the US ground war
through the eyes of Chris (Charlie
Sheen), a young grunt caught
between rival factions in his
platoon. Uncomfortably brutal
at times, but Stone is on a mission
here, and his impressive ensemble
cast and rich imagery leave you
in no doubt as to what it is.
Get it: Platoon was given a 25th
anniversary Blu-ray release in
2011 - and the best news is that
it ported over a wealth of extras
(including Stone's commentary
track) from previous DVD editions.
The Apartment
Billy Wilder's brilliant 1960
dramedy sees low-level
insurance clerk C.C. 'Bud' Baxter
(Jack Lemmon) letting company
executives use his apartment
to carry out their extramarital
affairs, in the hope it well net him
a promotion. But things become
tricky when Baxter falls for
an elevator operator (Shirley
MacLaine) who, unbeknownst to
him, is one of his bosses' lovers...
Get it: Released at the end of
last year, Arrow Video's Limited
Edition Blu-ray boasts a new
restoration and a superb
collection of extras.
Have we left out one of your favourite Best Picture winners?
Let us know: email letters@homecinemachoice.com
PLAYBACK EXTRA 109
The Godfather/
The Godfather Part II
Crowned Best Picture in 1972 and 1974, this mafia
crime duo is best watched as one lengthy, lavish
masterpiece. Marlon Brando, Al Pacino, John Cazale,
James Caan and Robert De Niro deliver towering
performances, but it's the script here that the's real
winner, mixing complex plotlines across the decades
with personal drama and moments of brutal violence.
Get it: No 4K release yet (but it is available in UHD
on digital platforms), so stick to the Blu-ray boxset.
On the
Waterfront
Marlon Brando gave one of the
most electrifying performances
of his career in this powerful and
uncompromising 1954 critique of
union corruption set around the
New York City docks.
Gladiator
Ridley Scott rebooted his career
(and the historical epic genre) in
2000 with this gripping, muscular
drama. Russell Crowe excels as
the Roman soldier-turned-slave
with vengeance on his mind.
Get it: Universal's 2009 BD
debut for Gladiator was a
travesty of obvious edge
enhancement and digital
smoothing, a situation rectified
by a re-release a year later.
Coming this April is an Ultra
HD platter that hopefully
won't open a whole new can
of picture quality worms.
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
Get it: With its solid AV
credentials, the Sony Pictures
UK Blu-ray coulda been
a contender, but falls short
of the Region A-locked
Criterion disc, which
offers a choice of three
aspect ratios and extra
bonus features.
Gone with the
Wind
Another cinematic 'epic' - this
1939 Civil War era romance/drama
runs for nearly four hours - and
the highest-earning flick ever at
the box office once inflation is
taken into account. Everyone
should watch it at least once.
Get it: Warner created a new
master from an 8K scan for a 70th
Anniversary BD release in 2009
- and this was used again for the
current (2014) release. Heaps of
extras on the two-disc UK BD,
but you'll find even more on the
four-disc US version.
The French
Connection
William Friedkin gave the police
thriller a shot of adrenaline with
this relentless (and ultimately
extremely influential) 1971 drama
about tough-as-nails narcotics
detectives, played by Gene
Hackman and Roy Scheider,
tracking a French drug smuggler
on the mean streets of New York.
Get it: It may have been approved
by the director, but the revisionist
look of Fox's initial Blu-ray was
downright weird. A 'remastered'
(ie: corrected) version was finally
issued as a UK steelbook in 2014.
lip
Samsung gi£D tV ii big, brle+u and beautiful
MMP
Htimaji's, tnplfi-tuneu- PVR wilt change
the wav you watch TVf
™ fg*. -
Why tfiE IBQln ZM Is the world's biggest, best HtJfi display
it/a Haabo-FILV
Optoma's UHDftS
flrd|E?£ldr gets 1 he
best from Blu-ray
Demurs
bist mu
TtM ull-Wnle tXirfie Clftomai
nartfMrtf*, Includinj:
■ * f- HDO TVs ■ Rmeetara
■ i- 7 -i jwdtars ■ Speakers
■ l^llJ wpliwn
■ PVfisB AVracohnin
■ AEfimnme:. ■ And rrore!
rwood loves C LED
AVTech
media ltd
Please note that we cannot guarantee the availability of all issuestffsplayed above.
rSSffiii 5 im m
; 2 p? ‘
tm
HI
sgnj
JJL 1
3£
A rill
' ill
£ 3 «i
mum**
. rjpjiiy*'
cssnv
fclJJjJUaLJiiJl
Ejijl
Till
i! hi
HI
RLMATvl
i
>«
i. ■
mm
”[■]
yi
jji
IE
33
■T
yl
fil
EE
mi
1
JTw
11J j
WWW.HOMECINEMACHOICE.COM
SELECT
-►Gear Guide TELEVISIONS From entry-level 40in LEDs to flagship 4K monsters
BLU-RAY PLAYERS Which deck rules the roost? PROJECTORS It's time to blow up your video!
AV RECEIVERS 5.1,7.1,11.2 - we've got all the options covered SPEAKERS Killer surround sound setups
for all rooms and budgets PVRs Including super-slim Freeview boxes and Sky 0 AND MORE!
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
GEAR GUIDE
TOP 10 Televisions
Sony KD-65ZD9** £3,000 ★★★★★
Sony finished 2016 on a high with this full-array LED Bravia
(with advanced local dimming tech) that claims a 1,800-nit
peak brightness and DV support. Cinematic, sublime pictures
- the lOOin version [HCC #282] is even more impressive. hcc#267
Sony KD-55A1 ->£2,800 ★★★★★
Another Sony set due a Dolby Vision upgrade, this 55in OLED
dazzles with its image quality (including superb motion
processing), hidden Acoustic Surface speaker technology
and eye-catching styling. hcc#275
LG OLED65E7
■*£3,800 ★★★★★
3D playback is dropped,
but the E7 offers welcome
picture improvements
over last year's E6,
particularly brightness
and near-black talents.
Supports Dolby Vision.
HCC #274
Panasonic TX-55EZ952
■*£ 2,000 ★★★★★
A 55in OLED TV with an
effortlessly naturalistic
performance, although not
as bright as some rivals.
Gorgeous, understated
design and premium
build quality.
HCC #277
Philips 55POS9002
■*£ 2,000 ★★★★★
Philips' second-gen Android-
powered OLED takes a more
refined approach to its
processing, focusing on
balanced cinematic imagery.
Ambilight, as usual, boosts
your immersion.
HCC #276
Samsung UE49MU7000
■*£750 ★★★★★
Not one of Samsung's
top-flight TVs, but a cracking
mid-range 49in model that
presents 4K and HD material
with bright, rich colours and
stable blacks. Good choice
for an affordable setup.
HCC #277
Samsung QE65Q9F
£3,500 ★★★★★
Sony KD-55XE8596
£900 ★★★★★
This premium 'QLED' screen
outguns rivals when it comes
to brightness and visual
impact. Routinely stunning,
but edge LED lighting has
some niggles. Supports
Samsung's HDR10+ format.
HCC #273
A real 4K bargain, combining
a 55in screen with a solid
picture performance. HDR
doesn't zing due to a lack of
sheer brightness, but it
benefits from backlight
stability. Impressive with
regular HD, too. hcc#278
Panasonic TX-65EX750
-►£1,500 ★★★★★
A (surprise!) 3D-capable
LED screen that offers
well-controlled backlighting,
pleasing 4K clarity and good
HD upscaling. Not the
brightest around, and some
colour inconsistencies.
HCC #279
LG 55SJ850V
-►£900 ★★★★★
Backlight distractions hinder
this set's performance in
low-lit rooms, but it's a
strong all-rounder, offering
Dolby Vision HDR, WebOS
smarts, well-rounded sonics
and a bargain price tag.
HCC #276
Blade Runner 2049
[Ultra HD Blu-ray]
A smart, evocative sequel that
proves worth the wait, and
blessed on Warner's US 4K
platter with a pin-sharp image
and spine-tingling Dolby Atmos
soundmix. HCC #283
★★★★★
Death of Stalin
More superb political satire from
Armando 'In The Loop' lannucci.
Entertainment One's BD may
be light on extras, but the chat-
track is well worth a listen, and
DTS-HD 5.1 audio works well with
the source material. HCC #283
★★★★★
Only the Brave
Josh Brolin stars in this powerful
drama about wildfire-fighters in
the American southwest, which
burns bright on BD courtesy of
an excellent 1080p image and
even more impressive DTS-HD
MA5.1 track. HCC #284
★★★★★
Paddington 2 [Ultra HD
Blu-ray]
A sequel that's better than its
forebear (if you pardon the pun),
Paddington 2 is sweet, funny and
its 4K HDR presentation shows
a clear improvement over its SDR
counterpart. HCC #283
★★★★★
Coco [Ultra HD Blu-ray]
Pixar returns to form with this
quirky tale of a boy trapped in
the Land of the Dead. The Atmos
track isn't a standout effort, but
the 4K visuals on this US import
are gorgeous, and there are some
fun extras. HCC #284
★★★★★
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
SELECT
TOP 70 Blu-rays
Oppo UDP-203 ->£650 ★★★★★
Oppo refreshes its player hardware with a superb universal
design with Ultra HD playback (including Dolby Vision via
firmware update). Packed with user adjustments and
connectivity. No apps or Darbee processing, though. hcc#269
Sony UBP-X800
■*£270 ★★★★★
Sony embraces UHD Blu-ray
with a full-width, sturdy
design that'll also spin
DVD-A and SACD platters.
A great all-rounder, but no
current Dolby Vision support
or word on an update.
HCC #274
Panasonic DMP-UB900
->£370 ★★★★★
The Ultra HD Blu-ray format
got an inspiring debut in
Panasonic's multi-talented
deck that offers a sterling
picture performance,
4K-enabled VOD apps and
analogue audio outs. No DV.
HCC #259
Oppo UDP-205-* £1,400 ★★★★★
This pricey, peerless UHD deck flaunts universal disc playback,
asynchronous USB input, headphone amp and balanced stereo
outs amongst its audiophile features. One for musos.
HCC #274
Cambridge Audio CXUHD
£800 ★★★★★
Sony UBP-X700
■*£250 ★★★★★
A compact player promised
a DV update this Summer,
the UBP-X700 has a
nondescript design, no
analogue outs and a stubby
remote. But it plays great,
and offers SACD support.
HCC #284
The lack of analogue outputs
is a surprise considering CA's
heritage, but this universal
(and DV-capable) deck
sounds sweet over its digital
outs. As with Oppo's UDP-
203, a MediaTek SoC is used.
HCC #279
Panasonic DMP-UB700
-►£300 ★★★★★
Shorn of some of the
audiophile niceties of
the UB900 (including
multichannel analogue
outputs), but still a safe pair
of hands with your 4K BDs.
And at a bargain price.
HCC #270
Panasonic DMP-UB300
-►£130 ★★★★★
Great 4K imagery from this
bargain deck, but you might
prefer to up your budget for
the UB700 - no split HDMI,
optical/coaxial or Wi-Fi
connections here. Half-size
design for an easy install.
HCC #272
Samsung UBD-K8500
-►£180 ★★★★★
Debut Ultra HD Blu-ray player
that finds fans courtesy of its
sensible price point (now
even lower), connected
smarts and eye-catching
visuals. Build quality is a
little uninspiring.
HCC #260
Samsung UBD-M9500
-►£230 ★★★★★
Second-gen 4K player that
adds features (mobile BD
streaming, 360-degree
image support) but removes
3D playback capability. As
before, the chassis is curved.
UHD discs look pin-sharp.
HCC #275
Fibre Optic Lighting
CED!A MEMBER
* Infinity - modular star ceiling panels for
professional installers
* Custom and off-the-shelf DIY fibre optic kits
* Room accent lighting from a single light source
* Comprehensive website with projects and ideas.
Help and advice from our small team of fibre optic enthusiasts
info@starscape.co.uk www.starscape.co.uk 01289 332900
GEAR GUIDE
TOP 70 Projectors
Sony VPL-VW760ES £15,000 ★★★★★
This premium beamer adds laser illumination to Sony's 4K
SXRD projection technology, and the results are staggering.
It's not super-bright, but images are detailed, vivid and
supremely well-balanced. Worthy of flagship status, hcc #283
JVC DLA-X5900 -*£4,000 ★★★★★
An outstanding performer at this price point. JVC's latest D-ILA
model may lack native 4K silicon but its eShift 4K engine shows
real improvement and HDR playback has been greatly boosted
too. A compelling home cinema PJ. hcc #282
Sony VPL-VW360ES
■*£7,000 ★★★★★
In Sony's 4K range between
the laser-based VW760ES
and entry-level 260ES you'll
find this accomplished
beamer. Excellent imagery
with both SDR and HDR.
Motorised controls.
HCC #284
Epson EH-TW6700
£1,300 ★★★★★
HDR and 4K scaling are
off the menu, leaving this
mid-range model to
concentrate on cinematic
HD images. Bright, crisp
performance, plenty of
tweaks, but no 12V trigger.
HCC #271
Optoma UHD60
-* £2,400 ★★★★★
An assured Ultra HD debut
from Optoma - the UHD60
presents 4K Blu-rays with a
pleasing contrast balance
and lush detail. SDR-HDR
conversion tool is best
avoided, though.
HCC #277
Sony VPL-VW260ES
-*£5,200 ★★★★★
Sony's base-level 4K PJ
comes with a few strings
attached (brightness and
colour range are limited),
but it's a tempter for anyone
speccing a UHD theatre.
HCC #280
Optoma UHZ65
-*£5,000 ★★★★★
The asking price here reflects
Optoma's addition of laser
illumination (yielding
improved contrast and far
greater 'lamp' life) to the
DLP 4K and HDR playback
talents of its stablemates.
HCC #282
Epson EH-TW7300
-►£ 2,200 ★★★★★
Similar performance traits
to its bigger EH-TW9300
sibling, but with reductions in
max brightness (and claimed
contrast). 4K upscaler, rather
than native, with HDR
playback, hcc #269
Acer VL7860
£3,500 ★★★★★
Laser 4K DLP projector that
misses out on the contrast
performance of some
models, but undercuts them
in terms of pricing. Use the
Silent mode for whisper-
quiet operation.
HCC #284
BenQ W1050
-►£500 ★★★★★
There are a few cut corners
on this budget DLP 1080p
model (no backlight on the
remote, no lens shift, a
meagre zoom), but overall
movie performance is good
for the money.
HCC #283
Award-winning home cinemas
At Cyberhomes our home cinemas and smart home installations aren't just about the amazing
4K picture and immersive Dolby Atmos® sound. We also implement the acoustic treatments,
lighting control, seating, ISF calibration, the intuitive Savant Pro or Control4 control system, and
so much more.
For details visit www.cyberhomes.co.uk/hcc
Cyberhomes
CEDIA
AWARDS
2016
WINNER
Best Home Cinema
over £100,000
MEMBER
Home cinema design and installation • Lighting control systems
Multi-room audio and video • Home automation
0333 344 3718 hello@cyberhomes.co.uk www.cyberhomes.co.uk
SELECT
TOP 70 Speakers
Monitor Audio Gold 300AV -> £7,150 ★★★★★
MA revamps its Gold Series and we pay serious attention. This
big-ticket package excels across the frequency range, offers
exquisite design and packs setup flexibility via the dipole/
monopole FX surrounds. hcc#251
WharfedaleDX-2->£450 ★★★★★
The asking price of this 5.1 system will tell you it doesn't deliver
the last word in surround sound fidelity, but Wharfedale's
package is compact, well-made and faultlessly delivers on its
home-cinema-on-a-budget promise. hcc#283
KEF 0 Series 5.1.2
£3300 ★★★★★
KEF's revamped Q Series
now offers Atmos modules
for an up-to-the-minute
sonic experience. Big, bold¬
looking speakers. Robust,
immersive audio. hcc#280
ATC HTS7 5.1
->£3,500 ★★★★★
Brit brand ATC rejigs the
driver tech and neutral sound
of its SCM range into a
wall-mountable, flexible
system perfect for discreet
AV setups. HCC #275
Monitor Audio Silver 500 5.1
->£3,650 ★★★★★
The new Silver range offers
a potent EQ-able sub, sweet
design, dipole surrounds and
largescale, nuanced sonics.
Atmos upfiring models would
be nice, though. hcc#282
KEF R Series 7.1
->£6,500 ★★★★★
A 7.1 set mixing dipolar and
direct surrounds, this
package takes its cues from
KEF's Blade and offers
faultless, largescale home
cinema sonics. hcc#217
Wharfedale Diamond 11
HCP £800 ★★★★★
Bookshelf speakers and lOin
sub combine in a system that
offers mid-range and treble
finesse and a healthy dollop
of boisterous bass. Fun and
affordable. hcc#279
DALI Opticon 5.1
->£3,200 ★★★★★
The Opticons employ driver
designs from DALI's high-
end models, and showcase
a talent for involving music
presentation and thrilling
home cinema, hcc #260
Q Acoustics 7000i 5.1 Slim
£ 1,000 ★★★★★
Consistent tonality and detail
retrieval are the standout
elements here, joined by a
cute, easy-to-accommodate
design - particularly the
7060S sub. HCC #284
Focal Sib Evo Dolby Atmos
5.1.2 ->£1,200 ★★★★★
Enjoyable-sounding and
well-priced sub/sat system
with Atmos upfirers in front
L/R enclosures. Not the
smallest 'satellite' speakers
around, hcc #276
Fibre Optic Lighting
CEO!A MEMBER
* Infinity - modular star ceiling panels for
professional installers
* Custom and off-the-shelf DIY fibre optic kits
* Room accent lighting from a single light source
* Comprehensive website with projects and ideas.
Help and advice from our small team of fibre optic enthusiasts
info@starscape.co.uk www.starscape.co.uk 01289 332900
116 GEAR GUIDE
TOP 70 AV Receivers/AV Processors
Denon AVR-X6400H *=>£2,100 ★★★★★
This receiver's 11 channels of power are joined by Atmos, DTS:X
and integrated Auro-3D, plus HEOS multiroom integration,
making it peerlessly flexible. Sound delivery is quick-footed
and articulate. A superb one-box solution. hcc#280
ArcamAVR850 ->£4,500 ★★★★★
High-end seven-channel AVR marrying Class G amplification
and Atmos (and future DTS:X) support with talented Dirac
Live Room EQ. 11-channel pre-outs for full-fat setups.
HCC #257
Anthem MRX1120
->£4,000 ★★★★★
Combining Anthem's superb
ARC room EQ system with
11-channel amplification
makes this an essential
consideration for full-spec
Atmos setups. Muscular,
precise sound. But no
networking skills. hcc#265
Pioneer VSX-1131
->£550 ★★★★★
Seven-channel model with
Atmos and DTS:X support
that features an overhauled
remote control and Ul to
improve usability. Bass-rich,
energetic sound.
HCC #265
Marantz NR1608
£600 ★★★★★
With a smoother sound
signature than before and the
addition of HEOS multiroom,
Marantz's 7.1-channel
slim-line AVR flies the flag
for living-room friendly AV.
Only one HDMI out, though.
HCC #278
Marantz SR7012
£1,700 ★★★★★
Nine-channel design (with
11.2 processing) for Atmos,
DTS:X and Auro-3D
configurations. Well-
featured, and solid and
sophisticated in use, but not
an all-out action monster.
HCC #282
Sony STR-DN1080
->£550 ★★★★★
Sony is back in the AVR game
with a first Atmos model that
adds worthy phantom rear
speaker processing to its 5.1.2
sonics. A few Ul niggles don't
take much of the shine off
an impressive budget buy.
HCC #277
Yamaha RX-A860
->£900 ★★★★★
Only seven channels and
hindered by only three HDCP
2.2-enabled HDMI inputs,
but beyond that this flexible
MusicCast AVR proves
a great listen, with plenty
of DSP toys.
HCC #270
Marantz SR8012
->£2,700 ★★★★★
Marantz joins the 11-channel
arms race with an AVR that
benefits from a beefed-up
power stage. As with the
Denon X6400H, format
support includes Auro-3D.
Sophisticated sonics.
HCC #284
Denon HEOS AVR
£800 ★★★★★
Able to run wireless rears/
sub (using HEOS models)
and sporting a display-free
design, this is a five-channel
AVR with a different
approach. One for HEOS
devotees only.
HCC #276
■n ki i±m i±m
mother! The Downward
Spiral
Darren Aronofsky's off-beat
psychological chiller isn't for
everyone, but this doc provides
fascinating insight into the
film's conception, planning
and 16mm capture. HCC #282
★★★★★
Kingsman: Inside the
Golden Circle
A near two-hour doc, split into
nine parts, is perhaps more
than this hit-n-miss sequel
deserves, but there's plenty
of info and insight here into K2's
production. HCC #283
★★★★★
Thor Ragnarok: Director's
Commentary
Taika Waititi delivers an oddball,
frequently hilarious chat track
that fits this movie's anarchic
nature well. A fine solo effort,
albeit with an unexpected
guest star... HCC #284
★★★★★
Impressions: A Journey
Behind the Scenes of
Twin Peaks
Twin Peaks fans can delve deep
into the recent series' production
with this 291-minute fly-on-the-
wall Making of... doc that gets
its own BD platter. HCC #281
★★★★★
You Must Remember This:
The Warner Bros. Story
The 480i image isn't great,
but this 289-minute film
charting WB's rise to the top of
Hollywood is a brilliant addition
to the Casablanca: Premium
Collection BD. HCC #284
★★★★★
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
SELECT
SVS SB-2000 -*£600 ★★★★★
This follow up to the SB-1000 offers immense value for money.
A mid-sized woofer that imbibes Blu-rays with quick, taut and
potent LFE, it's a perfect introduction to what a truly good sub
can accomplish. hcc#233
JL Audio Fathom f212v2
->£6,500 ★★★★★
A second outing for JL's 2 x
12in monster, with an increase
in power (3,600W) and room
EQ improvements among the
changes. Sounds as good as
you'd imagine. hcc#261
Bowers & Wilkins DB1D
->£3,750 ★★★★★
This sequel to the DB1 moves
EQ to an app and changes
driver/amp design. Beautifully
controlled performance with
depth and detail. Gorgeous
bodywork. hcc#277
RELNo.25 ->£6,500
REL celebrates its 25th anniversary in style with this
15in/l,000W premium concoction that exhibits exhilarating
speed and nuance down to serious depths. Big, but beautiful.
HCC #271
SVS SB16-Ultra
->£2,500 ★★★★★
A 16in driver and 1,500W
amp combine to give SVS's
flagship sealed sub real
appeal. Goes low but remains
tight and fast. App-assisted
EQ and operation. hcc#270
RELT7i
->£850 ★★★★★
Easy to house 8in sub (with
lOin passive driver). Decent
LF extension joined by
superb speed. Wireless
transmission via optional
(£200) system. hcc#277
SVS SB-4000
£1,800 ★★★★★
Similar in operation and
styling to the SB16-Ultra
flagship, but smaller and
more affordable. Superior
DSP results in a real sense
of control, hcc #284
BK Electronics P12-300SB-DF
->£475 ★★★★★
Bass heads can get
outrageous value for
money in the shape of BK's
overperforming 12in sub.
A front-firing model is also
offered, hcc #247
GoldenEar SuperSub X
->£1,450 ★★★★★
Four drivers squeezed into
a relatively compact design
and given plenty of push from
a 1.400W amp. Standout
traits are impact and depth.
HCC #272
KEF KubelOb
£600 ★★★★★
The middle option of KEF's
new Kube range packs a lOin
driver, 300W Class D amp
and 56-bit DSP engine
to maintain efficient low-
frequency control. HCC #283
Uncharted: Lost Legacy
The Drake brothers are replaced
by two new heroines in the latest
instalment of Sony's PlayStation
puzzler. The open-world element
hides the relatively short nature
of its story mode; HDR visuals
are stunning. HCC #277
★★★★★
Call of Duty: WWII
Eschewing the more fantastical
elements of recent COD entries
and giving greater emphasis to
tactics and staying alive, this
is a reminder of why the FPS
franchise is so well loved.
Superb sound FX, too. HCC #282
★★★★★
Monster Hunter: World
This series breaks out of its
Nintendo origins to offer PS4/
Xbox One owners varied,
open-world gameplay, plus HDR
and better-than-HD visuals that
can be tailored to your desire.
Monstrous fun. HCC #283
★★★★★
Super Mario Odyssey
Mario returns in this standout
title for Nintendo's Switch
console that endows its
platforming fun with superior
game mechanics, eye-popping
visuals and a foot-tapping score.
A genuine masterpiece. HCC #280
★★★★★
Injustice 2
Brilliant follow up to the 2013
superhero beat-em 'up classic,
letting you dole out a good
kicking to the bad guys while
playing as DC Comics legends.
Advanced resolution via PS4,
plus HDR. HCC #275
★★★★★
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
118 GEAR GUIDE
TOP 10 Accessories
KEF R50 ->£600 ★★★★★
KEF's Dolby Atmos-enabled reflective modules are a smart
choice to beef up a system. Using the company's Uni-Q point
source drivers pays dividends, enabling full-range sonics that
reach deep into your cinema room. First-rate build. hcc#252
Yamaha WX-AD10 -► £150 kkkki
Simple to use, unobtrusive add-on that brings MusicCast
multiroom/hi-res streaming to legacy AV gear via 3.5mm/
phono. Not a bad price - only available in grey, unfortunately.
HCC #274
Amazon Echo Dot
-►£50 ★★★★★
Less impressive as a
standalone speaker than its
larger sibling, but more
affordable. Use its 3.5mm
output and Bluetooth to pair
with third-party kit. Fun Al
experience. A real bargain.
HCC #269
Nvidia Shield Android TV
-►£180 ★★★★★
The Android-based streamer/
gaming box gets a gentle
revamp - same silicon,
neater design, new features
including future support for
Google Assistant. Slick and
easy to use.
HCC #272
Roku Streaming Stick+
-►£70 ★★★★★
If a simple life is your aim,
this content-rich, 4K/
HDR-capable dongle from
the streaming specialist
is your friend. Idiot-proof
interface and control.
Good price.
HCC #282
Amazon Fire TV (2017)
-►£70 ★★★★★
HDR playback has been
added to Amazon's great-
value media streamer,
although the absence of an
Ethernet port does niggle
considering its 4K talents.
Cluttered Ul.
HCC #280
Panasonic SC-GA10
-►£230 ★★★★★
Panasonic partners with
Google Assistant for its
debut smart speaker, and
doesn't forget to focus on
sonic power as well as Al
fun. Pricier than many rivals,
but still appealing.
HCC #284
Apple TV 4K
£180 (32GB) kkkkk
With Apple's iTunes movie
store offering 4K HDR (Dolby
Vision) movies at the same
price as Full HD downloads,
this compact media player
(irritating handset aside) is
sure to tempt.
HCC #284
PSB Imagine XA
-►£350 kkkkk
These two-way Dolby
Atmos-enabled upfiring
speakers are fairly chunky,
but work well at creating a
height layer and the
£350-per-pair ticket makes
them an enticing option.
HCC #264
Xbox One X
-►£450 ★★★★★
The most advanced games
console on the planet dazzles
with its native 4K HDR
gaming chops, but the price
tag is hefty and heavyweight
users may wish it came with
more than 1TB of storage.
HCC #280
H»i4d
Blue Planet II
A fine 4K companion to the
BBC's previous Planet Earth
II, this set delivers seven
episodes of expertly edited and
informative natural history, with
crisp, colour-rich HDR visuals
and immersive audio. HCC #283
★★★★★
The Wonderful Worlds of
Ray Harryhausen: Vol. Two
A trio of vintage flicks in a
sumptuous package from
Indicator. Here it's Mysterious
Island, Jason and The Argonauts
and First Men in the Moon given
the deluxe treatment. HCC #281
★★★★★
Harry Potter: 8-Film
Collection [Ultra HD]
Revised audio mixes accompany
each title in Warner's mega-hit
franchise, and 4K visuals impress,
not least the earlier flicks that
buff up well. No Full HD discs
included, nor extras. HCC #282
★★★★★
Hammer Volume 2:
Criminal Intent
Indicator again raids Hammer's
library to dig up four black-and-
white crime thrillers from the
late '50s/early '60s. Extras
include an alternate cut of 1961's
Cash on Demand. HCC #284
kkkkk
The Deuce: The Complete
First Season
David Simon (The Wire) is the
brains behind this evocative porn
industry drama set in 1970s New
York. This boxset offers quality
AV and a couple of informative
chat tracks. HCC #284
★★★★★
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
SELECT 19
Yamaha YSP-5600SW >£1,900 ★★★★★
With its 46 drivers (including upfirers) this premium 'bar
delivers precisely-steered and immersive audio, even of the
Atmos variety. Potent wireless sub and 4K-capable HDMI
switching sweeten the high-end deal. hcc#254
Canton DM55 ->£330 ★★★★★
Canton's smallest soundbase still delivers big sonic thrills.
Twin woofers underpin clean and crisp mids and highs, and
build quality is first-rate. Doddle to use. Bluetooth built-in.
HCC #260
Samsung HW-K950
->£1,300 ★★★★★
Soundbar with additional
wireless rears and Dolby
Atmos support via four
upfiring drivers. Impressively
largescale performance, good
connectivity. No native DTS
support.
HCC #263
Samsung HW-MS750/
SWA-W700
->£700/£600 ★★★★★
Upfiring drivers on this
premium 'bar, but no Atmos
decoding. Performance still
dazzles, and the optional sub
shows its merits with movie
soundmixes. hcc#278
m
Sony HT-ST5000
£1,500 ★★★★★
High-end Dolby Atmos-
capable soundbar/sub.
Upfirers elevate the
soundstage (but don't
wraparound). Sound quality
overall is excellent, blending
muscle and depth with
musicality. hcc#275
Q Acoustics M3
£300 ★★★★★
A 4in x 6in woofer is tucked
away in the M3's eye-catching
angular chassis, ensuring this
well-priced soundbar has a
full-range performance.
Simple to use. Bluetooth
streaming. hcc#271
DALI KubikOne
£800 ★★★★★
The Danish speaker brand
brings a slice of glamour to
your setup with this stylish
soundbar. No HDMI or digital
decoding but it packs a tight,
lively and nuanced sound.
HCC #269
JBL Bar Studio
->£150 ★★★★★
No subwoofer here, just
a fairly compact stereo
'bar that offers a useful
soundstage-widening
'Surround' mode, HDMI ARC
connectivity, and a decent
performance for the price.
HCC #284
Q Acoustics M2
->£300 ★★★★★
Easily accommodated in/on
AV furniture, and packing
HDMI ARC for a simple
hookup, this BMR-driver/
built-in woofer soundbase
impresses with its energetic
delivery and price. hcc#279
JBL Bar 5.1
->£650 ★★★★★
Switchable been stereo and
5.1 via battery-powered
surround modules, this
HDMI-toting package offers
a cable-free multichannel
solution. A lOin subwoofer
underpins the soundfield.
HCC #283
Charley Varrick
Walter Matthau stars in and Don
Siegel directs this superior 1973
bank robbery thriller, brought
to UK Blu-ray by indie label
Indicator. A great-looking Full FID
transfer and excellent selection
of extras. HCC #283
★★★★★
The Apartment
Plenty of effort has gone into
restoring this Billy Wilder comedy
- the result is a new BD transfer
that looks wonderfully sharp,
well-contrasted and clean,
considering the film's 1960
vintage. HCC #282
★★★★★
Night of the Living Dead
The Criterion Collection pleases
fans of George A. Romero's genre¬
defining 1968 horror with a
labour-of-love two-disc BD
release. Image quality benefits
from a consistent 4K restoration;
extras are plentiful. HCC #283
★★★★★
Suspiria: Limited Edition
Dario Argento's 1977 classic
receives a second UK Blu-ray,
with a new 4K restoration
making amends for the previous
lacklustre effort from 2010.
Plenty of worthwhile extras;
5.1 DTS-HDMA audio. HCC #282
★★★★★
Casablanca: Premium
Collection
A fresh transfer (from a 4K
scan), lossless audio and
some new extras make this
double-disc BD release for the
much-loved war-time romance
an essential purchase. HCC #284
★★★★★
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
www.hifichoice.co.uk
sound and make
your music sino
.OUT "®
THE ESSENTIAL GUIDE
to getting the best possible sound
from your hi-fi, whether you're
buying, tuning or tweaking
Stellar sounds
H Ftevlbto friend
■ ■■■ ■»« ■
pc
'."Tea foe Bowirl
ihoice
I *j Li Lfj-
©«L
• @
® «nr
. ^©lyy
!#■
1 1 * h
twitter.com@HiFiChoiceMag
facebook.com/hifichoice.co.uk
SELECT
lroP5 PVRs
Virgin Media TiVo,
£subscription
This triple-tuner PVR offers
recording flexibility, useful
features - you can undelete
deleted shows! - and smart
TiVo functionality. If you're in
a cable area, consider it
★★★★★
Sky 0, £subscription
Sky's new top-tier product
offering dazzles with its
image-rich user interface,
wireless multiroom skills and
recording flexibility delivered by
the PVR's 12 tuners. Now
supports 4K content
★★★★★
Humax FVP-5000T
Revamped menus, faster
operation and tweaks to its
triple-tuner engine make this the
most advanced Freeview Play
PVR around - and it doubles
admirably as a DLNA player/
media jukebox. 500GB/1TB/2TB
★★★★★
Humax DTR-T4000,
£subscription
This YouView-based PVR is
required to get BT Sport's new
Ultra HD channel - available
to those with BT fast fibre
and a BT TV sub. Easy to use and
with 1TB of storage
★★★★★
EE TV Smart Box
£subscription
This quad-tuner 1TB PVR, from
the mobile/broadband corp,
offers innovative Replay 24-hour
channel recording and great
Smart device streaming.
Needs more catch-up though
★★★★★
TtOP ™ Headphones
Sony MDR-HW700DS,
£800
Comfy cans supplied with
an HDMI surround processor,
enabling multichannel audio to
be fed to a virtual 9.1-channel
soundstage. The effect is superb
- great for late-night listening
★★★★★
Sony MDR-1000X, £360
Superior noise-cancelling cans
with hi-res audio support
via Sony's LDAC wireless
transmission tech. Slick,
touch-sensitive operation and
healthy battery life. Fulsome
sound and comfy to wear
★★★★★
IMore MK802,£150
Ignore the bling-tastic blue or red
finishes and focus on the assured
sound performance from these
well-priced closed-back cans.
Features include wireless
Bluetooth and app control (with
burn-in mode). Great value
★★★★★
Bowers & Wilkins PX, £330
B&W adds noise-cancelling to
the general spec of its previous
P7 wireless cans, a welcome
update for those seeking
uninterrupted listening. Offers a
neutral, balanced sound suited
to both movies and music
★★★★★
Audio Technica ATH-SR9,
£400
45mm drivers and Audio
Technica's Midpoint Mount tech
deliver wide, deep, spacious
sonics. Memory foam padding
aids listener comfort; 3m cable
should suit most AV setups
★★★★★
TOPS Wireless speakers
KEFMuo, £300
Portable Bluetooth speaker
that's a cut above much of the
competition. KEF's sonic
knowhow results in a punchy,
dynamic presentation that
cherishes lossless rips. Excellent
build quality
★★★★★
Sony SRS-X11,£60
An affordable palm-sized
Bluetooth speaker with internal
rechargeable battery, Sony's
SRS-X11 is supremely portable
and sounds decent for the
money. A neat little gizmo. Get
two and they can work in stereo
★★★★★
o Acoustics BT3, £280
Bluetooth stereo pair with
optical input makes a good
alternative to a soundbar
(there's even a subwoofer
pre-out) while remaining a dab
hand at music. Neat and tidy
design, good price
★★★★★
HOME CINEMA
Choice
Simple Audio Listen, £400
Desktop stereo speakers with
Bluetooth support, these benefit
from separate tweeter/m id bass
units and a classy construction.
Performance is well-balanced,
and a subwoofer output is
offered for extra bass
★★★★★
Denon HEOS 5 HS2, £350
The mid-range multiroom
speaker gets a second-gen
revamp, adding welcome
hi-res audio playback and
Bluetooth connectivity.
Gorgeous looks, boisterous,
room-filling sound
★★★★★
-*In the next issue
System selector AV setups for all budgets
Building a boxset Tricks of the Blu-ray trade from
the experts at the BFI
Bye bye 3D? What does the future hold for
stereoscopic home cinema?
-> Reviews
Yamaha RX-A3070 AV receiver Acoustic Energy
100 Series 5.1 Hisense55inU74KTV Bluesound
Pulse soundbar Affordable 4K projector grouptest
PLUS News, software, opinion, comps and more
CONTENTS SUBJECT TO CHANGE - BUT ONLY FOR THE BETTER
MAY 2018 HOME CINEMA CHOICE
AV Avenger
Steve May applauds the cinema owners who are using clever technology to ward
off mobile phone users. Now he's wondering if he should move to France
THESE DAYS, I generally try and avoid going to
the cinema. For one thing it’s too stressful. Any
excitement I feel at the prospect of catching a new
movie (and generally I’m always excited) is mitigated
by the thought of having my theatrical experience
ruined by less-than-respectful cinema goers who are
quite happy to chat, eat, laugh inappropriately and
consult their smartphones as regularly as if they were
outside the local pub.
Sometimes I can enjoy a bigscreen visit -
mid-week in the afternoon when screens become
delightfully empty - but for the most part I prefer
to watch films in my own home cinema. At least here,
family members respect the code. Mobile phone use
warrants a hard stare, and a possible punishment
Pause. I can also watch until the last credits have
rolled, and not be taken out of the moment by
dullards bolting for the exit as if their lives depended
on it at the first sign that the film is finishing.
Another compelling reason to give theatres
a miss is the often shoddy quality of presentation.
From omnipresent house lights, to cleaning staff
who’ll barrel in before the presentation is over, I
frequently leave irritated rather than inspired.
I do actually see a large number of movies in
real cinemas, but more often than not it’s at a media
screening in a well-equipped preview theatre, or
(if I’m really lucky) a special event at Dolby’s joyously
specc'd London PIQ. This means I enjoy all the
benefits of a theatrical viewing, without any of the
pitfalls (apart from when a fellow scribe takes out
a pen and paper to make notes). I am aware that this
isn't an option open to everyone.
We're jammin*
Perhaps there's good news for cinema-goers from
across the Channel. In Paris, some multiplexes have
installed smartphone signal blockers to combat the
disruption caused by punters unable to resist the lure
of Instagram for more than three minutes at a time.
Such jammers work by emitting a signal in the
same frequency band that mobile phones use.
There’s naturally been speculation that turning
theatres into an electromagnetic chamber is in some
way unhealthy, but if it stops an oik texting next to
me I’m all for it.
I reckon this policy should be
mandatory everywhere. Annoying, then,
that it’s actually illegal to use jammers in cinemas
and theatres in many countries. When the owners
of the Savoy picture house in Dublin installed
a mobile phone blocker back in 2003, they were
threatened with a hefty €25,000 fine and even
the prospect of jail by Ireland's communications
regulator. In fact, the Savoy’s initiative was prescient,
recognising the scourge of smartphones before they
even really took hold.
Communications watchdog Ofcom mandates
that mobile phone jammers cannot be used legally in
Britain. Its unhelpful suggestion is that people should
instead be educated to keep their mobiles switched
off instead. I’m not sure of the last time anyone from
Ofcom went to their local multiplex, but educating
the audience seems wistful at best.
France, however, likes to treat movies with
almost religious respect. Vive la France!
Elsewhere, there have even been reports of
phone-weary consumers taking matters into their
own hands by using a portable jammer bought
cheaply online. This, I suppose, is one solution.
Another is to just stay at home and stock up
on Pringles ■
Does your home cinema have any 'house rules'?
Let us know: email letters@homecinemachoice.com
Steve May
4
has now built a
dungeon under his
Jr
home cinema,
where he can throw
anyone who reveals
< '
spoilers halfway
through a movie
Jk. - :
HOME CINEMA CHOICE MAY 2018
ILLUSTRATION: BY TEKURA MAEVA
LG OLED TV™
LG
life's Good
The World's Number One OLED TV Brand
Most Awarded Range of OLED TVs in the UK
Which?
r?- /lofurirts
HIGHLY
RECOMMENDED
AUMLC0 c=s
HIGHLY
RECOMMENDED
znnmim
★★★★★
Stuff
OLED55B7/C7 OLED55B7
JUNE 2017 MAY 2017
OLED65E7 OLED55B7
MAY 2017 JUNE 2017
OLED55B7
JUNE 2017
QLED65E7 / 55C7
MAY / JUNE 2017
Perfect Colour | Perfect Black | Multi HDR with Dolby Vision™ | Dolby Atmos®
Discover more: lg,com/uk/lgo!ed
m DOLBY
VISION * ATMOS
UltraHD
m
DOLBY
VISION
The best-reviewed 4K HDR
players in existence
oppo
%
i m
EISA
AWARD
Best
Product
ia r m j
UNIVERSAL ULTRA HD BLU-RAY PLAYER
OPPO UDP-203
Image quality
(including from
Dolby Vision titles)
is peerless JJ
> m HT*
HIGHLY
RECOMMENDED
simply the best
movie source
available jj
tt You certainly
won't find a better
UHD Blu-ray player
on the market J J
WHAT HI FI?
SOUND AND VISION
WHATHIFI.COM
January 2017
H that sense of awe
you get when
watching 4Kfilms is
worth every penny J J
fc. r. i„
/ / /
u
j
1 Hi
BEST
BUY
image quality
excels jj
UDP-203
RECOMMENDED
it makes 4K
Blu-rays look more
beautiful than
they've ever looked
before JJ
oppo
UDP-205
assn: -j#®
t . r r-7 r.'nr.T
BEBH
inews
OUTSTANDING
product
I*- 'on jm<: |
HIGHLY
RECOMMENDED
0
j j There's a precision
here which is often
astonishing
« No other deck offers quite
so much, or executes it as
well. Its video performance
is fabulous
H An exceptional player that
sets a new benchmark for both
audio and video performance
))
www.oppodigital.co.uk
roon